Bentrada wrote:United Marxist Nations wrote:It is... arguable. An Empire is just a collection of nations under control of a single government. Whether the US is an Empire depends on whether you can consider it to govern multiple nations. Given the Indigenous nations, it could certainly qualify. There are few states today which are not empires.
Given the definitions (all of which are controversial) of what a nation is, any diverse state could be called an empire. Canada? Empire. Brazil? Empire. Indonesia? Empire.
Until there is a standard, agreed upon definition of the concepts of a "empire" and "nation", it is a largely meaningless term.
For the most part, by the usual definitions, these states are Empires. We live in an era where states have grown to absorb their neighbors to the point that many states are empires. It must be understood that, in an empire, there should be a dominant nationality, by which I mean in terms of political power, not necessarily demographic size.



