Would You Kill Someone if God Told You To?

[Nationes Pii Redivivi]

I would if Allah told me.
Allah is great.

If Allah would told you to kill someone, it would only mean that Allah isn't great.

Allah, if he exist, would be great in so far as he is infinitely more powerful than you are, so I would agree with Mr Jukraina, if Allah told me to kill someone, its either me or that poor sod, and I would rather it be him.

[Shilya]

If it's god, he's more than suitable to do the job himself. I'm pretty sure he doesn't need me for it. I'll consider it a test of my niceness and decline.

If it's not god, I was right in declining as well.

[Ammar]

No.

[Nationes Pii Redivivi]

If it's god, he's more than suitable to do the job himself. I'm pretty sure he doesn't need me for it. I'll consider it a test of my niceness and decline.

If it's not god, I was right in declining as well.

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

[Sun Wukong]

If it's god, he's more than suitable to do the job himself. I'm pretty sure he doesn't need me for it. I'll consider it a test of my niceness and decline.

If it's not god, I was right in declining as well.

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

I annihilated heaven's armies, and all I had to do was some community service. You'll be fine.

[Shilya]

If it's god, he's more than suitable to do the job himself. I'm pretty sure he doesn't need me for it. I'll consider it a test of my niceness and decline.

If it's not god, I was right in declining as well.

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

If it's a being with any power like that, it doesn't need my services in the first place. It's more reasonable to assume the being is testing you. In that case, I don't want to be found a murderer.

[Sun Wukong]

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

If it's a being with any power like that, it doesn't need my services in the first place. It's more reasonable to assume the being is testing you. In that case, I don't want to be found a murderer.

Wouldn't that be true of absolutely everything he might ask you to do?

[Nationes Pii Redivivi]

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

If it's a being with any power like that, it doesn't need my services in the first place. It's more reasonable to assume the being is testing you. In that case, I don't want to be found a murderer.

If this being works in mysterious ways, and it is more reasonable not to assume that it is some benevolent figure wanting to test you, but to do what it says. If you failed, and it claims that you failed the test, then you can always tell it that you are simply following its bidding like a good follower of that being, whilst, if you do not kill it, and it turns out that it is angry at you for not doing it, you are really out of an excuse.

[Nationes Pii Redivivi]

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

I annihilated heaven's armies, and all I had to do was some community service. You'll be fine.

They put you beneath a shit ton of rocks for centuries, and then made you go with some hippie monk fellow for years afterwards. And you would still be under a shit ton of rocks if it weren't for the hippie monk fellow.

[Sun Wukong]

I annihilated heaven's armies, and all I had to do was some community service. You'll be fine.

They put you beneath a shit ton of rocks for centuries, and then made you go with some hippie monk fellow for years afterwards. And you would still be under a shit ton of rocks if it weren't for the hippie monk fellow.

I needed a nap after all that excitement anyway.

[United Marxist Nations]

I annihilated heaven's armies, and all I had to do was some community service. You'll be fine.

They put you beneath a shit ton of rocks for centuries, and then made you go with some hippie monk fellow for years afterwards. And you would still be under a shit ton of rocks if it weren't for the hippie monk fellow.

I don't know what you're talking about. I crucified Jesus, then stabbed him with a spear, and all I got was a retirement pension.

[Shilya]

If it's a being with any power like that, it doesn't need my services in the first place. It's more reasonable to assume the being is testing you. In that case, I don't want to be found a murderer.

If this being works in mysterious ways, and it is more reasonable not to assume that it is some benevolent figure wanting to test you, but to do what it says. If you failed, and it claims that you failed the test, then you can always tell it that you are simply following its bidding like a good follower of that being, whilst, if you do not kill it, and it turns out that it is angry at you for not doing it, you are really out of an excuse.

Well, then my excuse is that I'm trying my best to be a good being and just can't help acting the way I was made. If the god blames me for that, then I was shit outta luck in the first place, because it means god's a dick.

[Sun Wukong]

If this being works in mysterious ways, and it is more reasonable not to assume that it is some benevolent figure wanting to test you, but to do what it says. If you failed, and it claims that you failed the test, then you can always tell it that you are simply following its bidding like a good follower of that being, whilst, if you do not kill it, and it turns out that it is angry at you for not doing it, you are really out of an excuse.

Well, then my excuse is that I'm trying my best to be a good being and just can't help acting the way I was made. If the god blames me for that, then I was shit outta luck in the first place, because it means god's a dick.

Even now Sithrak oils the spit.

[Tyriece]

I would be asking ALOT of questions....

[The Alma Mater]

If this being works in mysterious ways, and it is more reasonable not to assume that it is some benevolent figure wanting to test you, but to do what it says. If you failed, and it claims that you failed the test, then you can always tell it that you are simply following its bidding like a good follower of that being, whilst, if you do not kill it, and it turns out that it is angry at you for not doing it, you are really out of an excuse.

Well, then my excuse is that I'm trying my best to be a good being and just can't help acting the way I was made. If the god blames me for that, then I was shit outta luck in the first place, because it means god's a dick.

Fraid so. Remember the story about the bush that could not give Jesus fruit because it was not the right season ?
It died the next day.

[Greed and Death]

No and I would check myself in a mental hospital in another country ( to avoid anything in america being filed to have my guns seized).

[Cuprum]

Nah, i'd make a topic in NS about my mental problems before that.

[SolasDagr]

No, for the same reason I wouldn't kill someone in the name of Slenderman/Santa Claus/Zeus.

If I heard a voice in my head telling me to kill someone, I would see a psychiatrist.

Oh but if you are hearing voices your facilities of judgement would be skewed and the thought of needing a shrink probably wouldn't enter your mind at all. Unless it wasn't a psychological happening but an auditory message being sent to your head.

[Alaizia]

Oh Zeus forgive us for this thread....

[Sun Wukong]

Yes, but I'm charging double.

[Sunlandic]

If it is a being with any power to make your life extremely miserable for the rest of your existence, then declining would not be the wise thing to do.

I annihilated heaven's armies, and all I had to do was some community service. You'll be fine.

Funny.. I was in Heaven's armies.. and I don't ever recall losing, I LEGITIMATELY annihilated(will annihilate? Guess since its in the future ) Hell's armies.. and all I had to do was undergo some temporary punishment (because I had been ordered to let them go )

I'd beat 2000 demons faster than you could blink.

Also when I was undergoing my punishment I beat all of Satan's leuitanents like it was joke

Dude was legitimately frightened like you wouldn't believe.

Also probably killed all demons and entites in hell shortly after.. my memories of those days are vague. I just remember yelling at the top of a giant mountain of conquered entities.

Wasn't a thing left alive in hell except me.. then I just remember seeing a light.. and that was it.

[Sunlandic]

Yes, but I'm charging double.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBVrPWwSlRM

[Margno]

Gravedigging is against the rules, yo.

[Nirvash Type TheEND]

Would I get away with it if I told the local authorities god commanded it?

[Earth in Roughly 1000 Years]

I'm agnostic agnostic so I would probably tell he/she/shim/it to ask someone else. But I would think that a religious person would say that people are not omnipotent so whether it conflicts with our moral values or not, we are not perfect enough to evaluate God's intentions objectively.