Right Wing Discussion Thread XV: A New Hoppe

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

He was just fed up with this place, but couldn’t be bothered to wait for his profile to go ex-nation.

Can't really blame him tbh. It was real hard for me not to commit suicide by mod after that one thread happened.

I can't really blame him either to be honest. I love you all, but sometimes you folks don't mix well with each other.

[Novus America]

Not in the Russian Empire.
Also you can be economically okay and still mistreated and marginalized.

Wealthy middleman minorities elsewhere don't seem to be leading revolutionary movements. I mean, Indians in Apartheid SA, Chinese in Malaysia, and Igbos in Nigeria, just to name a few examples, seem interested in maintaining the status quo.
And, to the point, most of the Russian revolutionaries were not Peasant ben Farmerstein. They came from wealthy, educated, urban jews.

Chinese in Maylasia?
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Malayan_Emergency
“Chin Peng was born on 21 October 1924 into a middle-class family in the small seaside town of Sitiawan, in Perak state, Malaya.”

Also for the “rich Jews never get pogroms” what was the Holocaust?

Also it is not uncommon for the educated class of a group to lead revolutionary activity allegedly on behalf the more worse off in a group. Unfortunately these revolutions, like the Russian revolution often go astray. Most leaders of the Bolsheviks, both Jewish and non Jewish were educated middle class.

Most leaders of the French Revolution were educated middle class, not the worst off.

Actually pretty much every revolution is actually lead by educated middle or upperclass who are angry for the worst off, not the worst off.
This is is pretty much EVERY revolution. Not something innately Jewish or some other stab in the back dem ebul Jews BS.

[Novus America]

He was just fed up with this place, but couldn’t be bothered to wait for his profile to go ex-nation.

Can't really blame him tbh. It was real hard for me not to commit suicide by mod after that one thread happened.

The mods here are atrocious but we still do have good conversations at times.
Others not, but I have learned things I would not otherwise.
People demanding sources and links makes you really learn what you are advocating.

[Joohan]

What is the RWDT's opinion on the strategic bombing campaign of Nazi Germany by the RAF and USAAF? Is it justifiable, yes or no? I believe it was, considering that it was total war and it was the only viable means to damage German industry sufficiently.

I understand that the bombings were intrinsic in winning the war - but that is not to say that I find them justifiable. It helped to end WW2, but I still don't like it.

[Loben The 2nd]

Strategic bombing made sense, it worked, and therefore it is justified.

[Hakons]

Just noticed this thread's gonna go to pot in 7 more pages. Ecrasez l'infâme!

>Searches French phrase because historical French phrases are fun

>Realizes it's from Voltaire

>When he was talking about wanting to destroy the Church

*resets sign to zero days since Voltaire was proven to be a mistake*

[Duhon]

Just noticed this thread's gonna go to pot in 7 more pages. Ecrasez l'infâme!

>Searches French phrase because historical French phrases are fun

>Realizes it's from Voltaire

>When he was talking about wanting to destroy the Church

*resets sign to zero days since Voltaire was proven to be a mistake*

=p

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

Just noticed this thread's gonna go to pot in 7 more pages. Ecrasez l'infâme!

>Searches French phrase because historical French phrases are fun

>Realizes it's from Voltaire

>When he was talking about wanting to destroy the Church

*resets sign to zero days since Voltaire was proven to be a mistake*

Did Voltaire actively want to destroy the church?

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

Strategic bombing made sense, it worked, and therefore it is justified.

Not saying bombing Nazi cities was unjustified, but lots of horrible things make sense and work.

[Nea Byzantia]

I mean considering it used to be that you aren't wrong. Otherwise we will spend all night debating between Constantinople, and Instanbul again.

Might as well. Königsberg held about the same cultural and historical significance for Germans as Constantinople did for Greeks.

Really? Didn't know that.

[Andsed]

What is the RWDT's opinion on the strategic bombing campaign of Nazi Germany by the RAF and USAAF? Is it justifiable, yes or no? I believe it was, considering that it was total war and it was the only viable means to damage German industry sufficiently.

Eh with regards to the bombings I am conflicted. They did help weaken Germany but also kill thousands of civilians. I think I would consider it a more or less a nessary evil kind of like the nuclear bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki.

[Nea Byzantia]

What is the RWDT's opinion on the strategic bombing campaign of Nazi Germany by the RAF and USAAF? Is it justifiable, yes or no? I believe it was, considering that it was total war and it was the only viable means to damage German industry sufficiently.

I think it was a horrible tragedy. The Nazi Regime was terrible, but the German People suffered horribly as the War drew to its end. Almost as much as the Russians suffered.

[Diopolis]

TFW CM thinks this is actually a clever comeback but just shows he doesn't actually know what a Devil King is.

>> tfw I know the context of the quote and it's basically the same comeback Nobunaga himself used against Shingen, the equivalent of mocking a point of the opposition with a diametrically opposed shitpost

Only the Protestants really.

Yes, I am sure that's why Catholics are more liberal than the Protestants here in the States. They are upholding an even older form of the religion. =^)

I don't know of any liberal reformation of Catholicism,

Did you miss Vatican II?

Vatican II was not Catholic. It was an attempt to import the heresies of the french revolution into the church.

[Nea Byzantia]

>> tfw I know the context of the quote and it's basically the same comeback Nobunaga himself used against Shingen, the equivalent of mocking a point of the opposition with a diametrically opposed shitpost

Yes, I am sure that's why Catholics are more liberal than the Protestants here in the States. They are upholding an even older form of the religion. =^)

Did you miss Vatican II?

Vatican II was not Catholic. It was an attempt to import the heresies of the french revolution into the church.

Its succeeded so far, eh?

[Washington Resistance Army]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

[Valrifell]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Not a Christian but the Pope is the rightful heir to St. Peter.

[Evil Dictators Happyland]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Not a Christian but there really didn't need to be a power struggle between the Pope and the Emperor and Christianity would be much better off if it hadn't happened.

[Washington Resistance Army]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Not a Christian but the Pope is the rightful heir to St. Peter.

I feel like an uber progressive liberal claiming this kinda validates my position

[Nea Byzantia]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Even he understands...

[Nea Byzantia]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Not a Christian but the Pope is the rightful heir to St. Peter.

Heresy!

[Diopolis]

Vatican II was not Catholic. It was an attempt to import the heresies of the french revolution into the church.

Its succeeded so far, eh?

Hey, yall imported the sexual revolution into your church well before Vatican II.

[Nea Byzantia]

Its succeeded so far, eh?

Hey, yall imported the sexual revolution into your church well before Vatican II.

You mean we allow people to marry before getting ordained?

[Washington Resistance Army]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

Not a Christian but there really didn't need to be a power struggle between the Pope and the Emperor and Christianity would be much better off if it hadn't happened.

You're not wrong. Though all the schismatic nonsense is proof of the superiority of ye olde polytheistic traditions

Also nobody ever answered my question on if we have a new OP picked yet : (

[Hakons]

Hey, yall imported the sexual revolution into your church well before Vatican II.

You mean we allow people to marry before getting ordained?

Referring to lax divorce rules, I believe

[Novus America]

Not a Christian but tbh the Orthodox Church is the one true church and anyone who disagrees is a heretic and probably a l*beral too

The Orthodox Churches, One Church. Pick one and only one...
Seriously though there is no single united Orthodox Church.
There are a bunch of fighting and politicking, actually completely independent and often quite different churches.
Some of which are in communion with some others and not with others.