Is a hot dog a sandwich?

[Galloism]

The more important question is, is soup a beverage

Depends: if it is a smooth puree or broth, yes. If it has chunks of stuff in it, no.

Wouldn’t soup with chunks of stuff in it be considered stew?

[Bombadil]

The more important question is, is soup a beverage

Depends: if it is a smooth puree or broth, yes. If it has chunks of stuff in it, no.

I see your chunks and I raise you.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bubble_tea

[The South Falls]

How about my favorite. Would bread, with air in between, because air is an object, be a sandwich? I think yes, because air is an object.

[Dytarma]

How narrowly or broadly are we defining “bread” for this purpose?

(Image)

That's a sandwich, I've had a PB&J with butter on it, but in this case it's glaze and donuts, so ye, sandwich.

[Katganistan]

How narrowly or broadly are we defining “bread” for this purpose?

(Image)

My teeth hurt looking at that -- but you could stretch a point and call that a sandwich. Also: food within two discrete slices of bagel or croissant could also be called a sandwich.

[Bombadil]

How narrowly or broadly are we defining “bread” for this purpose?

(Image)

That's a sandwich, I've had a PB&J with butter on it, but in this case it's glaze and donuts, so ye, sandwich.

Not necessarily a pure sandwich, I'd call it a donut sandwich.. having said that it looks appealing.

[Farnhamia]

Depends: if it is a smooth puree or broth, yes. If it has chunks of stuff in it, no.

Wouldn’t soup with chunks of stuff in it be considered stew?

[Dytarma]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count as a sandwich? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

[Farnhamia]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

Hot dog tacos ... very interesting.

[Katganistan]

Depends: if it is a smooth puree or broth, yes. If it has chunks of stuff in it, no.

Wouldn’t soup with chunks of stuff in it be considered stew?

Minestrone is not stew, nor is pasta e fagioli. And Italian Wedding Soup has meatballs in it.

I would say a stew is a thickened liquid containing primarily meat, with the addition of some vegetables.

[Dytarma]

That's a sandwich, I've had a PB&J with butter on it, but in this case it's glaze and donuts, so ye, sandwich.

Not necessarily a pure sandwich, I'd call it a donut sandwich.. having said that it looks appealing.

Yeah, I'd give it an adjective to describe it more in detail.

[Katganistan]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count as a sandwich? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

No, a taco is not a sandwich. A soft taco uses a single tortilla, so not a sandwich. A hard taco is meat and veg inside a tortilla chip.

[Galloism]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

Well, for the double slicers, a taco wouldn’t be a sandwich.

However, a Mexican pizza would.

[Aureumterra]

By the logic of a sandwich being any sweet or savory thing between grain, a lasagna would be a sandwich

[Galloism]

By the logic of a sandwich being any sweet or savory thing between grain, a lasagna would be a sandwich

Well, a lasagna does have multiple layers of bread disconnected from each other.

[Dytarma]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count as a sandwich? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

No, a taco is not a sandwich.

Yeah, I thought that.

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

Well, for the double slicers, a taco wouldn’t be a sandwich.

However, a Mexican pizza would.

I love some Mexican pizza, it's very good.

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

Hot dog tacos ... very interesting.

I just now thought of the Spaghetti Taco from iCarly when thinking of weird food combinations.

[Katganistan]

Back to the hotdog, would a taco also not count? They share surprisingly a lot of things in common.

Well, for the double slicers, a taco wouldn’t be a sandwich.

However, a Mexican pizza would.

Hmm. I'd have to agree, although it does lose the "able to be picked up and eaten by hand" quality. Then again, there are open-faced sandwiches, so that should not be a disqualifier.

[Katganistan]

By the logic of a sandwich being any sweet or savory thing between grain, a lasagna would be a sandwich

Bread. And it would be disastrous to try to pick up and eat by hand.

[Galloism]

By the logic of a sandwich being any sweet or savory thing between grain, a lasagna would be a sandwich

Bread. And it would be disastrous to try to pick up and eat by hand.

Where’s your sense of adventure?

[Luziyca]

It is indeed a sandwich, though let's hope that we don't go anywhere more cursed.

There’s always sandwich options without bread:

On a tangential note, thank you for giving me my revenge to the delegate declaring pineapple pizza the OG pizza in Esquarium.

I don't think pizzas are sandwiches, but at least I am satisfied with the way things turned out.

[Dogmeat]

Bread. And it would be disastrous to try to pick up and eat by hand.

Where’s your sense of adventure?

I don't use my hands at all when I eat.

[Galloism]

Where’s your sense of adventure?

I don't use my hands at all when I eat.

That sounds very challenging.

[Neo Confederate States]

SCREW U GUYS I JUST ATE AND NOW IM HUNGRY AGAIN CUZ OF ALL THIS CRAP!

[Katganistan]

Bread. And it would be disastrous to try to pick up and eat by hand.

Where’s your sense of adventure?

Experience in an Italian-American family watching kidlets eat lasagna by hand tells me this will end poorly -- or with a commercial about washing machines or laundry detergent with stain fighting power.

[Katganistan]

SCREW U GUYS I JUST ATE AND NOW IM HUNGRY AGAIN CUZ OF ALL THIS CRAP!

EAT MOAR.