Old Man Kills Intruder

[Viritica]

Were they not still on his property?

Doesn't matter. You can't shoot a fleeing assailant, regardless if they're on your property. Funny thing, the police can't either.

Doesn't matter. Castle Doctrine states that as long as they're on his property and he feels they'll harm him in the future he is exempt from prosecution.

[Fartsniffage]

You underestimate the power of wishful thinking.

In a similar way to those who think that shooting someone running away is in any way justifiable self-defence.

Let's not make this thug bitch in to a victim .
In case people forgot she broke in to a 80 year old man's house and withl the other thug she was with gave him a beating . So the bitch got her thug ass killed .to that I say DSAF .

Andrea Miller is dead. Ton Greer is not. Seems to me like he came out of the altercation better off.

Now the judiciary should determine whether he acted in accordance with the law.

[Viritica]

I kind of expect our legal system to be held to a higher standard than angry old men with guns.

Why? The US was created by angry men with guns.

So what? Seriously, where are you even going with this?

[Fartsniffage]

Doesn't matter. You can't shoot a fleeing assailant, regardless if they're on your property. Funny thing, the police can't either.

Doesn't matter. Castle Doctrine states that as long as they're on his property and he feels they'll harm him in the future he is exempt from prosecution.

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

[New Acardia]

The only thing that should happen to this gentlemen .
Is be given a award for DSAF .
And all the thugs out there if you are going to go thuging .
Your pray may fight back and take your ass out .

[Viritica]

Doesn't matter. Castle Doctrine states that as long as they're on his property and he feels they'll harm him in the future he is exempt from prosecution.

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

It applies in literally every US state. And in most first world countries in general.

[Fartsniffage]

Why? The US was created by angry men with guns.

So what? Seriously, where are you even going with this?

The framework for the US judicial system was created by angry men with guns. They set up the most influential part of it, the Constitution.

It seems perfectly sensible to me that an angry man with a gun today would be considered by the same standards, and the derivatives, that they laid out.

[Fartsniffage]

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

It applies in literally every US state. And in most first world countries in general.

Does it apply in California?

[Viritica]

So what? Seriously, where are you even going with this?

The framework for the US judicial system was created by angry men with guns. They set up the most influential part of it, the Constitution.

It seems perfectly sensible to me that an angry man with a gun today would be considered by the same standards, and the derivatives, that they laid out.

Uh, the Founders really weren't angry men with guns. In fact, the only one who was on the front line was George Washington.

[Tekania]

Doesn't matter. Castle Doctrine states that as long as they're on his property and he feels they'll harm him in the future he is exempt from prosecution.

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

[Viritica]

It applies in literally every US state. And in most first world countries in general.

Does it apply in California?

Yes...

[Tarsonis Survivors]

Doesn't matter. You can't shoot a fleeing assailant, regardless if they're on your property. Funny thing, the police can't either.

Doesn't matter. Castle Doctrine states that as long as they're on his property and he feels they'll harm him in the future he is exempt from prosecution.

Actually, it says Immediate future, as in right then and there. Once they are fleeing, Castle doctrine no longer applies.

[New Acardia]

Let's not make this thug bitch in to a victim .
In case people forgot she broke in to a 80 year old man's house and withl the other thug she was with gave him a beating . So the bitch got her thug ass killed .to that I say DSAF .

Andrea Miller is dead. Ton Greer is not. Seems to me like he came out of the altercation better off.


If the thug bitch did not break in to Mr. Greer's house.
The thug bitch would not got her thug ass killed in the first plac.

[Fartsniffage]

Does it apply in California?

Yes...

And how is it defined?

[Tarsonis Survivors]

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

Doubtful, he already confessed. Most likely he'll get a plea deal.

[Fartsniffage]

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

I'm sorry, but you're ex-military. So am I.

Can you really condone in any way the shooting of someone running away and begging for their life?

[Nickel Empire]

Good.

[Infected Mushroom]

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

So it's not just Florida that has castle laws? I see.

This makes me happy. The poor old man won't be re-victimized by the law then? They won't file charges in the end you think?

I'm glad the DAs in the US have some tools they can use to decide who they'll go after and who they'll spare.

[Spoder]

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

I'm sorry, but you're ex-military. So am I.

Can you really condone in any way the shooting of someone running away and begging for their life?

If an ISIS terrorist broke your collarbone with a rusty pipe, would you give a fuck?

[Infected Mushroom]

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

I'm sorry, but you're ex-military. So am I.

Can you really condone in any way the shooting of someone running away and begging for their life?

Yes when mere seconds ago they were trespassing, robbing, beating up a frail old man.

[Tarsonis Survivors]

Castle Doctrine does exist in Cali, I believe the code is 198.5 (I know it's in the 190's)..... though this incident falls just outside of it, technically, from my reading of it earlier. Not that it makes much difference. I doubt the charges will actually be filed come Monday, and even if they are I'm absolutely certain that the result would just be a mistrial, and after Polling the DA would chose just not to refile.

I'm sorry, but you're ex-military. So am I.

Can you really condone in any way the shooting of someone running away and begging for their life?

Uh, I know some fellow vets who would, thankfully they live far away.

[Fartsniffage]

If the thug bitch did not break in to Mr. Greer's house.
The thug bitch would not got her thug ass killed in the first plac.

Andrea Miller. That's the name of the dead person.

And you're right, if she hadn't broken into the place then she would probably be alive. But the question is whether Mr. Greer killed her legally. I don't believe that he did.

[Ratateague]

Does Castle Doctrine apply in California?

It applies in literally every US state. And in most first world countries in general.

From what the article described, if they were running into an alley, unless Greer's house bordered that alley, then they were not on his property.

That part about Castle Doctrine in literally every state is a bit of a stretch.

[Fartsniffage]

I'm sorry, but you're ex-military. So am I.

Can you really condone in any way the shooting of someone running away and begging for their life?

If an ISIS terrorist broke your collarbone with a rusty pipe, would you give a fuck?

Of course I would.

[Former United Soviet Socialist republic]

Hey, stop it and stay on topic people. If you can't stop insulting people, come back when you can kay?