Arlenton wrote:Uiiop wrote:What is the issue with proportional?
It's perfectly legal and according to what you linked seems even fairer than both compact methods.
But i guess you didn't really say what you meant by "Fair".
Proportional works too. It is perfectly fair. But everyone seems stuck on using single member districts.
And I really only consider 100% population based algorithms fair when drawing districts.
Question: If the 538 showed blue mainly, would you support it?