Patridam wrote:Yumyumsuppertime wrote:
Why only first generation immigrants? You hear quite a bit about Irish-Americans during St. Patrick's Day, there are second and third-generation descendants of Mexican immigrants who refer to themselves as Mexican-American (or Latin American), and there are tons of people who refer to themselves as Italian-American despite never having been further east than the Jersey Shore. I have a few friends who refer to themselves as Scottish-American, and at least one has never seen the Highlands, contenting himself with wearing a kilt to formal functions.
"African-American" gives black Americans some sense of a shared ancestry, shared struggles, shared concerns, and a shared culture developed during and since slave times in a way that "black" does not. You may see this as unnecessary or ridiculous. I may not completely get it myself. Here's the thing: It's not up to either of us to make that call.
Now, let me turn it around: Why is this such an issue for you? What's wrong with using "African-American" rather than "Black", especially in journalism and in academia? What does it cost you? How does it cause you injury, or cause injury to those around you? How does this affect your life in the slightest, other than having to type a few extra letters on occasion? If prominent black people (including academics and community leaders) find the term more dignified than "black", and less clinical than "Negro", then why in the world wouldn't you say "Okay, African-American then" instead of wasting your energy fighting the change? Even if you don't have the sense of insight to understand why the term is preferable, do you at least have the sense of decency to go along with it so long as it doesn't cause you harm? It can't possibly be that difficult to remember the term, so that's not a real excuse.
1.) It leaves one with no term to refer to first generation immigrants from Africa to America
2.) Not all prominent blacks prefer the term. Bill Cosby comes to mind, indicating a black in America has almost no ties or relations to actual Africans. Heck, the NAACP still uses 'colored'
3.) A double standard is still in place; I can be called white or cracker with no repercussions (and indeed, I never really cared). Yet god forbid I use black, or even think about using the 'n-word', which only blacks have the privilege to use.
4.) If it was only this term I had to remember, it wouldn't be difficult to use it (despite the ungainly length compared to black), but it is not the only term PC wants you to remember, or forget, as the case may be. You must remember never to say oriental, mentally challenged, Easter, Christmas, negro, brainstorm, Indian, deaf, blind, manhole, policeman, fireman....
And then you must remember to replace them with Asian, intellectually impaired, Spring, Winter Holiday Season, <apparently there is no word for the color black in Spanish anymore>, though shower, Native American, hearing impaired, visually impaired, person hole, police officer, fire fighter... And then, you have to remember what all of those odd sexuality types are (pan?) and be sure to know the difference between gender and sex...
Yeah, no effort at all.
5.) My sense of decency says to stop what is rapidly becoming a culture of litigiousness and being easily offended before it gets out of control. It might already be, who knows, but if hurting a few oversensitive people's feelings at least keeps me from contributing towards a creep towards world of omnipresent censorship with good intentions, then I choose to do so.
1) Somali-American, or Mozambique-American, or Kenyan-American. It's the ones whose ancestors were taken so long ago who have to refer to the continent as a whole.
2) And?
3) Actually, very few people care if you use the term black in informal speech or writing. As far as "nigger" goes, do you really have such a desire to use the term? Is it that important to you?
4) You can use all of those holiday terms when referring to the holidays. Why are you so resistant to more inclusive language? All that fuss over an extra syllable or two.
5) I'm not sure that you get to define what's hypersensitivity on the part of others when it comes to terms describing them.



