1 Civilian Girl vs 10 Soldiers

[The Grene Knyght]

I'd save the girl and kill 10 soldiers - purely because I want to save the largest amount of innocent lives

[G-Max]

The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few. I let the civilian die.

[The Empire of Pretantia]

I'd save the girl and kill 10 soldiers - purely because I want to save the largest amount of innocent lives

So... Why are you killing ten people instead of one? I mean ten soldiers? In all likelihood only one or two of them is combat arms.

[Uxupox]

I'd save the girl and kill 10 soldiers - purely because I want to save the largest amount of innocent lives

There is no innocence only degrees of guilt.

[The Empire of Pretantia]

I'd save the girl and kill 10 soldiers - purely because I want to save the largest amount of innocent lives

There is no innocence only degrees of guilt.

The Emperor protects, battle-brother.

[Uxupox]

There is no innocence only degrees of guilt.

The Emperor protects, battle-brother.

Your false emperor has no power here.

[The Weapons Board]

Shoot the demon until I am unable to shoot, presumably it either dies or kills me. If it does neither, then I will wait it out until I die or it leaves. Thusly, I have minimized casualties, and if I live, I can say I fought a demon and lived!(not that anyone'd believe me)

[The Empire of Pretantia]

Shoot the demon until I am unable to shoot, presumably it either dies or kills me. If it does neither, then I will wait it out until I die or it leaves. Thusly, I have minimized casualties, and if I live, I can say I fought a demon and lived!(not that anyone'd believe me)

Alright there, marine.

[Imsogone]

There's this thing about life - people die: all the time, every day. Civilians die, soldiers die.They can do it without me playing deity.

[Nasjonal Regjering Norge]

i choose 3: both

[The Grene Knyght]

JUst to clarify, there's no option to kill more than 10 US soldiers, is there?

[The Alexanderians]

JUst to clarify, there's no option to kill more than 10 US soldiers, is there?

Why would you want to?

[Greed and Death]

How hot is the girl ?

[Skyviolia]

One dead is better than ten.

[The Intergalactic Universe Corporation]

Agreed.

[Quokkastan]

How hot is the girl ?

Corollary: how hot is the demon?

[Albertae]

JUst to clarify, there's no option to kill more than 10 US soldiers, is there?

Why.. Why would you ever say that?

[Greed and Death]

How hot is the girl ?

Corollary: how hot is the demon?

You have not lived until you've been bed by a succubus.

[The Grene Knyght]

JUst to clarify, there's no option to kill more than 10 US soldiers, is there?

Why.. Why would you ever say that?

Well I mean, this is a purely hypothetical situation. In hindsight my response was a little inappropriate, but like the US military is pretty evil.....

[Threlizdun]

I'd save the girl and kill 10 soldiers - purely because I want to save the largest amount of innocent lives

Stop. Don't try to prove your anarchist ideological purity by talking about killing soldiers like it's no loss. These are people in one of the most traumatizing professions in existence. Most of them are lower class and looking for one of the most extensive support networks the state provides. These are people. They have their reasons for being there. The institution of the military has proven mostly harmful, but the moment we forget that there human beings that compose is it is the moment all the rhetoric becomes meaningless.

[Impireacht]

The 10 soldiers, of course.
10 Soldiers will go on to protect our country, and could very well be just as "innocent" as the girl, never having actually killed. Or, those they killed could have had intention to kill even more people. The random American girl contributes far less to the nation, society, and worldwide peace. I believe the only reason that the girl has so many people saving her is the use of the word "girl" which is usually tied to words and ideas like "innocence" or "purity", had the OP said "woman" or "female" there would likely be far less people selecting that option.

[Impireacht]

Why.. Why would you ever say that?

Well I mean, this is a purely hypothetical situation. In hindsight my response was a little inappropriate, but like the US military is pretty evil.....

Just because you think the military is evil and corrupt doesn't mean the average soldier is - they're people too. The girl could be ten times more evil. He never said which girl, you could have just killed ten innocent soldiers who have never even seen combat and saved the life of a serial killer.

[Unified Heartless States]

You did not set this situation up properly.
Simply not choosing is the best option.
If the demon kills the girl, record it.
Demon goes to jail, America. . .

[The Alexanderians]

Well I mean, this is a purely hypothetical situation. In hindsight my response was a little inappropriate, but like the US military is pretty evil.....

Just because you think the military is evil and corrupt doesn't mean the average soldier is - they're people too. The girl could be ten times more evil. He never said which girl, you could have just killed ten innocent soldiers who have never even seen combat and saved the life of a serial killer.

Nevermind that combat experience isn't a requisite for good or evil.

[Mike the Progressive]

Hmm. This smells like a school project.