The Free Joy State wrote:Uan aa Boa wrote:Regarding 16 versus 18, I'm fudging that question a little due to being in Scotland where the marriage age is 16. I'm hesitant because the Scottish government's decision to reduce the voting age to 16 has been both popular and successful. With a quick search I haven't been able to find any figures on how common pre-18 marriages there are, but considering that only 3% of people aged 16-24 are married or in a civil partnership there probably aren't many. Marriages are also extremely easy to dissolve if you've lived separately for 2 years.
Returning to the USA, I was reading on Wikipedia that the age of consent is at least 16 in all states with some exemptions mainly aimed at not criminalising sex between minors (as opposed to between a minor and an adult), and also an exemption if the people are married to each other. So I'm struggling to understand how, when the girl in the OP article went to a courthouse and declared herself pregnant by a man of 32, the judge asked her if she'd like to marry him rather than ordering his arrest.
You see, I get that many people will go by the current law. In England, it's legal at 16 with a parent or guardian's consent.
But, I still think 18 (21 would be better) is the right age, because allowing marriage at 16 -- even with parental consent -- gives rise to events like this abomination where Christian homeschoolers (in 2016) gathered to arrange marriages for their teenage daughters, after "training" their daughters to accept marriage.
In 2016. In America.
Seriously.
And the "event" was to include daughters up to 20. So, I'd really favour increasingly the marital age to a higher age than 18. I said 18 because that's the age at which one is considered to have reached majority (for drinking, and voting) in England. So it's what I'm familiar with.
And, while divorce is easy (which is a good thing), it's worth considering that many of these religious communities frown on it and there's intense pressure for people to remain in (even deeply miserable) marriages. So, leaving a marriage that someone may have been pushed into may not be that easy.
Also, even if a marriage entered into at a young age wholly voluntarily, by the time the couple divorce there could still be children, leaving the couple with a tie that will last for life, and having to make custody arrangements. Divorces are emotionally draining. It's still a very hefty price to pay for a youthful mistake.
Better they wait a few more years. If it's true love, the kind that could stand the test of a long-term commitment, surely it could wait a few more years?
EDIT: Research by US State of how many people are married age 15-17 (it's most common in the Southern US, and especially Texas and West Virginia): http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/20 ... -by-state/
From the article you linked:
Two states, Massachusetts and New Hampshire, allow 12- and 13-year-old girls respectively and 14-year-old boys to marry with parental and judicial permission.
Something is rotten in Massachusetts and New Hampshire.









