Natapoc wrote:
It works very well thank you. You sure seem upset about something. Do you dislike challenges to illegitimate authority structures? Are you bigoted against youth? What is wrong?
You know, the trouble I find with youth, including some of the students I have taught, is that they complain loudest about being disrespected and treated like children when they are being treated like the adults they insist on being treated as. My current group of students, by and large, live on isolated cattle, sheep and crop properties, where they from a very young age have been involved in mustering, shearing, butchering, fencing, harvesting and a range of other related activities. Funnily enough, they seem to understand the way the world works a lot better than most students far older than them. I think it might be that they have actually experienced the real world and understand that if someone is in a position of authority, its usually because they have a reason - they know more than you do, or they have more experience in the area. They also learnt pretty damn quickly that if you're being told to do something, there is a reason for it. If they do have a question about why they have to do something, they tend to wait until after and ask me quietly. Which demonstrates respect for my position. And tends to get them a more mature, thoughtful and complete answer than the idiots who think they are tough by asking me in front of the whole class in a challenging tone.
Its not about challenging authority structures. My students are quite willing to challenge me on areas outside my authority when need be. But when I am supervising or teaching these students in my current school, they tend to respect that. They don't ask for an explanation on why they can't talk during a test, or why they have to sit together on the mat while I talk to them or whine about having to do their work. They just get on with the job.