Shofercia wrote:Novus America wrote:
No, because as explained thinking a past period was the best =/= wanting it back.
I will have to find the source again. But I remember seeing a poll where Americans said the best period was the 1950s.
That does not mean we want to go back to it.
That is quite idiotic to say: "We rocked, so we shouldn't go back to rocking!" That's not how reality works. Most Russians don't want Communism back, because of the transition difficulty. What we have works, let's not change it, rather than "we don't want to be great if we could be great!"Novus America wrote:Again when asked if they want to go back to it, they say no. That is not cherry picking because that is literally the direct question!
People can answer differently because just because the idolize the past does not mean they want to return to it.
That is the nature of nostalgia.
No, that's the nature of cherry picking. You might want to be a great runner, but you don't want to give up tasty food and wake up at 5 am to run; that doesn't mean that you don't want to go back to being a great runner, it just means that you're not ready to make the transition, yet. You have to consider the transition when asking someone to go from A to B.Novus America wrote:Also you can only want selective good parts of that past era back while leaving the ugly parts behind. You can only build the future, not return to the past, which you would not even want to do.
The majority saying they want to continue with Putinism over the Soviet model would mean the majority still want Putinism over the Soviet model... obviously.
Or it could mean that the majority wants the Soviet model, but doesn't want to work for it through the transition period, and are also happy with Putinism. No wonder you ignore my posts and call them "wanking" - because I make these points that you don't seem to grasp.Novus America wrote:Now on Belarus I do not have a poll, but I would imagine they do not want to magically role the clock back to 1975, even if they could, which of course they cannot. Even if a majority might say 1975 was better than now.
Or they could want to roll back the clock to 1975, just with a different leader. The longer the leader stays in power, the more he or she is usually disliked, and Lukashenko held power for a while. FDR was a better president than Teddy of JFK, and yet he was in power for a long time, (by US standards,) so who're Americans more nostalgic about? Teddy & JFK.
Exactly, this is precisely what I was getting at.
Russians don't want to go back to the USSR because another 30 year economic transition isn't viable.










