Transgender Peaceful Protest Advocate Kept in Men's Prison

[Kowani]

Shitty dictatorship does shitty things. What a surprise.

[Great Confederacy of Commonwealth States]

Even if this sentence had any information of importance to deliver, which it hasn’t, then even under your rules should she be in a female prison.

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

Yeah, so? The problem is they put her in a prison of a different gender, while islam prohibits that according to you.

[Great Confederacy of Commonwealth States]

The protests were started by a violent military government. So, ban violent military governments because they lead to protests which lead to coups. Or ban calling for coups. Just don’t ban peaceful protests.

Besides, Egypt’s recognition is not required.

Yes, actually, Egypt's recognition is required, it is their country, after all. Large scale protests in unstable countries are dangerous, and democracy is unworkable in Egypt.

Dictatorships are dangerous.

And no, Egypt’s recognition of a right is not required in order for it to be a right.

[Nakena]

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

Yeah, so? The problem is they put her in a prison of a different gender, while islam prohibits that according to you.

Islamic Fundamentalism ruined Egypt.

Also the wet dream is just getting started.

[Al Mumtahanah]

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

Yeah, so? The problem is they put her in a prison of a different gender, while islam prohibits that according to you.

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

[Great Confederacy of Commonwealth States]

Yeah, so? The problem is they put her in a prison of a different gender, while islam prohibits that according to you.

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

Sex is not the issue. Gender is.

[United Muscovite Nations]

Yes, actually, Egypt's recognition is required, it is their country, after all. Large scale protests in unstable countries are dangerous, and democracy is unworkable in Egypt.

Dictatorships are dangerous.

And no, Egypt’s recognition of a right is not required in order for it to be a right.

Yes it is, rights are given to you by the government, they are legal constructs.

You're welcome to institute democracy and then watch the radicals who make up most of the population take power.

[Al Mumtahanah]

Yeah, so? The problem is they put her in a prison of a different gender, while islam prohibits that according to you.

Islamic Fundamentalism ruined Egypt.

This government is much less Islamic than the democratic one.

[Nakena]

Islamic Fundamentalism ruined Egypt.

This government is much Islamic than the democratic one.

Indeed. It's quite the irony. Almost as if they feel like they need to prove themself for being sufficiently islamic.

[Al Mumtahanah]

Sunni Islam does not recognize sex change.

Sex is not the issue. Gender is.

Sunni Islam does not recognize gender change.

[The Derpy Democratic Republic Of Herp]

They should.

Then they might be toppled again and they'd be back at square 1. It's an unstable country with a military dictatorship, don't expect much out of it.

Still, I don't want anyone from any country being arrested for starting a peaceful protest.

[Al Mumtahanah]

This government is much Islamic than the democratic one.

Indeed. It's quite the irony. Almost as if they feel like they need to prove themself for being sufficiently islamic.

I meant to say less

[Nakena]

Then they might be toppled again and they'd be back at square 1. It's an unstable country with a military dictatorship, don't expect much out of it.

Still, I don't want anyone from any country being arrested for starting a peaceful protest.

Its quite daring if not outright dangerous and life-threatingly stupid to do anything remotely close to political activism in Egypt those days.

[The Derpy Democratic Republic Of Herp]

Still, I don't want anyone from any country being arrested for starting a peaceful protest.

Its quite daring if not outright dangerous and life-threatingly stupid to do anything remotely close to political activism in Egypt those days.

It shouldn't be, and she shouldn't have been arrested.

[United Muscovite Nations]

Its quite daring if not outright dangerous and life-threatingly stupid to do anything remotely close to political activism in Egypt those days.

It shouldn't be, and she shouldn't have been arrested.

That's easy to say while living in a stable country where protests don't threaten to become a revolution.

[Nakena]

Its quite daring if not outright dangerous and life-threatingly stupid to do anything remotely close to political activism in Egypt those days.

It shouldn't be, and she shouldn't have been arrested.

There is what should be and then what actually is be.

Egypt is pretty much a lost cause.

[Ordenstaat Burgundy]

I wouldn't say it's a lost cause. While not ideal, the current government is certainly better than the alternative of having Egypt be led by politicians affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.

[Nakena]

I wouldn't say it's a lost cause. While not ideal, the current government is certainly better than the alternative of having Egypt be led by politicians affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.

The current government is implementing even more fundamentalist policies than its predecessor.

[Imbalistan]

Even as a muslim, this is pretty disgusting on how there keeping her in a mens prison.

[Al Mumtahanah]

Even as a muslim, this is pretty disgusting on how there keeping her in a mens prison.

What madhab does your mosque follow?

[Ordenstaat Burgundy]

I wouldn't say it's a lost cause. While not ideal, the current government is certainly better than the alternative of having Egypt be led by politicians affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.

The current government is implementing even more fundamentalist policies than its predecessor.

Oh really? Where is your evidence for this? From what I have seen he has been fairly run of the mill as Arab dictators go/has been fairly anti fundamentalist especially given how he has targeted muslim extremist groups both at home and in the near abroad. He's certainly less of a fundamentalist than his predecessor was.

[Pacomia]

None of this is surprising. It’s a Muslim country.

[The Derpy Democratic Republic Of Herp]

It shouldn't be, and she shouldn't have been arrested.

That's easy to say while living in a stable country where protests don't threaten to become a revolution.

Even if I was there I would still advocate for protests to be legal.

[Ordenstaat Burgundy]

I wouldn't say it's a lost cause. While not ideal, the current government is certainly better than the alternative of having Egypt be led by politicians affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood.

The current government is implementing even more fundamentalist policies than its predecessor.

Oh really? Where is your evidence for this? From what I have seen he has been fairly run of the mill as Arab dictators go/has been fairly anti fundamentalist especially given how he has targeted muslim extremist groups both at home and in the near abroad. He's certainly less of a fundamentalist than his predecessor was.

Oh and as for the man being jailed. It's regrettable that he's in prison, but hopefully he'll end up being released later down the line.

[Kowani]

That's easy to say while living in a stable country where protests don't threaten to become a revolution.

Even if I was there I would still advocate for protests to be legal.

From prison?