Why you should eat Biblical apple

[La Xinga]

They felt gratitude. It showed you lots of examples.

No, your link did not give examples of animals feeling gratitude at the time of adam and eve

So animals magically gained gratitude over time?

[Last Breath]

Which says nothing about whether animals at the time of the story felt gratitude. And here

They felt gratitude. It showed you lots of examples.

First of all this is all anecdotal evidence, and thus shouldn't really be taken to support an extremely wide-reaching psychological claim. Secondly simply assuming animals feel gratitude because their behavior somewhat resembles that of humans expressing such emotions is a fairly unreasonable thing to do.

[Neutraligon]

No, your link did not give examples of animals feeling gratitude at the time of adam and eve

So animals magically gained gratitude over time?

See my edit as to whether the stories are actually animals feeling gratitude. And second, why not, they supposedly magically gained knowledge of good and evil as well

[La Xinga]

They felt gratitude. It showed you lots of examples.

First of all this is all anecdotal evidence, and thus shouldn't really be taken to support an extremely wide-reaching psychological claim. Secondly simply assuming animals feel gratitude because their behavior somewhat resembles that of humans expressing such emotions is a fairly unreasonable thing to do.

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

[Hurdergaryp]

So animals magically gained gratitude over time?

See my edit as to whether the stories are actually animals feeling gratitude. And second, why not, they supposedly magically gained knowledge of good and evil as well

And here I was thinking Genesis was just a monotheistic edit of Sumerian mythology, but apparently there are intricate layers involved!

[La Xinga]

So animals magically gained gratitude over time?

See my edit as to whether the stories are actually animals feeling gratitude. And second, why not, they supposedly magically gained knowledge of good and evil as well

Debatable? What else would they be feeling??!!
Magic?

[Neutraligon]

First of all this is all anecdotal evidence, and thus shouldn't really be taken to support an extremely wide-reaching psychological claim. Secondly simply assuming animals feel gratitude because their behavior somewhat resembles that of humans expressing such emotions is a fairly unreasonable thing to do.

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

I have evidence that the sun rotates around the earth, see it moves across the sky. Just because something looks like it happens does not mean your interpretation is correct. You are humanizing animals with no evidence that they should be humanized that way.

[Neutraligon]

See my edit as to whether the stories are actually animals feeling gratitude. And second, why not, they supposedly magically gained knowledge of good and evil as well

Debatable? What else would they be feeling??!!
Magic?

They could be remembering that they could get food at this place, and so be returning to get food (as is the case for the wild animals), or that the location was arm, and so return to a warm location, no gratitude necessary. For the dogs, they could simply be enjoying living a good life, no gratitude necessary.

[La Xinga]

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

I have evidence that the sun rotates around the earth, see it moves across the sky. Just because something looks like it happens does not mean your interpretation is correct. You are humanizing animals with no evidence that they should be humanized that way.

What other way should they be?

[Hurdergaryp]

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

I have evidence that the sun rotates around the earth, see it moves across the sky. Just because something looks like it happens does not mean your interpretation is correct. You are humanizing animals with no evidence that they should be humanized that way.

Humanizing animals sounds like a perfect way to end up worshipping pagan animal gods, and I'm okay with that.

[Last Breath]

First of all this is all anecdotal evidence, and thus shouldn't really be taken to support an extremely wide-reaching psychological claim. Secondly simply assuming animals feel gratitude because their behavior somewhat resembles that of humans expressing such emotions is a fairly unreasonable thing to do.

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

Evidence Is evidence, but 13 cases not under experimental conditions is not very strong evidence, certainly not strong enough for the fairly extreme calm you are making. It is unreasonable because the minds of animals are quite possibly very different from ours, a fact which is not acknowledged if you simply project your own sentiments onto them.

[Neutraligon]

I have evidence that the sun rotates around the earth, see it moves across the sky. Just because something looks like it happens does not mean your interpretation is correct. You are humanizing animals with no evidence that they should be humanized that way.

What other way should they be?

What do you mean by what other way should they be?

[La Xinga]

First, who cares? Evidence is evidence, some animals do have graditute.
Second of all, why?

Evidence Is evidence, but 13 cases not under experimental conditions is not very strong evidence, certainly not strong enough for the fairly extreme calm you are making. It is unreasonable because the minds of animals are quite possibly very different from ours, a fact which is not acknowledged if you simply project your own sentiments onto them.

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

What other way should they be?

What do you mean by what other way should they be?

^^^^^^^^^^

[Neutraligon]

Evidence Is evidence, but 13 cases not under experimental conditions is not very strong evidence, certainly not strong enough for the fairly extreme calm you are making. It is unreasonable because the minds of animals are quite possibly very different from ours, a fact which is not acknowledged if you simply project your own sentiments onto them.

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

What do you mean by what other way should they be?

^^^^^^^^^^

I am asking you a question for clarification, not making a statement.

[Last Breath]

Evidence Is evidence, but 13 cases not under experimental conditions is not very strong evidence, certainly not strong enough for the fairly extreme calm you are making. It is unreasonable because the minds of animals are quite possibly very different from ours, a fact which is not acknowledged if you simply project your own sentiments onto them.

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

What do you mean by what other way should they be?

^^^^^^^^^^

They could simply be expressing joy, without actually being thankful towards anybody. I'm fairly certain this has been suggested multiple times to you.

[Neutraligon]

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

^^^^^^^^^^

They could simply be expressing joy, without actually being thankful towards anybody. I'm fairly certain this has been suggested multiple times to you.

Or remembering where the food/safe place is and returning.

[La Xinga]

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

^^^^^^^^^^

I am asking you a question for clarification, not making a statement.

Clarification? Statements? WHY? You want Clarification what they are doing? What else are they doing?

[Neutraligon]

I am asking you a question for clarification, not making a statement.

Clarification? Statements? WHY? You want Clarification what they are doing? What else are they doing?

I already answered that. Also you are arguing from ignorance, a logical fallacy.

[La Xinga]

WHAT ELSE are they doing?

^^^^^^^^^^

They could simply be expressing joy, without actually being thankful towards anybody. I'm fairly certain this has been suggested multiple times to you.

How so joy? And cannot they just be happy, not needing to go to their saver?

They could simply be expressing joy, without actually being thankful towards anybody. I'm fairly certain this has been suggested multiple times to you.

Or remembering where the food/safe place is and returning.

Most of these stuff are not in people's home, yet the come there.

[Neutraligon]

They could simply be expressing joy, without actually being thankful towards anybody. I'm fairly certain this has been suggested multiple times to you.

How so joy? And cannot they just be happy, not needing to go to their saver?

Or remembering where the food/safe place is and returning.

Most of these stuff are not in people's home, yet the come there.

Not true.

[La Xinga]

Clarification? Statements? WHY? You want Clarification what they are doing? What else are they doing?

I already answered that. Also you are arguing from ignorance, a logical fallacy.

And I quoted that. And I'm not arguing from ignorance.

[La Xinga]

How so joy? And cannot they just be happy, not needing to go to their saver?
Most of these stuff are not in people's home, yet the come there.

Not true.

That horned animal.

[Dominioan]

What proof is there that god even exists anyway? But on the actual topic, the biblical apple (imo) should have been eaten.

[Neutraligon]

I already answered that. Also you are arguing from ignorance, a logical fallacy.

And I quoted that. And I'm not arguing from ignorance.

Yes, you are, and I already explained what could be happening. You quoting it does not change that I have already given possible explanations

[Neutraligon]

Not true.

That horned animal.

The dear, who is returning for food