The Islamic Discussion Thread ٤: It's Always Sunni In Arabia

[Greater Cesnica]

I swear when I’m talking to Amin I can feel the Arabian wind and sand from 715 A.D permeating my senses.

[Negarakita]

Not sure about Muhammad (there are conflicting reports) but here's one report from a site Amin likes to quote every so often.
https://islamqa.info/en/227776

(Also, please don't ignore the part where

I have a collection of those Hadith in my notes a d a collection of Hadith that counter those.

Amin, you know, the guy who runs that site is a Salafist fundamentalist right? That's why people think you are one.

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

[Saranidia]

I have a collection of those Hadith in my notes a d a collection of Hadith that counter those.

Amin, you know, the guy who runs that site is a Salafist fundamentalist right? That's why people think you are one.

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

what do you mean a fatwa on mickey mouse? a fatwa saying Disney is haram? an Iranian style fatwa of execution on a fictional character? or something else?

[Herskerstad]

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

what do you mean a fatwa on mickey mouse? a fatwa saying Disney is haram? an Iranian style fatwa of execution on a fictional character? or something else?

Who knows, either way makes as much sense as declaring a crusade on Ducktales.

[Negarakita]

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

what do you mean a fatwa on mickey mouse? a fatwa saying Disney is haram? an Iranian style fatwa of execution on a fictional character? or something else?

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldn ... leric.html

[Kowani]

I have a collection of those Hadith in my notes a d a collection of Hadith that counter those.

Amin, you know, the guy who runs that site is a Salafist fundamentalist right? That's why people think you are one.

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

Because the Islamic world has no bigger problems right now...

[Negarakita]

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

We need some sudanese ansari who can call for slavery and anti-colonial revolution like a true chad

Because the Islamic world has no bigger problems right now...

Nope that damn mouse is responsible for all of life's ills

[Jolthig]

Because the Islamic world has no bigger problems right now...

Nope that damn mouse is responsible for all of life's ills

Mickey Mouse is secretly the Dajjal.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Not sure about Muhammad (there are conflicting reports) but here's one report from a site Amin likes to quote every so often.
https://islamqa.info/en/227776

(Also, please don't ignore the part where

I have a collection of those Hadith in my notes a d a collection of Hadith that counter those.

Amin, you know, the guy who runs that site is a Salafist fundamentalist right? That's why people think you are one.

I don't care what they think about me. And the brother has reliable info, that's why I use him. And there's nothing wrong with being Salafi. And I use a lot more sites than islamqa, so that's dumb to judge because they only look at 1 site I use.

Well most of the madhaahib say it's obligatory.

Uh... No. The Shafii, Maliki, and Hanafi all view it as mustahhab. As I've already said several times. Are you just not reading what I post?

Oh, I read that wrong, sorry.

I swear when I’m talking to Amin I can feel the Arabian wind and sand from 715 A.D permeating my senses.

That's pretty cool, but how about the Arabian wind and sand from 12 BH - 10 AH/610-632 AD?

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I have a collection of those Hadith in my notes a d a collection of Hadith that counter those.

Amin, you know, the guy who runs that site is a Salafist fundamentalist right? That's why people think you are one.

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

Ok, mostly reliable info (forgot about him doing that. Has he taken that fatwa back or does he still stand by it?).

[Negarakita]

It's literally the guy who called for a fatwa on mickey mouse

Ok, mostly reliable info (forgot about him doing that. Has he taken that fatwa back or does he still stand by it?).

Iirc he took it back

[Greater Cesnica]

Amin, do you believe that the Quran should be taken literally, and that every concept pushed in it should exist in today’s society?

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Ok, mostly reliable info (forgot about him doing that. Has he taken that fatwa back or does he still stand by it?).

Iirc he took it back

I hope so.

Amin, do you believe that the Quran should be taken literally

No

and that every concept pushed in it should exist in today’s society?

Of course.

[Negarakita]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-sL6aEpcSM

Truly a powerful speech

[Greater Cesnica]

Iirc he took it back

I hope so.

Amin, do you believe that the Quran should be taken literally

No

and that every concept pushed in it should exist in today’s society?

Of course.

What do you think of Quran 65:4?

https://quran.com/65/4

”And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women - if you doubt, then their period is three months, and [also for] those who have not menstruated. And for those who are pregnant, their term is until they give birth. And whoever fears Allah - He will make for him of his matter ease.”

[Greater Cesnica]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A-sL6aEpcSM

Truly a powerful speech

10/10 grammar in the description. Can’t watch vid cuz I don’t have earbuds on me and I’m in public.

[Sahansahiye Iran]

Oh, I read that wrong, sorry.

Wow. Wrong yet again, in relation to this single topic. Here's an idea: don't argue about shit you clearly don't understand.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I hope so.

No

Of course.

What do you think of Quran 65:4?

https://quran.com/65/4

”And those who no longer expect menstruation among your women - if you doubt, then their period is three months, and [also for] those who have not menstruated. And for those who are pregnant, their term is until they give birth. And whoever fears Allah - He will make for him of his matter ease.”

https://discover-the-truth.com/2016/03/ ... iage-claim
http://www.qtafsir.com/index.php?option ... 16&Itemid=

[Negarakita]

Oh, I read that wrong, sorry.

Wow. Wrong yet again, in relation to this single topic. Here's an idea: don't argue about shit you clearly don't understand.

Always a good idea tbh. It's why I stay out of hadith arguments

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Oh, I read that wrong, sorry.

Wow. Wrong yet again, in relation to this single topic. Here's an idea: don't argue about stuff you clearly don't understand.

Reading something wrong =/= misunderstanding

[Sahansahiye Iran]

Wow. Wrong yet again, in relation to this single topic. Here's an idea: don't argue about stuff you clearly don't understand.

Reading something wrong =/= misunderstanding

Considering out of your statement that I called completely horseshit, all of it was actually horseshit, maybe you don't actually understand, eh? Because:
1. Manumission is not obligatory in the majority of Islam
2. It is not the slave just asking.for freedom

[Sahansahiye Iran]

Wow. Wrong yet again, in relation to this single topic. Here's an idea: don't argue about shit you clearly don't understand.

Always a good idea tbh. It's why I stay out of hadith arguments

It's one of my cardinal rules of debate. If more people followed it, we'd be much better off.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Scholars always have the best words on slavery

I remember that Hadith about Prophet Muhammad SAWS interceding for the free person who was enslaved. Lemme see if I can find it: ok, I can't find it, can someone find it for pls? Thx.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Reading something wrong =/= misunderstanding

Considering out of your statement that I called completely horseshit, all of it was actually horseshit, maybe you don't actually understand, eh? Because:
1. Manumission is not obligatory in the majority of Islam
2. It is not the slave just asking.for freedom

I knew about 2, I just forgot to mention it. And I don't think it was even that. I cited a source that talked about the price of freedom.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

I'm talking about nowadays.

It's never okay to marry a nine year old, sorry.

Says who?

Especially when you claim to have God speaking to you.

That was actually a prophetic dream. Allah SWT told the Prophet Muhammad SAWS that his marriage to A'isha RA would happen.