Israel boycott group declared anti-Semitic

[Witiland]

AGB is absolutely right. So is Golda Meir when she famously said there is no such thing as a "Palestinian people".

So everyone must be imagining the non-Israeli people that the Israelis are encroaching on.

What a brain-dead statement.

Its so sad to see people think that Palestine does not deserve a homeland or recognition at least.

[Albionist Great Britain]

If you’re so insistent in this hilariously naïve belief there exists a """Palestinian nation""", then I have your answer: it’s called Jordan. Any Arab that wishes to live in that land is welcome to - as an Israeli. Any Arab that’s angry a few Jews moved back into their own homeland, he can go cry to Allah at this ‘injustice’ ( ) in a Jordanian or ISIL mosque.

So to whom does the west bank and the gaza strip belong

I don’t really care much about those lots, put them under Jordanian and Egyptian administration for all I care or leave them as they are. The United Nations could deal with them but they’re completely braindead. Ideally the land would go to Israel, but the populations would swing the demographics to the point Israel can no longer be the Jewish state.

[Albionist Great Britain]

If you’re so insistent in this hilariously naïve belief there exists a """Palestinian nation""", then I have your answer: it’s called Jordan. Any Arab that wishes to live in that land is welcome to - as an Israeli. Any Arab that’s angry a few Jews moved back into their own homeland, he can go cry to Allah at this ‘injustice’ ( ) in a Jordanian or ISIL mosque.

so the Jews can have a homeland but not Israel? I can just say oh the Jews already have a homeland Europe or America... and i would make 0 sense. I'm not a Muslim and I used to be pro Israel until I realized what was really going on

*Mic Drop*

Europe nor America are Jewish homelands, Israel is.

[Salus Maior]

If you’re so insistent in this hilariously naïve belief there exists a """Palestinian nation""", then I have your answer: it’s called Jordan. Any Arab that wishes to live in that land is welcome to - as an Israeli. Any Arab that’s angry a few Jews moved back into their own homeland, he can go cry to Allah at this ‘injustice’ ( ) in a Jordanian or ISIL mosque.

Not to mix threads together, but couldn't you literally say the same thing about Armenians in Artsakh and the country of Armenia?

I certainly could imagine Hakinda or any other Turk using that argument. "There's no country of "Artsakh", any Armenian who wants to live in the Caucasus can live in Armenia."

For someone who was so incredibly enthusiastic about the Armenian cause in that one thread, you're not very sympathetic about a people that's literally in the same situation, and villainized by the same people (Israel).

[Kubra]

So to whom does the west bank and the gaza strip belong

I don’t really care much about those lots, put them under Jordanian and Egyptian administration for all I care or leave them as they are. The United Nations could deal with them but they’re completely braindead. Ideally the land would go to Israel, but the populations would swing the demographics to the point Israel can no longer be the Jewish state.

So wait a minute if you don't want the territories annexed what does it matter if they're owned by other arab states or organised as their own state called "Palestine"

[Albionist Great Britain]

So everyone must be imagining the non-Israeli people that the Israelis are encroaching on.

What a brain-dead statement.

Its so sad to see people think that Palestine does not deserve a homeland or recognition at least.

Because there isn’t a Palestine.

If you’re so insistent in this hilariously naïve belief there exists a """Palestinian nation""", then I have your answer: it’s called Jordan. Any Arab that wishes to live in that land is welcome to - as an Israeli. Any Arab that’s angry a few Jews moved back into their own homeland, he can go cry to Allah at this ‘injustice’ ( ) in a Jordanian or ISIL mosque.

Not to mix threads together, but couldn't you literally say the same thing about Armenians in Artsakh and the country of Armenia?

I certainly could imagine Hakinda or any other Turk using that argument. "There's no country of "Artsakh", any Armenian who wants to live in the Caucasus can live in Armenia."

For someone who was so incredibly enthusiastic about the Armenian cause in that one thread, you're not very sympathetic about a people that's literally in the same situation, and villainized by the same people (Israel).

Armenians are native to Artsakh. They always have, always will be. The Arabs are not the same in Israel.

[Witiland]

So to whom does the west bank and the gaza strip belong

I don’t really care much about those lots, put them under Jordanian and Egyptian administration for all I care or leave them as they are. The United Nations could deal with them but they’re completely braindead. Ideally the land would go to Israel, but the populations would swing the demographics to the point Israel can no longer be the Jewish state.

AGB I have a question for you. Number one do you think this conflict will ever be resolved? Two what do you think is the best solution?

[Salus Maior]

So everyone must be imagining the non-Israeli people that the Israelis are encroaching on.

What a brain-dead statement.

Its so sad to see people think that Palestine does not deserve a homeland or recognition at least.

Whether or not one buys into the idea of Palestinian nationalism, that doesn't change the fact that these are real people who are being forced out of their homes and victimized just so Israel can have more real estate for their own people.

[Shin-Mutsu]

If you’re so insistent in this hilariously naïve belief there exists a """Palestinian nation""", then I have your answer: it’s called Jordan. Any Arab that wishes to live in that land is welcome to - as an Israeli. Any Arab that’s angry a few Jews moved back into their own homeland, he can go cry to Allah at this ‘injustice’ ( ) in a Jordanian or ISIL mosque.

Not to mix threads together, but couldn't you literally say the same thing about Armenians in Artsakh and the country of Armenia?

I certainly could imagine Hakinda or any other Turk using that argument. "There's no country of "Artsakh", any Armenian who wants to live in the Caucasus can live in Armenia."

For someone who was so incredibly enthusiastic about the Armenian cause in that one thread, you're not very sympathetic about a people that's literally in the same situation, and villainized by the same people (Israel).

I wonder if they might be supporting or opposing causes due to their personal beliefs instead of being consistent in applying rules.

[Albionist Great Britain]

I don’t really care much about those lots, put them under Jordanian and Egyptian administration for all I care or leave them as they are. The United Nations could deal with them but they’re completely braindead. Ideally the land would go to Israel, but the populations would swing the demographics to the point Israel can no longer be the Jewish state.

So wait a minute if you don't want the territories annexed what does it matter if they're owned by other arab states or organised as their own state called "Palestine"

Because putting those territories in the hands of Arab states would pose a security threat to Israel I do not wish upon it.

[Witiland]

so the Jews can have a homeland but not Israel? I can just say oh the Jews already have a homeland Europe or America... and i would make 0 sense. I'm not a Muslim and I used to be pro Israel until I realized what was really going on

*Mic Drop*

Europe nor America are Jewish homelands, Israel is.

when 2,000 years ago?

[Albionist Great Britain]

I don’t really care much about those lots, put them under Jordanian and Egyptian administration for all I care or leave them as they are. The United Nations could deal with them but they’re completely braindead. Ideally the land would go to Israel, but the populations would swing the demographics to the point Israel can no longer be the Jewish state.

AGB I have a question for you. Number one do you think this conflict will ever be resolved? Two what do you think is the best solution?

It will only be resolved once the Arabs accept Israel as a state, thereby giving it something to lose if it continues the current treatment of Arabs in Israel; or until the Arabs exterminate Jews from their homeland forever.

The former is obviously the best solution.

[Albionist Great Britain]

Europe nor America are Jewish homelands, Israel is.

when 2,000 years ago?

Always.

[Salus Maior]

Armenians are native to Artsakh. They always have, always will be. The Arabs are not the same in Israel.

Arabs have lived in Palestine for well over a thousand years at this point. At what point does a place become someone's "homeland"?

That being said, I'm not for destroying Israel either (although I do believe founding Israel was a mistake). But they need to stop colonizing Palestine with their illegal settlements which are only making things worse in the region, as well as promoting ethnocentric policies.

[Witiland]

AGB I have a question for you. Number one do you think this conflict will ever be resolved? Two what do you think is the best solution?

It will only be resolved once the Arabs accept Israel as a state, thereby giving it something to lose if it continues the current treatment of Arabs in Israel; or until the Arabs exterminate Jews from their homeland forever.

The former is obviously the best solution.

So you think Israel should rule over Palestine? And if so would that be influenced by religion and might treat the Palestinians unfair?

[Albionist Great Britain]

It will only be resolved once the Arabs accept Israel as a state, thereby giving it something to lose if it continues the current treatment of Arabs in Israel; or until the Arabs exterminate Jews from their homeland forever.

The former is obviously the best solution.

So you think Israel should rule over Palestine? And if so would that be influenced by religion and might treat the Palestinians unfair?

I do not support an Israeli annexation of Jordan.

[Kubra]

Its so sad to see people think that Palestine does not deserve a homeland or recognition at least.

Because there isn’t a Palestine.

Not to mix threads together, but couldn't you literally say the same thing about Armenians in Artsakh and the country of Armenia?

I certainly could imagine Hakinda or any other Turk using that argument. "There's no country of "Artsakh", any Armenian who wants to live in the Caucasus can live in Armenia."

For someone who was so incredibly enthusiastic about the Armenian cause in that one thread, you're not very sympathetic about a people that's literally in the same situation, and villainized by the same people (Israel).

Armenians are native to Artsakh. They always have, always will be. The Arabs are not the same in Israel.

wait when did the arabs get into the province of palestina

[Witiland]

when 2,000 years ago?

Always.

So apparently for generations the Jews have not lived in that area and we are gonna say ":well historically it belongs to them!" But for hundreds of years has been ruled by Muslims....

[Kubra]

So wait a minute if you don't want the territories annexed what does it matter if they're owned by other arab states or organised as their own state called "Palestine"

Because putting those territories in the hands of Arab states would pose a security threat to Israel I do not wish upon it.

But
Egypt and Jordan are arab states
and you just said you stick em with them

[Witiland]

So you think Israel should rule over Palestine? And if so would that be influenced by religion and might treat the Palestinians unfair?

I do not support an Israeli annexation of Jordan.

Ok now I finally agree with you

[The Restored Danelaw]

Because there isn’t a Palestine.



Armenians are native to Artsakh. They always have, always will be. The Arabs are not the same in Israel.

wait when did the arabs get into the province of palestina

The majority of those living there now? During the migrations between 1880s and 1940s.

[Salus Maior]

wait when did the arabs get into the province of palestina

The majority of those living there now? During the migrations between 1880s and 1940s.

Who lived there before that point?

I imagine it wasn't majority Jews up to that point. Nor has it been since Rome deported the Jewish population of Judea back in the first century AD.

[Albionist Great Britain]

Because there isn’t a Palestine.



Armenians are native to Artsakh. They always have, always will be. The Arabs are not the same in Israel.

wait when did the arabs get into the province of palestina

The Romans called it that to mock the Jews, calling it after their enemies the Philistines.

Always.

So apparently for generations the Jews have not lived in that area and we are gonna say ":well historically it belongs to them!" But for hundreds of years has been ruled by Muslims....

Jews have always lived in Israel, and always will. There haven’t been as many Jews since the Romans came in and expelled many Jews from their homeland, but Jews have always lived there. The Arabs moved in and enforced their might upon the natives (Jews) and foreign residents (non-Jews), as they always do.

Because putting those territories in the hands of Arab states would pose a security threat to Israel I do not wish upon it.

But
Egypt and Jordan are arab states
and you just said you stick em with them

Egypt and Jordan pose security threats to Israel, at least until they’re formal Israeli allies, then they can have those shanty towns.

[Kubra]

wait when did the arabs get into the province of palestina

The majority of those living there now? During the migrations between 1880s and 1940s.

1880's? But the ottoman census was reporting muslim identity at about 80% before then. And while muslim ain't synonymous with arab, there ain't much folks there liable to be anything else.

[The Restored Danelaw]

The majority of those living there now? During the migrations between 1880s and 1940s.

Who lived there before that point?

I imagine it wasn't majority Jews up to that point. Nor has it been since Rome deported the Jewish population of Judea back in the first century AD.

Oh, it was probably either Arabs or Muslims (which really only means Arab in the Middle East under Ottomans) -at least by that point in time. But most of the people who lived there before the Migrations of late 1800s didn't come to identify as Palestinians after the first Arab-Israeli War.