Uelvan wrote:Mushet wrote:Or half that.
You make it sound like it was hundreds of Spaniards alone fighting against hundreds of thousands of Tawantinsuyu warriors, this was not the case the defending army was overwhelmingly warriors from Tawantinsuyu, and the defending side had the advantage of holding down the capital city, at least at first until they lost that advantage.
It was still a hundred or two thousand against just a few thousand. The Spanish tactics, weaponry, and overall skill in warfare beat the Incans just about every time, and there is no other way around it. This is what history showed. They always went to battle outnumbers like crazy, and rarely suffered great losses, themselves.
If you're implying the Spanish would not have an axillary consider the OP's post, he claimed the Incans would conquer and oppress the Aztecs and Mayans both. So therefore, the Conquistadors would just need to play along their tribal divide there and get their axillaries from there, instead of Peru itself. History has shown, once they have this type of army going they will win the battles.
No, it was the Spanish AND factions of Tawantinsuyu warriors versus different factions of Tawantinsuyu warriors with the former holding and defending the capital, it wasn't Conquistadores vs "The Inca", it was Conquistadores and "The Inca" versus the Inca in a time of instability with a power vacuum, and the spread of a new disease amongst the populace, big difference. And tribal divide? Really? We're talking about urban civilizations here not tribes, you just use that language because they're Native American. History has really shown that the defining feature of why colonists were able to beat the natives was mainly due to disease weakening them, notice how Cortes and his men and native warriors got run out of Tenochtitlan and Cortes almost died and they were only able to retake the city after smallpox has greatly weakened the inhabitants. That's the pattern of that history, colonist conquering greatly facilitated by smallpox and all the problems caused by it, if it wasn't for smallpox Pizarro would've faced a healthy, stable, undivided empire, Cortes probably wouldn't have been able to get Tenochtitlan when he was kicked out, the countless other non-urban nations would've had much more of a fighting chance.