Xmara wrote:The Rich Port wrote:See I dunno, I remember hearing similar concerns about knowledge about the Holocaust back in the day.
I distinctly remember the way we covered the Holocaust in my Catholic School, as part of World War 2. It was kinda hype. As part of our approach to Christmas, me and my TV fan girlfriend proposed we watch Band of Brothers, which was available in the school library. Everybody got hyped. We made popcorn, we brought snacks, and all we did in class was watch the show supplemented by a brief lesson and some discussions...
Then, we got to the Holocaust episode, and my teacher warned us, this show about war is about to get even more serious, and if people can't handle it, leave now. Everybody kinda nodded and was all meh about it... Until we got to the actual part in the show and a bunch of the kids started crying. One girl, who was a Jew herself and my ex-girlfriend, was inconsolable and had to sit outside in the hall. Luckily we had comfy couches for that. After the episode was over a few minutes later, I went outside to console her.
Her conclusion was that, as hard as it was to watch, she needed to know. We all came away better, happier, wiser people from having watched that show.
Is it really that hard to educate kids about the realities of WW2? Is it so offensive... Just how many lies are people telling their children?
My 8th and 10th grade English classes had Holocaust units, and we touched on it in 9th grade English with our summer reading assignment. I have a couple of memories that stand out from those classes:
-In 8th grade, we were split into three groups, and each group read a different book: The Children of Willesden Lane, Night, and The Diary of Anne Frank. I was in the group assigned to The Children of Willesden Lane, but my English teacher lent me a copy of Night because I had asked about it. I remember only making it through the first few chapters. I couldn't complete it. It was, at that point in my life, the most disturbing thing I had ever read.
-In 10th grade, we were assigned I Have Lived A Thousand Years. It was pretty disturbing as well, but I think the moment that stands out the most to me is when the girl and her mother are given bowls of soup (the way it's described, it sounded more like slop than it did soup). The girl points at her mother's soup and tells her that there is a worm in it. It doesn't matter to her, though, and she eats the whole bowl, worm included. IDK why, but I found that scene really unnerving, even though it was far from the most horrifying aspect of the book.
Schindler's list, when I was in 7th grade I watched Schindler's list with my Hebrew School classmates. Same year I went to the DC holocaust museum. They have video of what the camps where like when active, as well as the experiments done on the ... prisoners. Those videos where hidden by a wall so that those children not able to deal would not see them. I still remember the images of the bodies piled on each other.







