Why are you your Religion?

[Dyakovo]

Dead people can't use phones.
Either your mother lied to you or you made up the entire story.

I swear on my life I don't make this up.

And you are assuming things from one doctrine.

That isn't always the best thing you know.

Swearing false oaths is bad.

[Tlaceceyaya]

Dead people can't use phones.
Either your mother lied to you or you made up the entire story.

I swear on my life I don't make this up.

And you are assuming things from one doctrine.

That isn't always the best thing you know.

Sure, she might have said that to you. But what's more likely - dead people can use phones to warn people about problems, or it wasn't a dead person?

[Conscentia]

Yeah, it is.

That's like denying the fact you hunt if you do.
Where are your arguments?

Where is thy evidence?

[Ifreann]

Yeah, it is.

That's like denying the fact you hunt if you do.

Where are your arguments?

It's really not necessary to argue against things so obviously impossible as the dead making phone calls about blood sugar levels. Now, if you want us to accept this story as true, feel free to try and argue why we should, but you'll need a whole lot of evidence and I somehow suspect you don't have any.

[The Isle of Jimboy]

I was raised in a Roman Catholic home and was pretty pious considering I was worrying if I was doing something immoral all the time. But now I don't really care too much about religion considering there are over 13,000 religions I think. I also have the philosophy live and let live since I beleive you voice opinion as long it doesn't harm someone.

[Dyakovo]

That's like denying the fact you hunt if you do.
Where are your arguments?

Where is thy evidence?

He doesn't have any.

[Crusifius]

Unfortinatly the NT overrides the OT in some things, like this one.

You do realize you cannot prove Jesus was the Messiah by word of the NT right?

I know, just wanting to point some things out.

[Crusifius]

Where is thy evidence?

He doesn't have any.

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

[YellowApple]

Im a muslim because I think that its the true religion.

Why do you think it is "the true religion"?

Perhaps because that is the religion which best complements his/her own personal viewpoints?

[Menassa]

You do realize you cannot prove Jesus was the Messiah by word of the NT right?

I know, just wanting to point some things out.

Right... also it really doesn't.. that's like me saying that fan fiction overrides the real story.

[Menassa]

Why do you think it is "the true religion"?

Perhaps because that is the religion which best complements his/her own personal viewpoints?

Or they were born that way.

[YellowApple]

Perhaps because that is the religion which best complements his/her own personal viewpoints?

Or they were born that way.

That would tie into 'his/her own personal views', given that many personal views are shaped by childhood - like how Mormonism continues to influence me even though I am no longer a Mormon.

[Conscentia]

Why do you think it is "the true religion"?

Perhaps because that is the religion which best complements his/her own personal viewpoints?

One's perception is not reality.

[Menassa]

He doesn't have any.

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

He's not dead.

[Conscentia]

He doesn't have any.

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

Humans require water to live. As he is still alive, one assumes he consumed water at some point in the last 3 years.

[YellowApple]

Perhaps because that is the religion which best complements his/her own personal viewpoints?

One's perception is not reality.

I never said it was (though, considering the closest thing a human has to reality is perception, such an argument would be complicated beyond measure, and should be left to philosophers). What I'm saying is that to him it would be the truth, regardless of whether or not that perception of reality is shared by us.

[Dyakovo]

He doesn't have any.

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

Since you refuse to even try to provide actual evidence that your story has any basis in reality, I accept your admission that you were lying.

[Crusifius]

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

He's not dead.

Point is is this is nothing more than a tu queque which results into nothing.

[Great Nepal]

I swear on my life I don't make this up.

Fine, I take your word that you didn't make it up. Now, we are left with these possibilities:
1. Your mother exaggerated a vaguely related dream.
2. Your mother made up whole thing.
3. Someone played awesome practical joke on you.

I am going with 1 or 3.

And you are assuming things from one doctrine.
That isn't always the best thing you know.

Nope, we are taking it from primary school biology.

[Crusifius]

Where is the evidence that you drank water last 3 years?

Since you refuse to even try to provide actual evidence that your story has any basis in reality, I accept your admission that you were lying.

Again, I swear on my death I am not. I invite you to my house and to listen and debate further there with me and my parents if you really want evidence.

[Conscentia]

He's not dead.

Point is is this is nothing more than a tu queque which results into nothing.

No comprendo.
I think you should clarify without the unnecessary French.

[Crusifius]

I swear on my life I don't make this up.

Fine, I take your word that you didn't make it up. Now, we are left with these possibilities:
1. Your mother exaggerated a vaguely related dream.
2. Your mother made up whole thing.
3. Someone played awesome practical joke on you.

I am going with 1 or 3.

And you are assuming things from one doctrine.
That isn't always the best thing you know.

Nope, we are taking it from primary school biology.

My mother told my father about the man she saw, my father told it was my paternal great grandfather, basing on the looks.

[Crusifius]

Point is is this is nothing more than a tu queque which results into nothing.

No comprendo.
I think you should clarify without the unnecessary French.

A yes no yes no situation

[YellowApple]

No comprendo.
I think you should clarify without the unnecessary French.

A yes no yes no situation

I translated that as roughly "you whatwhat" in Spanish.

[Great Nepal]

Fine, I take your word that you didn't make it up. Now, we are left with these possibilities:
1. Your mother exaggerated a vaguely related dream.
2. Your mother made up whole thing.
3. Someone played awesome practical joke on you.

I am going with 1 or 3.


Nope, we are taking it from primary school biology.

My mother told my father about the man she saw, my father told it was my paternal great grandfather, basing on the looks.

So, we can amend possibilities:-
1. Your mother exaggerated a vaguely related dream.
2. Your mother made up whole thing.
3. Someone played awesome practical joke on you and your father misidentified.