Halo vs. Star Wars: Who would win?

[New Emphillon]

If, for some reason, the Star Wars and Halo universes were to clash, what do you think will happen? Do you think one side would win over the other? A peace between a few factions and war against the others? I would like to get some opinions as to what would happen.

Personally, if the two universes clashed, I think it would be a draw for a few reasons:
1. Both have futuristic weapons that would be effective against each other- An Imperial Star Destroyer could annihilate a few UNSC ships single handedly and a Covenant vessel could then destroy that Star Destroyer. I could go on with this, but I need to go on.

2. Each side has a weapon that could destroy a large population- Halo obviously has the Halo Array (duh) and nuclear weapons, while Star Wars has the Death Stars, Tarkin Station, the Darksaber, Sun Crusher, the Eye of Palpatine, etc.

3. A faction(s) with special abilities- Star Wars has the Jedi and the Sith, plus the Yuuzhan Vong (they don't have special abilities, but they do make good use of organic materials instead of regular technology), while Halo has the Spartans and the Forerunners.

Rules of the forum:
1. Please don't get to violent with the debate. This is just for fun and I don't want people battling to the death over this or putting each other down.
2. Have fun and enjoy the debates!

New Halo 5 Debate Thread:
http://forum.nationstates.net/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=247751

[Avenio]

Star Trek.

[Disserbia]

Nerdgasm.

[Harrinton]

Hard choice, it's gotta be the Star Wars universe. Could bullets from the UNSC penetrate droids? I'm curious.

[New Emphillon]

I would think so. The UNSC's bullets range from 7.62mm rounds to 50 cal. plus everything in between. The 7.62 could at least make a dent in battle droid armor.

[Zilam]

What would happen if the Sith were infected by the Flood?

[Lunatic Goofballs]

Neither are a match for the Mighty Goofball and his Monstrous Catapult of Thread-Moving!

[Kota land]

The Soviet Union

[The Parthians]

Warhammer 40k.

[Alios territorys]

Im going to block the consequences of that from my head,halo would win,with ONIs nearly inextinguishable supply of secret projects and the chief and spartan fours,depending on the timeline,would eventually MAC round the CIS,Spartans would nuke the death star,and energy shields would at least block one slash from a light-saber if we just rolled the dice

[Olthar]

Halo wouldn't stand a chance. Star Wars is one of the most overpowered universes out there, especially once you get into the Extended Universe. There's almost nothing that can stand up to it.

[New haven america]

Neither, they're both 2 completely different universes(galaxies I should say) with different physics, so neither could win, it's impossible.

[Confederate People of the United States]

Nerdgasm.

TRU DAT this is crap and I hope you children grow up in the next 20 years.

[Herador]

Star Wars clearly, the UNSC got wrecked by a force which is barely close to the power of the Empire from Star Wars.

[Upiantstan]

I am totally going with Star Wars on this one, but just out of curiosity, would the *people* of HALO be able to figure out how to tame the force? Or would the force even exist in the HALO galaxies? Just something for you all to think about...

[Olthar]

I am totally going with Star Wars on this one, but just out of curiosity, would the *people* of HALO be able to figure out how to tame the force? Or would the force even exist in the HALO galaxies? Just something for you all to think about...

Potentially. Doesn't mean it would make a difference. They wouldn't be able to learn how to use it fast enough for it to have any affect on the outcome of the battle.

[Empire of Narnia]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

[New haven america]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

Star Wars is so overpowered, it could destroy the Earth, so no.

[Constaniana]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

Oh, you mean judging the stormtroopers by how they fight against the designated good guys, where they're supposed to lose?

[Olthar]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

The Star Wars infantry is only weak when the plot demands they be so for the sake of the heroes. At the beginning of A New Hope, they took down that rebel blockade runner in mere seconds because the plot didn't make them lose. They're still an army of genetically enhanced clones with futuristic equipment. It'd be like taking Captain America, encasing him in nearly impenetrable armor, giving him a laser gun, and then making millions of him. Earth can't beat that.

The vehicles are slow and bulky because the movies were made in the 70s and 80s. The newer movies and the rest of the Star Wars universe is much better about that.

The tactics are outdated because the script was written by a man with no military training. You can't expect him to know how anything works.

If you ignore the expanded universe, then you're just making arbitrary limitations because you don't want to be wrong.

[Upiantstan]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

As for the nukes, it would depend on where the battle is being fought. UNSC is smart enough not to use a nuke to blow up a star destroyer when its IN EARTHS ORBIT. Even if they wanted to use a nuke elsewhere, they would have to transport it, and Star Wars is advanced enough to find the transport and destroy it before it reaches it destination.

[Singpu]

Star Wars. Honestly, if in 1 month they can build a Death Star to destroy a planet, and it takes them years to find someone in HALO that can activate the grid, then Star Wars wins. They have AT-ATs,AT-ST, and fucking super steroid Captain America with lasers and then Master Chief but invincible and with a beam of laser!

[Empire of Narnia]

Halo. Star Wars infantry is so weak WWI infantry would beat it. All their vehicles are also so slow and overly big they would get taken out by airstrikes. Ships would be nuked and they fight with 17th century naval doctrines lol. If you judge by what you see in the movies and not the ludicrous claims in the expanded universe Star Wars would get owned by Earth, let alone the UNSC.

The Star Wars infantry is only weak when the plot demands they be so for the sake of the heroes. At the beginning of A New Hope, they took down that rebel blockade runner in mere seconds because the plot didn't make them lose. They're still an army of genetically enhanced clones with futuristic equipment. It'd be like taking Captain America, encasing him in nearly impenetrable armor, giving him a laser gun, and then making millions of him. Earth can't beat that.

The vehicles are slow and bulky because the movies were made in the 70s and 80s. The newer movies and the rest of the Star Wars universe is much better about that.

The tactics are outdated because the script was written by a man with no military training. You can't expect him to know how anything works.

If you ignore the expanded universe, then you're just making arbitrary limitations because you don't want to be wrong.

LOL, they got beat by furry midgets with sticks and rocks. I ignore the EU because it was made by a bunch od different authors who aren't named George Lucas and a lot of it will probably get retconned when the new movies come out anyways. Star Wars guns are bad anyways. They are likf semi-auto rifles shooting a projectile so slow you could jump out of it's way. Just look between the time the stormtrooper pulls the trigger to the time the beam makes a burn mark in the wall. The "bullets" on star wars guns move about as fast as airsoft BBs out of a cheap airsoft gun.

[Singpu]

The Star Wars infantry is only weak when the plot demands they be so for the sake of the heroes. At the beginning of A New Hope, they took down that rebel blockade runner in mere seconds because the plot didn't make them lose. They're still an army of genetically enhanced clones with futuristic equipment. It'd be like taking Captain America, encasing him in nearly impenetrable armor, giving him a laser gun, and then making millions of him. Earth can't beat that.

The vehicles are slow and bulky because the movies were made in the 70s and 80s. The newer movies and the rest of the Star Wars universe is much better about that.

The tactics are outdated because the script was written by a man with no military training. You can't expect him to know how anything works.

If you ignore the expanded universe, then you're just making arbitrary limitations because you don't want to be wrong.

LOL, they got beat by furry midgets with sticks and rocks. I ignore the EU because it was made by a bunch od different authors who aren't named George Lucas and a lot of it will probably get retconned when the new movies come out anyways. Star Wars guns are bad anyways. They are likf semi-auto rifles shooting a projectile so slow you could jump out of it's way. Just look between the time the stormtrooper pulls the trigger to the time the beam makes a burn mark in the wall. The "bullets" on star wars guns move about as fast as airsoft BBs out of a cheap airsoft gun.

You speak like they are rifles or pistols shooting blanks, mocking how they are so weak they can't even use bullets. They use lasers, and are faster than that. Wanna be shot by one? I didn't think so bitch. You may act high and mighty and like the gun is nothing, but it'll leave a clean mark you can see through in you.

[Empire of Narnia]

I would just hold up my school notebook and block the lasers. A bunch of gangsters with MAC-10s could take down the entire 501st legion of stormtroopers. Even the ships would fall to Missile Command. If Star Wars fought the modern army they would get owned worse then if they fought Halo, since Halo vehicles are made to suck for gameplay purposes. Few fictional armies could take on the US army and win actually.