NationStates

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/MDE2425032015ENGLISH.PDF

That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/MDE2425032015ENGLISH.PDF

That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/MDE2425032015ENGLISH.PDF

That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

United Muscovite Nations wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

It's not been debunked, and it's not trying to corroborate a Turkish narrative, it's trying to give voice to a small minority within Northern Syria. Moreover, if it was an act of military necessity, why were the refugees not permitted to return?

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:https://www.amnesty.org/download/Documents/MDE2425032015ENGLISH.PDF

That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Loben The 2nd wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

by mistake

Rojava Free State wrote:https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/isis-rears-its-head-adding-to-chaos-as-turkey-battles-kurds/ar-AAIDaQw?ocid=AMZN#page=2


And now ISIS is back in business. Ladies and gentlemen I see this as an absolute loss

Aureumterra wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:Forced displacement is never good. But let's not pretend that the YPG are perfectly innocent and have never committed terrorist actions or forced people from their homes as refugees, who need to be returned. There are reasons there are groups within Rojava's territory who support the Turkish operation.

I’ve given up trying to convince socialists that Rojava isn’t perfect

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:It's not been debunked, and it's not trying to corroborate a Turkish narrative, it's trying to give voice to a small minority within Northern Syria. Moreover, if it was an act of military necessity, why were the refugees not permitted to return?

Claims of ethnic cleansing by Rojava is very much a Turkish narrative that Amnesty is trying to peddle.

How do you expect them to reinhabit completely demolished homes, exactly?

Rojava Free State wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

Rojava Free State wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

United Muscovite Nations wrote:

Rojava Free State wrote:
Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

Of course, you realize, this would trigger article 5 of NATO.

Rojava Free State wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
That Amnesty International report is by and large trash that tries to corroborate a Turkish narrative of the YPG committing ethnic cleansing. It's also been debunked.

As for the displacements, those literally happened because the villages hadn't yet been secured and still featured an ISIS presence. It was an act of military necessity.

Also, now US troops are being bombed by Turkey.

Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

Loben The 2nd wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:Of course, you realize, this would trigger article 5 of NATO.

which is

Napkizemlja wrote:

Rojava Free State wrote:
Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

Should Canadian military personnel been allowed to bomb American personnel in Afghanistan?

Rojava Free State wrote:

Napkizemlja wrote:Should Canadian military personnel been allowed to bomb American personnel in Afghanistan?

We don't bomb Canadians though. The US may not be the sanest nation, but Turkey wins in the delusional races

Rojava Free State wrote:

Napkizemlja wrote:Should Canadian military personnel been allowed to bomb American personnel in Afghanistan?

We don't bomb Canadians though. The US may not be the sanest nation, but Turkey wins in the delusional races

Ifreann wrote:

Rojava Free State wrote:
We don't bomb Canadians though. The US may not be the sanest nation, but Turkey wins in the delusional races

American troops have accidentally fired on friendly soldiers on many occasions. It happens all the time in war. So often that there's a name for it. Friendly fire.

United Muscovite Nations wrote:

Torrocca wrote:
Claims of ethnic cleansing by Rojava is very much a Turkish narrative that Amnesty is trying to peddle.

How do you expect them to reinhabit completely demolished homes, exactly?

Why do you think that? Amnesty has been extremely critical of the Turkish government.

United Muscovite Nations wrote:

Rojava Free State wrote:
Time to bomb the Turkish army. I doubt we will though since America is basically running away from Turkey instead of standing up to the aggression of a tyrant

Of course, you realize, this would trigger article 5 of NATO.

Dooom35796821595 wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:Of course, you realize, this would trigger article 5 of NATO.

You mean that security agreement which is basically America saves you from the Russians? Yeah, I doubt anyone will take Turkeys side in that fight.

Rojava Free State wrote:

Dooom35796821595 wrote:
You mean that security agreement which is basically America saves you from the Russians? Yeah, I doubt anyone will take Turkeys side in that fight.

Turkey legit needs and deserves to suffer a horrific war for their behind the scenes aid to ISIS alone. We're fighting ISIS but won't fight ISIS's biggest allies. In other words this war isn't serious

Rojava Free State wrote:

Napkizemlja wrote:Should Canadian military personnel been allowed to bomb American personnel in Afghanistan?

We don't bomb Canadians though. The US may not be the sanest nation, but Turkey wins in the delusional races

Torrocca wrote:

United Muscovite Nations wrote:Why do you think that? Amnesty has been extremely critical of the Turkish government.

Because other organizations investigated the claims of ethnic cleansing and found no corroborating evidence. Because Erdogan despises the Kurds, and especially because Rojava's existence as a Libertarian Socialist movement threatens the continued existence of the Turkish state.

Speaking of which, it's both incredibly odd and incredibly infuriating that you're choosing to play ball for a Fascist-like regime by vilifying Rojava and making apologetics for Turkish attacks on civilians in Rojava when you call yourself an Anarchist.