The Islamic Discussion Thread ٤: It's Always Sunni In Arabia

[Western Vale Confederacy]

Egypt and Iraq, too.

Special attention given to the Coptics...

The Copts really don't deserve being mistreated by their fellow Egyptian brothers just because they practice a different religion (which, just as a reminder, was present in Egypt longer than Islam was).

[Greater Cesnica]

Special attention given to the Coptics...

The Copts really don't deserve being mistreated by their fellow Egyptian brothers just because they practice a different religion (which, just as a reminder, was present in Egypt longer than Islam was).

Yep. They're completely harmless and peaceful.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I didn't say that. You said that homosexuals get lashed for being homosexual, which is not the case in Al-Islam. I said that if that was the reason why they were lashed in a Muslim-majority country, it should be changed to the Islamic judgement of lashing for illegal sexual intercourse, in this case being homosexual sex.

But then what's wrong with homosexual sex?

https://onepathnetwork.com/why-is-homos ... -in-islam/

[Greater Cesnica]

But then what's wrong with homosexual sex?

https://onepathnetwork.com/why-is-homos ... -in-islam/

I'm asking about YOUR personal belief and justification. Not you parroting Islamic Theology.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

No they don't.

So you don't support whipping people for having consensual sex?

I do.

https://onepathnetwork.com/why-is-homos ... -in-islam/

I'm asking about YOUR personal belief and justification. Not you parroting Islamic Theology.

I don't put my opinions into Al-Islam, or anything related to it. Also, you didn't specify that. But regardless if you did or not, I wouldn't give it.

[Greater Cesnica]

So you don't support whipping people for having consensual sex?

I do.

I'm asking about YOUR personal belief and justification. Not you parroting Islamic Theology.

I don't put my opinions into Al-Islam, or anything related to it. Also, you didn't specify that. But regardless if you did or not, I wouldn't give it.

So... You would support two people caught having gay sex being whipped?

Lovely.

[Washington Resistance Army]

So you don't support whipping people for having consensual sex?

I do.

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

[Western Vale Confederacy]

So you don't support whipping people for having consensual sex?

I do.

I'm asking about YOUR personal belief and justification. Not you parroting Islamic Theology.

I don't put my opinions into Al-Islam, or anything related to it. Also, you didn't specify that. But regardless if you did or not, I wouldn't give it.

You're sounding as if Allah himself prohibits you to have an opinion, which is stupid.

[Greater Cesnica]

I do.

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

So he supports whipping my bisexual partner.

[Washington Resistance Army]

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

So he supports whipping my bisexual partner.

100 times, yes.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I do.

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

Actually it is. Urges are not prohibited, the actions are.

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

So he supports whipping my bisexual partner.

Is she Muslim?

[Western Vale Confederacy]

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

So he supports whipping my bisexual partner.

Well, I'm sorry to disappoint you, but as a bisexual, my back would also be bleeding from the lashes.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

So he supports whipping my bisexual partner.

Well, I'm sorry to disappoint you, but as a bisexual, my back would also be bleeding from the lashes.

https://islamqa.info/en/13233
Not that this applies to you anyway because you aren't Muslim, just correcting any misunderstandings.

[Western Vale Confederacy]

Well, I'm sorry to disappoint you, but as a bisexual, my back would also be bleeding from the lashes.

https://islamqa.info/en/13233
Not that this applies to you anyway because you aren't Muslim, just correcting any misunderstandings.

You are misunderstood if you think that I would not actively protect any Muslim being """punished""" (more abused/beaten) by fighting back.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

https://islamqa.info/en/13233
Not that this applies to you anyway because you aren't Muslim, just correcting any misunderstandings.

You are misunderstood if you think that I would not actively protect any Muslim being """punished""" (more abused/beaten) by fighting back.

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

[Sahansahiye Iran]

You are misunderstood if you think that I would not actively protect any Muslim being """punished""" (more abused/beaten) by fighting back.

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

"justice"

[Western Vale Confederacy]

You are misunderstood if you think that I would not actively protect any Muslim being """punished""" (more abused/beaten) by fighting back.

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

Again, I do not follow Islamic law, I follow secular law, so frankly, your concept of punishment is worthless to me, for I only submit to SECULAR arrest.

[The Empire of Pretantia]

You are misunderstood if you think that I would not actively protect any Muslim being """punished""" (more abused/beaten) by fighting back.

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

"Justice"

[Dahon]

Just dropping by to say portraying whipping in a positive light is a horrid look.

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

Amin, I know you can't because I've had this same discussion with you several times, dude. I don't have to search your posts. Here's one: if a spouse leaves Islam, should he/she be forced to leave their Muslim spouse?

https://islamqa.info/en/134339, https://darululoomtt.net/married-leaves-islam/

In other words, "yes, he/she should." You're not very smart, are you? You're supposed to be arguing against the idea that sharia is punitive and unfair, not confirming it.

BTW, incest is best.

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

I do.

Great, and that's disgusting and no different from whipping people for who they are.

The libertarian WRA is still in there!

[The Xenopolis Confederation]

Remind me what the punishment is in Al-Islam for leaving it

None

and for having lesbian sex?

Same for other forms of illegal sexual intercourse

Oh. I guess the "you and your partner won't get punished" thing didn't last long.

[Western Vale Confederacy]

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

"justice"

I find it quite ironic that he says that non-Muslims would not be subject to Islamic law, only to state that a non-Muslim would be punished in accordance to Islamic law for preventing a Muslim from getting a "punishment".

My sides are in fucking orbit.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Then you'd go to jail for obstruction of justice.

Again, I do not follow Islamic law, I follow secular law, so frankly, your concept of punishment is worthless to me, for I only submit to SECULAR arrest.

This has nothing to do with enforcing Islamic Law on you, it has to do with obstruction of justice, which you will be sent to jail for of you lived in an Islamic nation. That's not even the Islamic punishment for obstruction of justice.

None

Same for other forms of illegal sexual intercourse

Oh. I guess the "you and your partner won't get punished" thing didn't last long.

Muslims who do haram things will be punished.

only to state that a non-Muslim would be punished in accordance to Islamic law

Show me where I said that.

[Internationalist Bastard]

Again, I do not follow Islamic law, I follow secular law, so frankly, your concept of punishment is worthless to me, for I only submit to SECULAR arrest.

This has nothing to do with enforcing Islamic Law on you, it has to do with obstruction of justice, which you will be sent to jail for of you lived in an Islamic nation. That's not even the Islamic punishment for obstruction of justice.

Oh. I guess the "you and your partner won't get punished" thing didn't last long.

Muslims who do haram things will be punished.

only to state that a non-Muslim would be punished in accordance to Islamic law

Show me where I said that.

So what about the case of to use an example of a poster on this thread, a person who leaves the Muslim faith and engages in gay sex?