Albionist Great Britain wrote:Witiland wrote:
so the Jews can have a homeland but not Israel? I can just say oh the Jews already have a homeland Europe or America... and i would make 0 sense. I'm not a Muslim and I used to be pro Israel until I realized what was really going on
*Mic Drop*
Europe nor America are Jewish homelands, Israel is.
America isn't the homeland of modern day Americans with that logic. The Old World is. The Turkish and Slavic homeland is in Asia, the German and Hungarian homeland is somewhere in Russia. Actually, with no definitive cap on how far back you can go, all of Europe (except probably the Basque) can only call the Pontic-Caspian steppe home.
Historically the homeland of a people shifts and changes. Outside of theological reasons, why should the Jews be any different? The Jews have not held Israel in millennia, they have less of a claim on it than the Palestinians who, up until recently, called that land home. Not to say they don't have a claim, but it is weak and outweighed by its more recent long-term inhabitant.