The Islamic Discussion Thread ٤: It's Always Sunni In Arabia

[Sahansahiye Iran]

Amin, I know you can't because I've had this same discussion with you several times, dude. I don't have to search your posts. Here's one: if a spouse leaves Islam, should he/she be forced to leave their Muslim spouse?

https://islamqa.info/en/134339, https://darululoomtt.net/married-leaves-islam/

And there you go. There's your punishment for leaving Islam. Even ignoring all the fucking ahadith that tell you to apostates.

[Greater Cesnica]

But see, in Amin's eyes, the beliefs of the majority of the rest of Muslims don't matter. Only his interpretation.

Incorrect.

Do you deny that gays are thrown off of buildings, along with lesbians and bisexuals? This is why I fear a theocracy- it becomes saturated with evil perpetrated under the cloak of religion.

[Sahansahiye Iran]

In any case, under the definition of Shariah, I am an apostate. It is widely accepted that death is an acceptable punishment for those like me.

Most Muslims don't consider Ahmadis to be Muslim, and that's probs the same for Saudi and Iran. So they wouldn't even kill you, or that'd force them to accept that Ahmadis are Muslim.

That is woefully ignorant. That doesn't mean they wouldn't kill them. The Bahai are a completely different faith but Iran punishes them as apostates.

[Greater Cesnica]

Most Muslims don't consider Ahmadis to be Muslim, and that's probs the same for Saudi and Iran. So they wouldn't even kill you, or that'd force them to accept that Ahmadis are Muslim.

That is woefully ignorant. That doesn't mean they wouldn't kill them. The Bahai are a completely different faith but Iran punishes them as apostates.

Oh, and Christians get blown up in my Mother country, Pakistan.

[Sahansahiye Iran]

That is woefully ignorant. That doesn't mean they wouldn't kill them. The Bahai are a completely different faith but Iran punishes them as apostates.

Oh, and Christians get blown up in my Mother country, Pakistan.

Egypt and Iraq, too.

[Greater Cesnica]

Oh, and Christians get blown up in my Mother country, Pakistan.

Egypt and Iraq, too.

Special attention given to the Coptics...

[Kubumba Tribe]

Incorrect.

Do you deny that gays are thrown off of buildings, along with lesbians and bisexuals?

Do you want to talk about Shari'ah or a country's law?

[Greater Cesnica]

Do you deny that gays are thrown off of buildings, along with lesbians and bisexuals?

Do you want to talk about Shari'ah or a country's law?

Shari'ah influences Saudi Arabia and Iran, as well as Pakistan, Egypt, and most of the Arab states.

[Kubumba Tribe]

Do you want to talk about Shari'ah or a country's law?

Shari'ah influences Saudi Arabia and Iran, as well as Pakistan, Egypt, and most of the Arab states.

It more like those countries' influences on Shari'ah. Which we can both agree on, those countries have effed up laws that need to be removed.

[Greater Cesnica]

Shari'ah influences Saudi Arabia and Iran, as well as Pakistan, Egypt, and most of the Arab states.

It more like those countries' influences on Shari'ah. Which we can both agree on, those countries have effed up laws that need to be removed.

Eyyy we can agree on that!

*agreement fistbump*

[Washington Resistance Army]

Shari'ah influences Saudi Arabia and Iran, as well as Pakistan, Egypt, and most of the Arab states.

It more like those countries' influences on Shari'ah. Which we can both agree on, those countries have effed up laws that need to be removed.

And replaced with things like whipping people a hundred times for being who they are

[Kubumba Tribe]

It more like those countries' influences on Shari'ah. Which we can both agree on, those countries have effed up laws that need to be removed.

And replaced with things like whipping people a hundred times for being who they are

That should be removed as well. At least, the intent behind it should be.

[Greater Cesnica]

It more like those countries' influences on Shari'ah. Which we can both agree on, those countries have effed up laws that need to be removed.

And replaced with things like whipping people a hundred times for being who they are

You know, if a government is spying to see what people are doing in their bedrooms, doesn't that make them voyeurs and perverts?

[Kubumba Tribe]

And replaced with things like whipping people a hundred times for being who they are

You know, if a government is spying to see what people are doing in their bedrooms, doesn't that make them voyeurs and perverts?

True, they shouldn't be doing that.

[Washington Resistance Army]

And replaced with things like whipping people a hundred times for being who they are

That should be removed as well. At least, the intent behind it should be.

Isn't it a bit impious of you to say that about Islamic law?

[Kubumba Tribe]

That should be removed as well. At least, the intent behind it should be.

Isn't it a bit impious of you to say that about Islamic law?

[Greater Cesnica]

That should be removed as well. At least, the intent behind it should be.

Isn't it a bit impious of you to say that about Islamic law?

I recall he once said it was haram to change Islamic Law.

o o f

[Kubumba Tribe]

Isn't it a bit impious of you to say that about Islamic law?

I recall he once said it was haram to change Islamic Law.

It is

[Greater Cesnica]

I recall he once said it was haram to change Islamic Law.

It is

Then... what does that say about what you just said a few minutes prior?

[Washington Resistance Army]

Isn't it a bit impious of you to say that about Islamic law?

You've been quite clear that 100 lashes is the crime for gay sex. Isn't it impious for you as a Muslim to claim the intent behind that should be changed?

[El-Amin Caliphate]

You've been quite clear that 100 lashes is the crime for gay sex. Isn't it impious for you as a Muslim to claim the intent behind that should be changed?

I didn't say that. You said that homosexuals get lashed for being homosexual, which is not the case in Al-Islam. I said that if that was the reason why they were lashed in a Muslim-majority country, it should be changed to the Islamic judgement of lashing for illegal sexual intercourse, in this case being homosexual sex.

[Greater Cesnica]

You've been quite clear that 100 lashes is the crime for gay sex. Isn't it impious for you as a Muslim to claim the intent behind that should be changed?

I didn't say that. You said that homosexuals get lashed for being homosexual, which is not the case in Al-Islam. I said that if that was the reason why they were lashed in a Muslim-majority country, it should be changed to the Islamic judgement of lashing for illegal sexual intercourse, in this case being homosexual sex.

But then what's wrong with homosexual sex?

[Washington Resistance Army]

You've been quite clear that 100 lashes is the crime for gay sex. Isn't it impious for you as a Muslim to claim the intent behind that should be changed?

I didn't say that. You said that homosexuals get lashed for being homosexual, which is not the case in Al-Islam.

Your distinction is meaningless. They get whipped for being who they are, and that's disgusting.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I didn't say that. You said that homosexuals get lashed for being homosexual, which is not the case in Al-Islam.

Your distinction is meaningless. They get whipped for being who they are, and that's disgusting.

No they don't.

[Washington Resistance Army]

Your distinction is meaningless. They get whipped for being who they are, and that's disgusting.

No they don't.

So you don't support whipping people for having consensual sex?