Is genocide ever justified?

[Rio de Fuego]

No, it's really not when it comes to territorial disputes.

Try again.

Yes, it is, because it is the Word of God.

To quote you

Prove it

[Viritica]

That's... Gonna cause a shitload of unnecessary tension.

Just leave the two states at their current size.

It makes sense their are more Palestinians and their claim isn't founded in a book they like

In the current State of Israel the Jews compose a vast majority.

Just leave the borders like they are now.

[Cu Math]

Genocide is never justified unless, as stated on the first page the last person from a race tried to kill you and you killed him/her in self defence. However switching over to the topic of Palestine, I would just like to point out the fact that name comes from a Hebrew word that actually means invader. Just saying.

So do many first nations tribe names.
They still live in their lands. Can't just up and kill them all.

[Parhe]

All land should belong to everyone.

But no, genocide is never justified.

Why not?

I feel like many people have answered and you cherry pick the posts to reply to even though others answer your post and are valid points.

Prove it.

Without the Bible, please.

Becuase the Jews are the Chosen People of God. And of course the Holy Bible is a valid source.

Yeah yeah, chosen people. That explains the genocide, history of migration and oppression, and, uh, um, what? The Jewish people aren't that unique in experience and traditional beliefs.

[Wisconsin9]

Becuase the Jews are the Chosen People of God. And of course the Holy Bible is a valid source.

The 'Holy' Bible is a valid source? Bitch the Gospel of the Flying Spaghetti Monster is a valid source.

Listen, if you want to be technical, Jews aren't some 'chosen people,' they were the chosen nation to one day birth a Messiah, promised in the covenant with Abraham. That DOES NOT mean they are better than anyone else.

Say no to racism

Except for pro-Jewish racism, because everyone should bow before the Jewish Master Race.

[Nanatsu no Tsuki]

And of course the Holy Bible is a valid source.

How so? If the Bible is a valid source, so is every religious text.

And considering Jesus and the apostles went forth and spread Christianity to other nations and peoples, you could say Christians are God's people too. If the Bible is to be considered as source.

[Geilinor]

No, it's really not when it comes to territorial disputes.

Try again.

Yes, it is, because it is the Word of God.

Said Word of God only applies to Christians.

[Viritica]

Prove it.

Without the Bible, please.

Becuase the Jews are the Chosen People of God. And of course the Holy Bible is a valid source.

Is the Quran a valid source?

[The Archregimancy]

I am locking this thread pending a review and further action.

Said further action may take some time due to a range of issues, but it will be dealt with today.

[The Archregimancy]

Apologies that this has taken a while.

First of all, you'll likely notice that the OP is no longer with us. This rapid insta-DEAT for someone without much of a previous record was instituted specifically for attempting to argue that genocide against an ethnic group that has members participating on this site (indeed, in this thread) is somehow justified; advocating mass murder against a ethnic group participating in these forums is no more acceptable than threatening violence against an individual poster.


That taken care of, there were several other incidents of actionable behaviour in this thread. While I'm not without sympathy to the fact that the OP was highly provocative (and this is a rare case where I feel a certain regret at handing out further warnings) there was no need to give in to that provocation.



Persian Soviet Republics:

No, the most horrible act that can be committed is the wiping out of the Jewish people. We are talking about potential genocide of [ur;=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Filastin]philistines[/url], not jews, here.

Of course genocide should be avoided at all costs but if it is needed as a last resort to restore peace and normality to the Jews of Israel, so be it. Population relocation is still preferable to genocide though.

Are you stupid? Jewish lives are not worth more than anybody else's lives what separates Zionist racial supremacism from that of the Nazis? What separates the need of a pure Jewish state from Hitler's pure Aryan state? You can't tell me the difference because all Zionists are is abunch of whining hypocrites. GO HOME

*** Warned for flaming / trolling ***




Planita

To all people who voted yes on the poll: You are an damn idiot

*** Warned for flaming. ***



I am going to let pass the multiple comparisons of the [allegedly] Jewish OP with Nazis / Hitler / etc. Given the specific circumstances, in this thread they weren't wholly unjustified.