Heinleinites wrote:Muravyets wrote:I haven't read the rest of the thread yet, so apologies if this was already touched on, but this is one of those examples of legend overtaking history. In fact, several people were rescued from the doomed Donner Party after the end of the winter, but the reality of the story is way weirder and more freak-worthy than the legends. In fact, the real story ends with almost a punchline, involving the allegedly most avid of the cannibals getting rescued, making it at last to California, and...opening a restaurant. I kid you not.
There's always one person who has to throw cold water on the ghost story
You ever see The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance? Great movie, and germane to the subject. There's a quote in there, at the very end, "When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
Ah, but that non-ghostly reality did in fact generate a new legend. This one an old 19th-20th century urban legend about restaurants that serve human flesh. The basic form of the legend is always about a restaurant with a strong word of mouth reputation for being amazingly good and having the most talented chef in town. It's located in a seedy part of town and is very hard to find but well worth the effort. Its food is exotic, though, and the owners, chef and staff are all foreigners who don't speak English. People wait months to get a table there, and the most coveted privilege of all is to be offered a tour of the kitchen... only it's a privilege you wouldn't want if you knew how it would end.
This legend reached its fictionalized apex with the mystery writer Stanley Ellin's 1948 short story "The Specialty of the House." It's a legend about xenophobia and the fear of taboo, alien food. The original stories were all about the immigrant communities of San Francisco, where the guy from the Donner Party ended up opening his business, but over time spread out to other cities that saw waves of immigration. The Donner party member was from Germany, but later versions of the story got more race-oriented, adding racism to xenophobia.