Advertisement

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:52 am

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:53 am

by The Emerald Dawn » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:54 am

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:56 am

by The United Colonies of Earth » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:56 am

by Mavorpen » Tue Feb 03, 2015 9:58 am
Escasia wrote: Segregation and slavery were still in place until fairly recently (in terms of generations) and affected huge amounts of people as well as their descendants indirectly. it's not really surprising that those things still have effects today.

by Escasia » Tue Feb 03, 2015 10:04 am
The Cobalt Sky wrote:Escasia wrote:On the "black people are filling up our jails" thing:
Black people are likely to be poorer than white people due to the circumstances which brought many of their families to the United States.
You've still ignored the 20% longer prison sentences for similar crimes.
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241 ... 3789858002The average person isn't going to be much richer or poorer than their parents, and most of the African-American population was forced to start at the bottom of the system. Segregation and slavery were still in place until fairly recently (in terms of generations) and affected huge amounts of people as well as their descendants indirectly. it's not really surprising that those things still have effects today.
Still doesn't warrant THAT much of a disparity with how many of us make up the US population and how many of us make up the US prison system population, unless you're operating under the assumption that ALL poor people are criminals.Poorer people are more likely to commit crime out of desperation, frustration or necessity and more likely to get convicted than richer people because they lack the resources to defend themselves as effectively in court.
Source that. At what rate? To what degree?Institutional racism compounds the likelihood of black people being convicted for a crime and getting a harsher sentence. It also produces a feeling of resentment among young black people which may also lead to more crime.
Wait, you just admit there's institutional racism, but the point of your argument is to say that it's not actually a big factor?That's why black people are more likely to end up in jail than white people.
You haven't proven this, and you still clearly didn't read the part about racial profiling done by police.It's important not to view people in isolation from their circumstances or we end up attributing all sorts of unreasonable things to race/genetics. The problem's systemic, not racial as some would claim.
No. The problem is that the system is racist.
Mavorpen wrote:Escasia wrote: Segregation and slavery were still in place until fairly recently (in terms of generations) and affected huge amounts of people as well as their descendants indirectly. it's not really surprising that those things still have effects today.
On what planet do you live? It can't be this one, because de facto segregation still exists.

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 10:17 am
Escasia wrote:The Cobalt Sky wrote:You've still ignored the 20% longer prison sentences for similar crimes.
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241 ... 3789858002
Still doesn't warrant THAT much of a disparity with how many of us make up the US population and how many of us make up the US prison system population, unless you're operating under the assumption that ALL poor people are criminals.
Source that. At what rate? To what degree?
Wait, you just admit there's institutional racism, but the point of your argument is to say that it's not actually a big factor?
You haven't proven this, and you still clearly didn't read the part about racial profiling done by police.
No. The problem is that the system is racist.
Umm. Did you even read my post properly? We've got the same point of view. I think class ties into it too but institutional racism is also a very large factor.
The idea that the system is racist is pretty implicit in what I said.
Had to edit this post a lot because I can already imagine people jumping on some tiny wording to accuse me of an opinion I don't actually hold.

by Escasia » Tue Feb 03, 2015 10:30 am
The Cobalt Sky wrote:Ah, I got more of a 'institutional racism is a problem, but class is way MORE of a problem' vibe. Sorry about that.
I didn't think it was too implicit, but sorry about that. I kinda jumped the gun on that one, because if you read through the posts (towards the beginning) you'll see two people advocating for freaking apartheid.
I thought I read it wrong and I did, but Mavorpen didn't really get you either so maybe it's wording too? I don't know. Either way, sorry! I'll erase my post.


by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 10:55 am
Escasia wrote:The Cobalt Sky wrote:Ah, I got more of a 'institutional racism is a problem, but class is way MORE of a problem' vibe. Sorry about that.
That's alright, just a misunderstanding. Maybe I worded it oddly or something, no harm done.
I wouldn't say class is more of a problem and I certainly couldn't quantify either class or racism in that way. I have a hunch the two problems are deeply related and better understood alongside one another, (although I admit it's just that, a hunch and not much more) but institutional racism certainly isn't a small (or even moderate) problem by any measure. It's massive.
I didn't think it was too implicit, but sorry about that. I kinda jumped the gun on that one, because if you read through the posts (towards the beginning) you'll see two people advocating for freaking apartheid.
I'll try to be clearer on that next time, then. I see where I should have worded stuff differently and I understand why you'd jump the gun, I've done the same way too many times.
I thought I read it wrong and I did, but Mavorpen didn't really get you either so maybe it's wording too? I don't know. Either way, sorry! I'll erase my post.
Nah don't be sorry, my wording was probably off. No need to erase your post, haha. Was just surprised I got jumped on by someone I'd generally consider to be "on the same side" on this issue.

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 10:59 am

by Patridam » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:10 am

by Romalae » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:13 am
The Cobalt Sky wrote:I have a theory that many people are racist, but are closeted about it. I think that the stigma of a racist is sort of an irrational brute, someone who anyone of any race couldn't stand to be around because they're such a jerk. But it seems unlikely that that's what ALL racists are. I think they can be kind and caring people, people who you'd never really suspect, and would never want to admit are racists, and we go into denial about who they really are.

by Reynoso » Tue Feb 03, 2015 11:26 am

by Patridam » Tue Feb 03, 2015 12:37 pm
Reynoso wrote:A solution to racism could be education. Most racial stereotypes are unfounded and can apply to any group. Stuff like Jews are greedy, Mexicans are lazy, Asians are bad at driving can literally be said about ANY GROUP OR PERSON. Once people can become informed enough where they can see how irrational the hatred was, they may become at least a little less racist.
Also, racism comes from a fear of the unknown. Most people fear Islam but have no idea what Islam really teaches or is about. In this case, education is also the solution because people will be able to learn about other cultures and see that other races' cultures are more similar and beautiful than they had first imagined.

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 12:52 pm
Patridam wrote:Seeing this debate has seemed to end in 'agreement' that modern disparity falls upon systemic racism; what sort of solution would anyone propose? Telling people 'don't be racist' really hasn't seemed to do too much.

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 1:00 pm
Patridam wrote:Reynoso wrote:A solution to racism could be education. Most racial stereotypes are unfounded and can apply to any group. Stuff like Jews are greedy, Mexicans are lazy, Asians are bad at driving can literally be said about ANY GROUP OR PERSON. Once people can become informed enough where they can see how irrational the hatred was, they may become at least a little less racist.
Also, racism comes from a fear of the unknown. Most people fear Islam but have no idea what Islam really teaches or is about. In this case, education is also the solution because people will be able to learn about other cultures and see that other races' cultures are more similar and beautiful than they had first imagined.
Education against racism is already extremely prevalent in the united states, our school system especially stresses the unfortunate circumstances perpetuated against minorities through the years (slavery, segregation, land theft, stereotyping...). High school history courses explain the differences between the two large sects of Islam, etc. What else would you suggest be done?

by Saiwania » Tue Feb 03, 2015 1:04 pm
Patridam wrote:Education against racism is already extremely prevalent in the united states, our school system especially stresses the unfortunate circumstances perpetuated against minorities through the years. High school history courses explain the differences between the two large sects of Islam, etc. What else would you suggest be done?

by Infected Mushroom » Tue Feb 03, 2015 1:06 pm
The Cobalt Sky wrote:Hi there. This is my first real discussion thread, so if it comes out lopsided, I’ll work on a new one and come back later. I hope that there isn't another thread out there that covers this one, and I looked but I didn't see one. In case you’re wondering, I’m 14, one half black, and one half white. Apparently, there is some Native American in there somewhere, but I’m not really Native American, and I do not claim to understand their experience in America whatsoever and I do not know what it is like to be one at all. But anyway, I think that lately, people have been saying racism is not a problem. But I think that it is, and a very serious one at that. I point to the criminal justice system, which a lot of people apparently don’t think has any racial problems.
“The survey, which was mostly conducted before the shooting of NYPD Officers Wenjian Liu and Rafael Ramos in New York over the weekend, found similar results on perceptions of the justice system as a whole. While 41% of Americans say the criminal justice system treats blacks fairly, far more whites - 50% - see equity. Among non-whites, that figure drops to just 21%. Two-thirds of non-whites said that the criminal justice system favors whites over blacks.”
http://www.cnn.com/2014/12/22/politics/ ... e-justice/
But it definitely seems to have problems.
“Prison sentences of black men were nearly 20% longer than those of white men for similar crimes in recent years, an analysis by the U.S. Sentencing Commission found.”
http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241 ... 3789858002
http://www.vox.com/2014/7/1/5850830/war ... minorities
“Approximately 12%-13% of the American population is African-American, but they make up 40% of the almost 2.1 million male inmates in jail or prison (U.S. Department of Justice, 2009).[1]”
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statistics ... ican_males
There are also many issues with racial profiling.
“For every 10,000 residents, about 3,400 more black people are stopped than whites, and 360 more Latinos are stopped than whites. Stopped blacks are 127% more likely to be frisked -- and stopped Latinos are 43% more likely to be frisked -- than stopped whites. Stopped blacks are 76% more likely to be searched, and stopped Latinos are 16% more likely to be searched than stopped whites.
Stopped blacks are 29% more likely to be arrested, and stopped Latinos are 32% more likely to be arrested than stopped whites.
Now consider this: Although stopped blacks were 127% more likely to be frisked than stopped whites, they were 42.3% less likely to be found with a weapon after they were frisked, 25% less likely to be found with drugs and 33% less likely to be found with other contraband. We found similar patterns for Latinos.
Not only did we find that African Americans and Latinos were subjected to more stops, frisks, searches and arrests than whites, we also found that these additional police actions aren't because of the fact that people of color live in higher-crime areas or because they more often carry drugs or weapons, or any other legitimate reason that we can discern from the rich set of data we examined.”
http://articles.latimes.com/2008/oct/23 ... oe-ayres23
And, with the advent of DNA technology, tons of people were exonerated. The vast majority of the wrongfully convicted were black.
http://www.innocenceproject.org/Content ... onwide.php
A few other links to consider:
https://www.americanprogress.org/issues ... ed-states/
http://www.sentencingproject.org/templa ... cfm?id=122
After looking through this, I’d say race is still a pretty serious problem in the US, and not talking about it won’t solve anything, just make it worse. I think people are touchy and uncomfortable when it comes to talking about race, because there’s a chance they could be called racist, and a racist is something that society at large generally says is bad, although I think tons of people are still racist. But this wouldn’t be much of a thread if I didn’t ask: what do you think? What racist experiences have you gone through?
EDIT:
Let me revise this, so people can post a little bit more.
A problem, but how serious a problem? Who do you think is its source? How ingrained is it? Are you a racist? (I want a little more than the generic statement, 'yes, it's a problem')

by Infected Mushroom » Tue Feb 03, 2015 1:08 pm

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:13 pm
Saiwania wrote:Patridam wrote:Education against racism is already extremely prevalent in the united states, our school system especially stresses the unfortunate circumstances perpetuated against minorities through the years. High school history courses explain the differences between the two large sects of Islam, etc. What else would you suggest be done?
Don't forget that if a school shoves it down people's throats that racism is bad too much, it might just drive some people to be racist who wouldn't be otherwise.

by Patridam » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:15 pm
The Cobalt Sky wrote:Maybe touch on it a little more. School systems seem to be somewhat avoiding it. Apparently a few in Texas have decided to call the trans-Atlantic slave trade the the Atlantic triangular trade, conveniently omitting the bit about slavery, although I think they changed it back. It might not seem like much, but it's the small things that can end up being big and then detrimental. History is sacred, and to know who your ancestors really were, no matter how much it hurts, I believe, is one's sacred duty in life, along with building society for the benefit of everyone.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bryan-mon ... 86633.html
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/2 ... 24157.html
Infected Mushroom wrote:To simplify... what I am saying is...
Why does the fact that certain groups get searched more often, get convicted in court more often, and stay in prison longer PROVE that there is racism?
Couldn't it be that this is simply a government response to there being more crime in certain neighbourhoods?

by The Cobalt Sky » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:18 pm
Infected Mushroom wrote:To simplify... what I am saying is...
Why does the fact that certain groups get searched more often, get convicted in court more often, and stay in prison longer PROVE that there is racism?

by Patridam » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:23 pm
The Cobalt Sky wrote:Infected Mushroom wrote:To simplify... what I am saying is...
Why does the fact that certain groups get searched more often, get convicted in court more often, and stay in prison longer PROVE that there is racism?
The prison length is for crimes that are similar, meaning that the crimes are similar enough that that shouldn't be the case, and the time given to spend in prison should be around the same. Being searched more often is a sign of racism, since blacks and whites should be searched around the same amount.
“For every 10,000 residents, about 3,400 more black people are stopped than whites, and 360 more Latinos are stopped than whites. Stopped blacks are 127% more likely to be frisked -- and stopped Latinos are 43% more likely to be frisked -- than stopped whites. Stopped blacks are 76% more likely to be searched, and stopped Latinos are 16% more likely to be searched than stopped whites.
Stopped blacks are 29% more likely to be arrested, and stopped Latinos are 32% more likely to be arrested than stopped whites.
Now consider this: Although stopped blacks were 127% more likely to be frisked than stopped whites, they were 42.3% less likely to be found with a weapon after they were frisked, 25% less likely to be found with drugs and 33% less likely to be found with other contraband. We found similar patterns for Latinos.
Not only did we find that African Americans and Latinos were subjected to more stops, frisks, searches and arrests than whites, we also found that these additional police actions aren't because of the fact that people of color live in higher-crime areas or because they more often carry drugs or weapons, or any other legitimate reason that we can discern from the rich set of data we examined.”
http://articles.latimes.com/2008/oct/23 ... oe-ayres23

by Mavorpen » Tue Feb 03, 2015 2:28 pm
Patridam wrote:The Cobalt Sky wrote:The prison length is for crimes that are similar, meaning that the crimes are similar enough that that shouldn't be the case, and the time given to spend in prison should be around the same. Being searched more often is a sign of racism, since blacks and whites should be searched around the same amount.
“For every 10,000 residents, about 3,400 more black people are stopped than whites, and 360 more Latinos are stopped than whites. Stopped blacks are 127% more likely to be frisked -- and stopped Latinos are 43% more likely to be frisked -- than stopped whites. Stopped blacks are 76% more likely to be searched, and stopped Latinos are 16% more likely to be searched than stopped whites.
Stopped blacks are 29% more likely to be arrested, and stopped Latinos are 32% more likely to be arrested than stopped whites.
Now consider this: Although stopped blacks were 127% more likely to be frisked than stopped whites, they were 42.3% less likely to be found with a weapon after they were frisked, 25% less likely to be found with drugs and 33% less likely to be found with other contraband. We found similar patterns for Latinos.
Not only did we find that African Americans and Latinos were subjected to more stops, frisks, searches and arrests than whites, we also found that these additional police actions aren't because of the fact that people of color live in higher-crime areas or because they more often carry drugs or weapons, or any other legitimate reason that we can discern from the rich set of data we examined.”
http://articles.latimes.com/2008/oct/23 ... oe-ayres23
It's on the front page, you don't need to copy it every single time.
I would counter that they are searched more often because they are more likely to live in high crime areas. A much larger portion of whites live in posh suburbs - police don't go around frisking people in areas like that, because there isn't much crime like there is in the inner city. This source of yours simply says 'it's not because of that' without providing an explanation of how they know.
Advertisement
Users browsing this forum: Abaro, Bradfordville, Dimetrodon Empire, Dtn, Eternal Algerstonia, Ethel mermania, Gallade, Heavenly Assault, Isla of Maktoy, New Ciencia, Nilokeras, Old Temecula, The Notorious Mad Jack, Urkennalaid, Utquiagvik, Vassenor, Xind
Advertisement