Iceland To Ban Male Circumcision

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Goes against Judaism.

And?

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Goes against Judaism.

Who says i am against Judaism?

Who says that's what I'm saying?

[Holt]

Who says i am against Judaism?

Who says that's what I'm saying?

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

[Holy Tedalonia]

Aren't flu shots given to children regardless of consent if the parent wants it done?

No, parents can give or not give consent to their children getting shots.

I'm asking if the parent decides to give the child a flu shot the kids consent doesn't matter.

[Ors Might]

And?

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

They do. They just shouldn’t have the right to cut pieces off of their children.

[Holt]

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

They do. They just shouldn’t have the right to cut pieces off of their children.

Exactly!

[Holy Tedalonia]

Who says that's what I'm saying?

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

I like your idea as a suitable alternative, but I don't think it follows the Jewish mandate, they'd still be angry. The problem isn't even that big to really seek a policy though to be honest. I find it much better if a parent just decides to give them a choice rather than a law mandating it.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

No, parents can give or not give consent to their children getting shots.

I'm asking if the parent decides to give the child a flu shot the kids consent doesn't matter.

Idk about that, but I'm pretty sure the parent has the final say.

Who says that's what I'm saying?

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

Does you proposal go or everyone or are Jews exempted from the law?

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

They do. They just shouldn’t have the right to cut pieces off of their children.

So, they don't have the right to practice their religion.

[Holt]

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

I like your idea as a suitable alternative, but I don't think it follows the Jewish mandate, they'd still be angry. The problem isn't even that big to really seek a policy though to be honest. I find it much better if a parent just decides to give them a choice rather than a law mandating it.

I understand your point, but sadly we can't decide above the government

[Ors Might]

I'm asking if the parent decides to give the child a flu shot the kids consent doesn't matter.

Idk about that, but I'm pretty sure the parent has the final say.

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

Does you proposal go or everyone or are Jews exempted from the law?

They do. They just shouldn’t have the right to cut pieces off of their children.

So, they don't have the right to practice their religion.

If their religion requires them to mutilate people without consent, I’d rather they didn’t practice those bits. Mutilation is bad.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Idk about that, but I'm pretty sure the parent has the final say.

Does you proposal go or everyone or are Jews exempted from the law?

So, they don't have the right to practice their religion.

If their religion requires them to mutilate people without consent, I’d rather they didn’t practice those bits. Mutilation is bad.

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

[Holt]

I'm asking if the parent decides to give the child a flu shot the kids consent doesn't matter.

Idk about that, but I'm pretty sure the parent has the final say.

"Goes against Judaism", look i am Catholic, but i believe that at the age of 16, they can take the choice if they want to be circumcised or not

Does you proposal go or everyone or are Jews exempted from the law?

They do. They just shouldn’t have the right to cut pieces off of their children.

So, they don't have the right to practice their religion.

That has nothing to do with religion, i know that if you are 16, you can make decisions of your own body without having regrets and/or traumas. These babies are screaming murder! That's ridicilous!

[Fartsniffage]

If their religion requires them to mutilate people without consent, I’d rather they didn’t practice those bits. Mutilation is bad.

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Holy loaded question Batman!

[Ors Might]

If their religion requires them to mutilate people without consent, I’d rather they didn’t practice those bits. Mutilation is bad.

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

I don’t support ritual human sacrifice and I doubt you do either. Clearly freedom of religion isn’t absolute, unless you want to defend the Aztecs.

[Holt]

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Holy loaded question Batman!

[Holt]

If their religion requires them to mutilate people without consent, I’d rather they didn’t practice those bits. Mutilation is bad.

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

[El-Amin Caliphate]

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

Until said 'mutilation' involves a religious practice.

[Aureumterra]

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

Exactly

[Aureumterra]

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

Until said ‘mutilation' involves a religious practice.

Which harms the human body

[Holt]

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

Until said 'mutilation' involves a religious practice.

Doesn't matter, mutilation of a freaking child is never good and shouldn't be allowed

[Ifreann]

And?

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

But I shouldn't have the right to practice my religion of being given beer on other people's dime. Because Jews can remove the foreskins of their children, but I can't remove money from people's wallets.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

And Jews should have the right to practice their religion

But I shouldn't have the right to practice my religion of being given beer on other people's dime. Because Jews can remove the foreskins of their children, but I can't remove money from people's wallets.

Considering this religion doesn't even exist and you don't adhere to it, technically "no".

[Ors Might]

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

Until said 'mutilation' involves a religious practice.

Do you consider banning ritualistic human sacrifice a violation of religious freedoms?

[Holy Tedalonia]

So, you don't support freedom of religion?

Banning mutilation has nothing to do with being against freedom of religion

People have differing opinions on Freedom of Religion. The education system in America explains it as the separation of church and state.

I believe that freedom of religion allows people to practice their religion unless they infringe on someone's rights.

[El-Amin Caliphate]

Until said 'mutilation' involves a religious practice.

Do you consider banning ritualistic human sacrifice a violation of religious freedoms?

Technically yes.