Christmas: Glass Box Edition

[Infected Mushroom]

what about Witch Annie's good behaviour over the year?

"Broken" =/= good behaviour. If I break someone's spirit it'd be asinine to claim that they are behaving themselves.

Still, I think it should be factored in that she's been cooperating with the prison and has cooperated with the Order and the state's efforts to study and understand her and to get information from her.

You are correct that when she first got in the Glass Box she was a lot more combative. However, she has resigned herself to her fate and has stopped giving the authorities trouble.

This should be considered in whether or not to grant the Christmas meal.

[Free Arabian Nation]

Fuck no

well at least with regards to royalty

Buddy, if we're talking royalty, then there were more executions during the Sumerians to the French Revolution than in all of Iranian History (post-coup), Saudi History, and North Korean history combined

[Kowani]

"Broken" =/= good behaviour. If I break someone's spirit it'd be asinine to claim that they are behaving themselves.

Still, I think it should be factored in that she's been cooperating with the prison and has cooperated with the Order and the state's efforts to study and understand her and to get information from her.

You are correct that when she first got in the Glass Box she was a lot more combative. However, she has resigned herself to her fate and has stopped giving the authorities trouble.

This should be considered in whether or not to grant the Christmas meal.

It was considered irrelevant.

[Infected Mushroom]

Still, I think it should be factored in that she's been cooperating with the prison and has cooperated with the Order and the state's efforts to study and understand her and to get information from her.

You are correct that when she first got in the Glass Box she was a lot more combative. However, she has resigned herself to her fate and has stopped giving the authorities trouble.

This should be considered in whether or not to grant the Christmas meal.

It was considered irrelevant.

but I'm sure lots of people who voted Yes factored that in right?

[Kowani]

It was considered irrelevant.

but I'm sure lots of people who voted Yes factored that in right?

Am I a mind reader? Fuck if I know.

[Heloin]

El-Amin and I pointed out that these threads are useless as acting like some sort of gauge for human psychology a few days ago. But the bigger question these threads keep bringing me too is, "Why the hell do you so want us to like or sympathise with Witch Hitler?"

[ECKU]

El-Amin and I pointed out that these threads are useless as acting like some sort of gauge for human psychology a few days ago. But the bigger question these threads keep bringing me too is, "Why the hell do you so want us to like or sympathise with Witch Hitler?"

Exactly!

[Infected Mushroom]

El-Amin and I pointed out that these threads are useless as acting like some sort of gauge for human psychology a few days ago. But the bigger question these threads keep bringing me too is, "Why the hell do you so want us to like or sympathise with Witch Hitler?"

I believe that most people can be helped and understood

[The Free Joy State]

El-Amin and I pointed out that these threads are useless as acting like some sort of gauge for human psychology a few days ago. But the bigger question these threads keep bringing me too is, "Why the hell do you so want us to like or sympathise with Witch Hitler?"

I believe that most people can be helped and understood

It is not possible to understand the mindset of a person who willingly goes out and slaughters millions of innocent civilians -- simply for being different to themselves.

It's not possible to sympathise with a person that can look at men, women and children and decide to kill them -- simply for possessing different characteristics.

When you ask us to pity her, you ask something impossible.

My pity -- and probably that of most in the thread -- is for the victims, cut down by a ruthless, genocidal ideologue.

[Infected Mushroom]

I believe that most people can be helped and understood

It is not possible to understand the mindset of a person who willingly goes out and slaughters millions of innocent civilians -- simply for being different to themselves.

It's not possible to sympathise with a person that can look at men, women and children and decide to kill them -- simply for possessing different characteristics.

When you ask us to pity her, you ask something impossible.

My pity -- and probably that of most in the thread -- is for the victims, cut down by a ruthless, genocidal ideologue.

What about the conditions of Annie’s imprisonment?

[ECKU]

It is not possible to understand the mindset of a person who willingly goes out and slaughters millions of innocent civilians -- simply for being different to themselves.

It's not possible to sympathise with a person that can look at men, women and children and decide to kill them -- simply for possessing different characteristics.

When you ask us to pity her, you ask something impossible.

My pity -- and probably that of most in the thread -- is for the victims, cut down by a ruthless, genocidal ideologue.

What about the conditions of Annie’s imprisonment?

Her prison should be her grave.

[Kowani]

What about the conditions of Annie’s imprisonment?

Her prison should be her grave.

That would be a waste of space.

[Free Arabian Nation]

It is not possible to understand the mindset of a person who willingly goes out and slaughters millions of innocent civilians -- simply for being different to themselves.

It's not possible to sympathise with a person that can look at men, women and children and decide to kill them -- simply for possessing different characteristics.

When you ask us to pity her, you ask something impossible.

My pity -- and probably that of most in the thread -- is for the victims, cut down by a ruthless, genocidal ideologue.

What about the conditions of Annie’s imprisonment?

Prison? No.

Execution? Yes.

[Infected Mushroom]

What about the conditions of Annie’s imprisonment?

Prison? No.

Execution? Yes.

Isn’t there a modern day argument that goes: the state has no right to take a life?

[Free Arabian Nation]

Prison? No.

Execution? Yes.

Isn’t there a modern day argument that goes: the state has no right to take a life?

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering shitheads like her

[ECKU]

Isn’t there a modern day argument that goes: the state has no right to take a life?

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering sh*theads like her

I agree but for different reasons.

[Infected Mushroom]

Isn’t there a modern day argument that goes: the state has no right to take a life?

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering shitheads like her

if the state kills her, then the state shows itself to be no better than her

if the state lowers to the level of denying and revoking Christmas meal rights out petty malice, then it does not reflect well on its legitimacy

[ECKU]

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering shitheads like her

if the state kills her, then the state shows itself to be no better than her

if the state lowers to the level of denying and revoking Christmas meal rights out petty malice, then it does not reflect well on its legitimacy

Both of these are fat lies, especially - actually, both of them are pretty stupid.

[Andsed]

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering shitheads like her

if the state kills her, then the state shows itself to be no better than her

if the state lowers to the level of denying and revoking Christmas meal rights out petty malice, then it does not reflect well on its legitimacy

Bullshit enacting justice on a mass murdering piece of shit does not make you as bad as them.

And no this is not ¨petty malice¨ this is punishing a horrible awful piece of shit for their crimes.

[Free Arabian Nation]

I don't follow that argument. I believe the state, and by-extension the people, has the right to take away the lives of mass murdering shitheads like her

if the state kills her, then the state shows itself to be no better than her

if the state lowers to the level of denying and revoking Christmas meal rights out petty malice, then it does not reflect well on its legitimacy

Bullshit, you're just trying to make another bad excuse to keep your genocidal waifu alive. It isn't working as this statement, along with many others, is false.

[The New California Republic]

…You do know what Wolverine did, right?

Have a gruff and sexy look about him?

...oh, that's not what you are talking about. Never mind then...

[The New California Republic]

"Broken" =/= good behaviour. If I break someone's spirit it'd be asinine to claim that they are behaving themselves.

Still, I think it should be factored in that she's been cooperating with the prison and has cooperated with the Order and the state's efforts to study and understand her and to get information from her.

You are correct that when she first got in the Glass Box she was a lot more combative. However, she has resigned herself to her fate and has stopped giving the authorities trouble.

This should be considered in whether or not to grant the Christmas meal.

Nope. If I break someone then they are not behaving themselves, they are just doing what they are being programmed to do.

[Heloin]

…You do know what Wolverine did, right?

Have a gruff and sexy look about him?

...oh, that's not what you are talking about. Never mind then...

Nightcrawler/Wolverine

[The New California Republic]

Have a gruff and sexy look about him?

...oh, that's not what you are talking about. Never mind then...

Nightcrawler/Wolverine

[Infected Mushroom]

Still, I think it should be factored in that she's been cooperating with the prison and has cooperated with the Order and the state's efforts to study and understand her and to get information from her.

You are correct that when she first got in the Glass Box she was a lot more combative. However, she has resigned herself to her fate and has stopped giving the authorities trouble.

This should be considered in whether or not to grant the Christmas meal.

Nope. If I break someone then they are not behaving themselves, they are just doing what they are being programmed to do.

Not necessarily, someone other than Annie might not play ball. And might try to be a constant thorn/threat to the prison staff.

Two individuals thrown into the same situation might behave differently.