Opinion on the idea of "white nationalism" (CLOSED)

[Brocwika]

First of all white nationalism is NOT the same as white supremacy.

White nationalism is, as the name suggests, nations reserved for whites, especially if founded by whites. Essentially, it's segregation of the world, but not necessarily an ideology all white-majority nations should follow, but one a nation founded specifically for the preservation of the white race would follow.


Now that that's cleared up, I ask you, what is your opinion. I myself am neutral on this topic honestly.

Edit: Cite sources and post reasons surrounding your arguments. I want a scholar thread, not a "post my standpoint in 3 words and leave" thread.

[NERVUN]

First of all white nationalism is NOT the same as white supremacy.

White nationalism is, as the name suggests, nations reserved for whites, especially if founded by whites. Essentially, it's segregation of the world, but not necessarily an ideology all white-majority nations should follow, but one a nation founded specifically for the preservation of the white race would follow.


Now that that's cleared up, I ask you, what is your opinion. I myself am neutral on this topic honestly.

No. It's a bad and rather stupid idea.

That was easy, when's lunch?

[Greater Pokarnia]

I dislike the idea of ethnic or racial nationalism.

[Nadkor]

Sounds pretty terrible.

[Regnum Dominae]

Stupid idea.

/thread

[Neo Art]

no, that's pretty fucking stupid really.

[Ashmoria]

First of all white nationalism is NOT the same as white supremacy.

White nationalism is, as the name suggests, nations reserved for whites, especially if founded by whites. Essentially, it's segregation of the world, but not necessarily an ideology all white-majority nations should follow, but one a nation founded specifically for the preservation of the white race would follow.


Now that that's cleared up, I ask you, what is your opinion. I myself am neutral on this topic honestly.

I think 2 things

1) there aren't enough "white" people who want a white-only nation to make up a nation

2) there is no place available to set up such a nation.

[Choronzon]

White Nationalism? Ooooh, you mean, "Darkies get out of muh country!"

[Wisconsin9]

There's really no room for shit like this in the modern world.

[Avenio]

It's up there in terms of terrible-ness. Maybe in the top 10 of the 'most terrible', in fact.

[Dolphin with an AK-47]

A shitty idea.

[Thafoo]

[Diopolis]

First of all white nationalism is NOT the same as white supremacy.

White nationalism is, as the name suggests, nations reserved for whites, especially if founded by whites. Essentially, it's segregation of the world, but not necessarily an ideology all white-majority nations should follow, but one a nation founded specifically for the preservation of the white race would follow.


Now that that's cleared up, I ask you, what is your opinion. I myself am neutral on this topic honestly.

I think 2 things

1) there aren't enough "white" people who want a white-only nation to make up a nation

2) there is no place available to set up such a nation.

1. If we put all the white supremacists in one nation, it could probably have enough people.
2. Therein lies the problem.
White nationalism is a great idea because it would get the white supremacists out of modern countries so that they can slowly inbreed themselves out of existence.

[United Dependencies]

Apparently summer has already started for some people.

[Regnum Dominae]

I think 2 things

1) there aren't enough "white" people who want a white-only nation to make up a nation

2) there is no place available to set up such a nation.

1. If we put all the white supremacists in one nation, it could probably have enough people.
2. Therein lies the problem.
White nationalism is a great idea because it would get the white supremacists out of modern countries so that they can slowly inbreed themselves out of existence.

Well, if you think of it that way...

Anyway, just offer them a piece of Antarctica, and see if they're still so keen on the idea. If they ask, why Antarctica, just tell them that it's white, and you thought any brown or green landmass would be an insult to their whiteness.

[Regnum Dominae]

Apparently summer has already started for some people.

What happens here during the summer? People keep talking about it like it's some kind of apocalypse.

[Ainin]

Is it just me or is the description you gave in the OP similar to the ideology of Nazi Germany?

[Nadkor]

Apparently summer has already started for some people.

What happens here during the summer? People keep talking about it like it's some kind of apocalypse.

It's not pretty.

[Ainin]

Apparently summer has already started for some people.

What happens here during the summer? People keep talking about it like it's some kind of apocalypse.

Oh, well, during the summer, [redacted for your own good].

[Diopolis]

1. If we put all the white supremacists in one nation, it could probably have enough people.
2. Therein lies the problem.
White nationalism is a great idea because it would get the white supremacists out of modern countries so that they can slowly inbreed themselves out of existence.

Well, if you think of it that way...

Anyway, just offer them a piece of Antarctica, and see if they're still so keen on the idea. If they ask, why Antarctica, just tell them that it's white, and you thought any brown or green landmass would be an insult to their whiteness.

That would be a good idea... Except that Antarctica has enough oil that they can skate by without confronting reality.( I am assuming that setting up a sovereign nation in antarctica would nullify the antarctic treaty)

[Ainin]

Well, if you think of it that way...

Anyway, just offer them a piece of Antarctica, and see if they're still so keen on the idea. If they ask, why Antarctica, just tell them that it's white, and you thought any brown or green landmass would be an insult to their whiteness.

That would be a good idea... Except that Antarctica has enough oil that they can skate by without confronting reality.( I am assuming that setting up a sovereign nation in antarctica would nullify the antarctic treaty)

Someone tell the Sealand guys this.

[Regnum Dominae]

Is it just me or is the description you gave in the OP similar to the ideology of Nazi Germany?

It actually does sound a lot like the pre-war Nazi Party.

"Psssst, hey guys, we just want to create a nation for the German race where they can live free of outside influence. Don't worry, this will be completely peaceful, and we'll definitely make sure not to infringe on the rights of non-whites while creating this paradise on earth. Oh, and by the way, we're not going to invade Poland, massacre ethnic and religious minorities, or anything stupid like that. We're all friends, right?"

[Tlaceceyaya]

This just makes me think of the Israel/Palestine thread.

[Mike the Progressive]

It's not the change we want, it's the change we need.

White power.

[Diopolis]

Apparently summer has already started for some people.

What happens here during the summer? People keep talking about it like it's some kind of apocalypse.

The sort of people who troll have more time on their hands, so they start trolling threads. The guy who was trying to prove the bible was the literal word of God because it correctly predicted events started during the summer last year, for example. And stuff like that guy who was making threads that were stormfront copypasta become more common.