Transgender Discussion Thread III: Vote in our poll!

[Liriena]

That is merely propaganda.

Turning your genitals inside out doesn't make you a woman.

#nowthatswhaticalledgy

Also, that's some lame ass girldick erasure on his part.

[Grenartia]

The scientific field of psychology.

That is merely propaganda.

Turning your genitals inside out doesn't make you a woman.

If actual fucking scientists won't convince you, then you're beyond all use of reason.

[Grenartia]

#nowthatswhaticalledgy

Also, that's some lame ass girldick erasure on his part.

【ＭＯＵＴＨＦＥＥＬ】

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

That is merely propaganda.

Turning your genitals inside out doesn't make you a woman.

If actual fucking scientists won't convince you, then you're beyond all use of reason.

The actual scientists are either silenced, or choose to take a back seat to political ideology.

#nowthatswhaticalledgy

Also, that's some lame ass girldick erasure on his part.

If theres anything I don't like about the 4chan and anime subcultures, it is their obsession with 'girl'dicks, even right wing people who I otherwise agree with 99%. Its frusturating

[Vassenor]

If actual fucking scientists won't convince you, then you're beyond all use of reason.

The actual scientists are either silenced, or choose to take a back seat to political ideology.

Prove it then.

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

The actual scientists are either silenced, or choose to take a back seat to political ideology.

Prove it then.

David Reimer is a historic and tragic example.

[Vassenor]

Prove it then.

David Reimer is a historic and tragic example.

So what you're saying is we shouldn't force someone to be the gender they are not against their will? Nice to see you agree with us.

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

David Reimer is a historic and tragic example.

So what you're saying is we shouldn't force someone to be the gender they are not against their will? Nice to see you agree with us.

No, what im saying is that doctors and parents shouldnt force transgenderism on their children

[Vassenor]

So what you're saying is we shouldn't force someone to be the gender they are not against their will? Nice to see you agree with us.

No, what im saying is that doctors and parents shouldnt force transgenderism on their children

Which no-one does. What your example proves is forcing people to live in a gender that they are not is bad.

[Revanchism]

Why are you all feeding the troll?

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

No, what im saying is that doctors and parents shouldnt force transgenderism on their children

Which no-one does. What your example proves is forcing people to live in a gender that they are not is bad.

Which is exactly what progressives and leftists keep pushing for.

[Vassenor]

Which no-one does. What your example proves is forcing people to live in a gender that they are not is bad.

Which is exactly what progressives and leftists keep pushing for.

Letting people be who they are is bad? That's not what your example says.

[Ifreann]

There are only 2 genders

Factually incorrect.

Technically Correct
Factually Incorrect
Wronger Than Wrong

The three genders.

---

The scientific field of psychology.

That is merely propaganda.

Turning your genitals inside out doesn't make you a woman.

It's interesting that you phrase it that way, because humans begin our development as anatomically female and after a certain point in the pregnancy our hormones kick in and we either stay female or develop male anatomy.

So if one has a penis and testicles then one's genitals are, in a sense, already inside-out.

---

Why are you all feeding the troll?

Lulz.

[Dumb Ideologies]

Why are you all feeding the troll?

If we don't scream loudly at every low-effort technicolour yawn that gets spewed into the bowl then how will anyone know how proud and absolutely not emotionally insecure we all are?

That said, as well as not feeding it, the optimal red-text-free path also involves reporting it rather than naming it.

[Liriena]

Prove it then.

David Reimer is a historic and tragic example.

Yeah, a historic and tragic example of why you can't unilaterally force a child to identify with a gender just to cover for a past medical mishap. Which, if anything, is a pretty good argument for respecting both cisgender and transgender people's gender identities.

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

David Reimer is a historic and tragic example.

Yeah, a historic and tragic example of why you can't unilaterally force a child to identify with a gender just to cover for a past medical mishap. Which, if anything, is a pretty good argument for respecting both cisgender and transgender people's gender identities.

And people still don't understand what I'm saying.

David was a boy forced to be a girl. The man in charge of the whole procedure, Dr John Money was a man who pushed for the same shit that the transgenderists push today, the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological reality

[Vassenor]

Yeah, a historic and tragic example of why you can't unilaterally force a child to identify with a gender just to cover for a past medical mishap. Which, if anything, is a pretty good argument for respecting both cisgender and transgender people's gender identities.

And people still don't understand what I'm saying.

David was a boy forced to be a girl. The man in charge of the whole procedure, Dr John Money was a man who pushed for the same shit that the transgenderists push today, the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological reality

Maybe in your fantasy world. The only people doing the forcing now are the conservatives.

[Anarcho capitalist utopia]

And people still don't understand what I'm saying.

David was a boy forced to be a girl. The man in charge of the whole procedure, Dr John Money was a man who pushed for the same shit that the transgenderists push today, the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological reality

Maybe in your fantasy world. The only people doing the forcing now are the conservatives.

Dr money wrote several books on gender. Many of his ideas are mainstream in the transgender movement.

And this is exactly what the transgenderists pushes for today

[Philjia]

Yeah, a historic and tragic example of why you can't unilaterally force a child to identify with a gender just to cover for a past medical mishap. Which, if anything, is a pretty good argument for respecting both cisgender and transgender people's gender identities.

And people still don't understand what I'm saying.

David was a boy forced to be a girl. The man in charge of the whole procedure, Dr John Money was a man who pushed for the same shit that the transgenderists push today, the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological reality

Nah, it's the feminists who hate transpeople who make that assertion.

[Liriena]

Yeah, a historic and tragic example of why you can't unilaterally force a child to identify with a gender just to cover for a past medical mishap. Which, if anything, is a pretty good argument for respecting both cisgender and transgender people's gender identities.

And people still don't understand what I'm saying.

David was a boy forced to be a girl.

We know. And that was very shitty.

The man in charge of the whole procedure, Dr John Money was a man who pushed for the same shit that the transgenderists push today, the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological reality

Except that trans activists and professionals don't advocate for forcing pre-pubescent children to become trans, let alone undergo any sort of surgery. If you bothered to read that trans activists and professional organizations are actually advocating for, maybe you'd know.

[Vassenor]

Maybe in your fantasy world. The only people doing the forcing now are the conservatives.

Dr money wrote several books on gender. Many of his ideas are mainstream in the transgender movement.

And this is exactly what the transgenderists pushes for today

Oh, a website run by social conservatives said it. Guess it must be true.

[Liriena]

Maybe in your fantasy world. The only people doing the forcing now are the conservatives.

Dr money wrote several books on gender. Many of his ideas are mainstream in the transgender movement.

And this is exactly what the transgenderists pushes for today

lifesitenews

Nope.

[Vassenor]

Dr money wrote several books on gender. Many of his ideas are mainstream in the transgender movement.

And this is exactly what the transgenderists pushes for today

lifesitenews

Nope.

I smell Kool-aid. Does anyone else smell Kool-aid?

[Liriena]

Dr money wrote several books on gender. Many of his ideas are mainstream in the transgender movement.

And this is exactly what the transgenderists pushes for today

Oh, a website run by social conservatives said it. Guess it must be true.

To be fair, the article does link to a website that appears to have actual court documents. But it looks to me like lifesitenews might be misleading in its assessment of what went on with this child.

[Vassenor]

Oh, a website run by social conservatives said it. Guess it must be true.

To be fair, the article does link to a website that appears to have actual court documents. But it looks to me like lifesitenews might be misleading in its assessment of what went on with this child.

So I'm guessing it's "Mum sues dad for not respecting daughter's identity"?