The Islamic Discussion Thread ٤: It's Always Sunni In Arabia

[A m e n r i a]

Im sure it’s not haram to marry Deists.
If they believe in God, don’t worship multiple gods and don’t have bad morals then ok.
You emphasised the word that, what is bad about her?
You also said it was hopeless but I can give you advice Inshallah.
And Allah knows best.

Well..she has her flaws, including the fact that she enjoys..ahem..the art of psychological warfare..

Depends on the madhhab. Some say you can't eat shrimp. Some say you can.

But overall, no predatory animals, no scavenger birds, no horses, nothing containing pork products (most gelatin, for instance), and no animals that weren't slaughtered properly.

Woa, but I think horse meat is halal, since as far as I know, it doesn't mentioned as being haram. But maybe you got another source?

---

Hehe, anyway semangat A m e n r i a !

Edited: Sorry Am, it seems that I misspelled your nation's name.

Terima kasih gan, gpp kok gk pake spasi jg, itu negara ane waktu sma mangkanya hasilnya masih ampas wkwk

[Khataiy]

@Sahansiye Iran -

Well, I just did some research and yeah, there are multiple opinions on this matter. Apparently some opinions said that horse meat is either makrooh or mubah. I also read this one hadith:

"It was narrated from Jaabir ibn ‘Abd-Allaah (may Allaah be pleased with him) that he said: On the day of Khaybar, the Messenger of Allaah (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) forbade eating the flesh of domestic donkeys, but he granted a concession with regard to horses."
Narrated by al-Bukhaari, 3982; Muslim, 1941.

I also read that shrimp is considered as 'makrooh' in the Hanafi school of thought, but so are onions (?).
Maybe some Hanafis can clarify this?

---

@Geneviev -

Just read again, and sorry for the late response. Apparently frogs are also considered as haram by some.

/Not a Hanafi, but, I have heard the reason Imam Azam Abu Hanifa (RH) forbade the consumption of horses and camels was because he said they are useful for warfare and should be reserved be for utility usage only, however this is obviously no longer applicable and the other Imams of Fiqh have disagreed in this regard as well and of course we have the saying of the Prophet (صلى الله عليه وعلى آله وسلم )

[Saranidia]

Im sure it’s not haram to marry Deists.
If they believe in God, don’t worship multiple gods and don’t have bad morals then ok.
You emphasised the word that, what is bad about her?
You also said it was hopeless but I can give you advice Inshallah.
And Allah knows best.

Well..she has her flaws, including the fact that she enjoys..ahem..the art of psychological warfare..

Woa, but I think horse meat is halal, since as far as I know, it doesn't mentioned as being haram. But maybe you got another source?

---

Hehe, anyway semangat A m e n r i a !

Edited: Sorry Am, it seems that I misspelled your nation's name.

Terima kasih gan, gpp kok gk pake spasi jg, itu negara ane waktu sma mangkanya hasilnya masih ampas wkwk

“Psychological warfare” well
As a personal rule of thumb I would go for women “above suspicion”.
Sometimes siren like women can cause all kinds of problems(NOT
A misogynistic comment as I think most women are good people).
Although everyone had their faults.
I wonder if Frievolk will call me a misogynist now.

[Jolthig]

Well..she has her flaws, including the fact that she enjoys..ahem..the art of psychological warfare..



Terima kasih gan, gpp kok gk pake spasi jg, itu negara ane waktu sma mangkanya hasilnya masih ampas wkwk

“Psychological warfare” well
As a personal rule of thumb I would go for women “above suspicion”.
Sometimes siren like women can cause all kinds of problems(NOT
A misogynistic comment as I think most women are good people).
Although everyone had their faults.
I wonder if Frievolk will call me a misogynist now.

What kind of problems?

[Saranidia]

“Psychological warfare” well
As a personal rule of thumb I would go for women “above suspicion”.
Sometimes siren like women can cause all kinds of problems(NOT
A misogynistic comment as I think most women are good people).
Although everyone had their faults.
I wonder if Frievolk will call me a misogynist now.

What kind of problems?

Infidelity is the most common I imagine followed by false accusations.
I wasn’t talking about all women specifically the siren like ones,

[Jolthig]

What kind of problems?

Infidelity is the most common I imagine followed by false accusations.
I wasn’t talking about all women specifically the siren like ones,

Eh, both men and women are equally responsible tbh.

[Andsed]

What kind of problems?

Infidelity is the most common I imagine followed by false accusations.
I wasn’t talking about all women specifically the siren like ones,

What the hell is “siren” like womens?

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Infidelity is the most common I imagine followed by false accusations.
I wasn’t talking about all women specifically the siren like ones,

What the h*ll is “siren” like womens?

I guess woemn who sbow themselves off immodestly.

[Samudera Darussalam]

@ A m e n r i a

Well, if you say so

---

@ Khataiy

I see. So perhaps it's not a problem anymore. Anyway, thanks for the clarification!

[Andsed]

What the h*ll is “siren” like womens?

I guess woemn who sbow themselves off immodestly.

So like ladies of the night? (need to be pg-13) Also why did you take the e out of hell when you quoted me?

[Jolthig]

I guess woemn who sbow themselves off immodestly.

So like ladies of the night? (need to be pg-13) Also why did you take the e out of hell when you quoted me?

The brother has a tendency to do that when quoting people who swear or "swear".

[El-Amin Caliphate]

So like ladies of the night? (need to be pg-13) Also why did you take the e out of hell when you quoted me?

The brother has a tendency to do that when quoting people who swear or "swear".

^This

[Sahansahiye Iran]

I guess woemn who sbow themselves off immodestly.

So like ladies of the night? (need to be pg-13) Also why did you take the e out of hell when you quoted me?

No swearing in my Christian NS forum!

[A m e n r i a]

So like ladies of the night? (need to be pg-13) Also why did you take the e out of hell when you quoted me?

No swearing in my Christian NS forum!

Wrong thread, mate.

[Saranidia]

Infidelity is the most common I imagine followed by false accusations.
I wasn’t talking about all women specifically the siren like ones,

What the hell is “siren” like womens?

It’s a classics reference, from the Odessy

[Sahansahiye Iran]

No swearing in my Christian NS forum!

Wrong thread, mate.

Is it, though?

[Samudera Darussalam]

What the hell is “siren” like womens?

It’s a classics reference, from the Odyssey

*Fixed that for you

Anyway, I think he asked about the meaning of siren-like women in your statement. Maybe you can elaborate?

[Jolthig]

It’s a classics reference, from the Odyssey

*Fixed that for you

Anyway, I think he asked about the meaning of siren-like women in your statement. Maybe you can elaborate?

Fixed what?

[Samudera Darussalam]

Fixed what?

The spelling of the odyssey

[Andsed]

It’s a classics reference, from the Odyssey

*Fixed that for you

Anyway, I think he asked about the meaning of siren-like women in your statement. Maybe you can elaborate?

Yeah I know what a siren is I know quite a bit about mythology but I don’t get what you would mean by a siren like women. I am guessing based off mythology you are talking about say ladies of the night or gold diggers.

[Saranidia]

*Fixed that for you

Anyway, I think he asked about the meaning of siren-like women in your statement. Maybe you can elaborate?

Yeah I know what a siren is I know quite a bit about mythology but I don’t get what you would mean by a siren like women. I am guessing based off mythology you are talking about say ladies of the night or gold diggers.

Essentially yes.


For those of you who don’t know
Sirens tempted sailors to sail closer and in doing so wreck their ships leading to their deaths on the rocks.

[Saranidia]

Cool, Freivolk hasn’t called me a misogynist yet.

[Jolthig]

Cool, Freivolk hasn’t called me a misogynist yet.

Not unless if you want to be called one by him or someone else.

[Frievolk]

Cool, Freivolk hasn’t called me a misogynist yet.

Do I need to? You make it clear whether or not it is true very very faster by your own posts than I would by calling you out. Though, then again, apart from like, 2 or 3 exceptions, this thread has become the very definition of an echo chamber for people like you so what's the point?

[Saranidia]

Cool, Freivolk hasn’t called me a misogynist yet.

Do I need to? You make it clear whether or not it is true very very faster by your own posts than I would by calling you out. Though, then again, apart from like, 2 or 3 exceptions, this thread has become the very definition of an echo chamber for people like you so what's the point?

Find a post where i was a misogynist.