NATION

PASSWORD

Assassination of politicians: Would it be moral?

For discussion and debate about anything. (Not a roleplay related forum; out-of-character commentary only.)

Advertisement

Remove ads

To what point is it morally right?

The murder of a dictator is morally right.
42
40%
It is also morally right to kill a leader if he is democratically elected.
5
5%
The 2nd and it's also OK to kill politicians for voting for bills that trample on our rights.
17
16%
The 3rd and it's also moral to punish citizens for supporting such leaders/politicians.
7
7%
It is never morally right.
35
33%
 
Total votes : 106

User avatar
Abatael
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6608
Founded: Mar 03, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Abatael » Sun Oct 14, 2012 8:45 am

Old Geneva wrote:I'm a Republican conservative. Mitt Romney and I share most of the same views on a lot of things.

I personally think that abortion is murder, denying the individual to grow up and live in the pursuit of happiness. It should also be up to the father of the child, seeing that he himself could raise the infant. He must have a say in the going on.

I've seen people get charged with murder by killing their infant, and I ask, what is so different from abortion?

Also, same sex marriage is morally wrong. It's just not right. There is something obviously wrong with your head, if you find the same gender attractive beyond reasoning.

Murder is abortion. Gay rights are wrong.


I think you have submitted this under the wrong topic.
IMPERIVM·NOVVM·VENOLIÆ.
PAX·PER·BELLVM.
ROMVLVS·AVRELIVS·SECVNDVS.
DEVS·VENOLIAM·BENEDICAT.

Second Best Factbook (UNDERGOING MAJOR REVISIONS)| Factbook Rankings | Embassy Program

User avatar
Old Geneva
Envoy
 
Posts: 286
Founded: May 29, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Old Geneva » Sun Oct 14, 2012 8:48 am

Abatael wrote:
Old Geneva wrote:I'm a Republican conservative. Mitt Romney and I share most of the same views on a lot of things.

I personally think that abortion is murder, denying the individual to grow up and live in the pursuit of happiness. It should also be up to the father of the child, seeing that he himself could raise the infant. He must have a say in the going on.

I've seen people get charged with murder by killing their infant, and I ask, what is so different from abortion?

Also, same sex marriage is morally wrong. It's just not right. There is something obviously wrong with your head, if you find the same gender attractive beyond reasoning.

Murder is abortion. Gay rights are wrong.


I think you have submitted this under the wrong topic.


No. I was replying to the opening statement.
The Democratic Socialist Republic of Old Geneva


User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Sun Oct 14, 2012 8:50 am

Abatael wrote:
Old Geneva wrote:I'm a Republican conservative. Mitt Romney and I share most of the same views on a lot of things.

I personally think that abortion is murder, denying the individual to grow up and live in the pursuit of happiness. It should also be up to the father of the child, seeing that he himself could raise the infant. He must have a say in the going on.

I've seen people get charged with murder by killing their infant, and I ask, what is so different from abortion?

Also, same sex marriage is morally wrong. It's just not right. There is something obviously wrong with your head, if you find the same gender attractive beyond reasoning.

Murder is abortion. Gay rights are wrong.


I think you have submitted this under the wrong topic.


Wait...Obama supports abortion

...abortion is murder...

...Obama is the leader...



Holy FUCK, HE WANTS TO KILL OBAMA!

MAN THE FUCKING LIFEBOATS!
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Xeng He
Minister
 
Posts: 2905
Founded: Nov 14, 2011
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby Xeng He » Sun Oct 14, 2012 8:56 am

Abatael wrote:You'll need to be more specific in what you mean by "wrongs the people under him."



As in, he doesn't take actions as a ruler that maximize the ability of those people to, ultimately, do/live as they wish.

This doesn't mean "if he restricts freedoms at all", mind you, there are certain freedoms that hamper the freedoms of others, or freedoms that don't allow for things like justice, which do come into play, but...if his/her actions don't fall in that line, really.
Blazedtown wrote:[an ism is] A term used by people who won't admit their true beliefs, or don't have any.
[spoiler=Quotes]
Galloism: ...social media is basically cancer. I’d like to reiterate that social media is bringing the downfall of society in a lot of ways.
I'm Not Telling You It's Going to Be Easy, I'm Telling You It's Going to be Worth It.
Oh my god this comic

User avatar
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace
Powerbroker
 
Posts: 9720
Founded: Jul 25, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace » Sun Oct 14, 2012 8:57 am

Old Geneva wrote:I'm a Republican conservative. Mitt Romney and I share most of the same views on a lot of things.

I personally think that abortion is murder, denying the individual to grow up and live in the pursuit of happiness. It should also be up to the father of the child, seeing that he himself could raise the infant. He must have a say in the going on.

I've seen people get charged with murder by killing their infant, and I ask, what is so different from abortion?

Also, same sex marriage is morally wrong. It's just not right. There is something obviously wrong with your head, if you find the same gender attractive beyond reasoning.

Murder is abortion. Gay rights are wrong.


To respond to the former, the difference lies in when a fetus objectively becomes an actual human person.

To respond to gay marriage, you gave no reason except for "just because". And in my personal view, the government should view ALL OF THAT stuff as far as marriage as legal contracts only, and shouldn't care about who does them in what combination, that includes polygamy and the like. Keep them out of your church, no one cares, but they have no logical and objective reason not to have the same legal rights as you as far as government recognized unions are concerned.
Founder of the Church of Ass.

No Homo.
TET sex chat link
Neo Art wrote:
The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:Ironic ain't it, now there really IS 47% of the country that feels like victims.

........fuck it, you win the internet.

User avatar
Abatael
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6608
Founded: Mar 03, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Abatael » Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:10 am

Xeng He wrote:
Abatael wrote:You'll need to be more specific in what you mean by "wrongs the people under him."



As in, he doesn't take actions as a ruler that maximize the ability of those people to, ultimately, do/live as they wish.

This doesn't mean "if he restricts freedoms at all", mind you, there are certain freedoms that hamper the freedoms of others, or freedoms that don't allow for things like justice, which do come into play, but...if his/her actions don't fall in that line, really.


No.
IMPERIVM·NOVVM·VENOLIÆ.
PAX·PER·BELLVM.
ROMVLVS·AVRELIVS·SECVNDVS.
DEVS·VENOLIAM·BENEDICAT.

Second Best Factbook (UNDERGOING MAJOR REVISIONS)| Factbook Rankings | Embassy Program

User avatar
Xeng He
Minister
 
Posts: 2905
Founded: Nov 14, 2011
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby Xeng He » Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:18 am

Abatael wrote:
No.


Now it's your turn to be more specific.
Blazedtown wrote:[an ism is] A term used by people who won't admit their true beliefs, or don't have any.
[spoiler=Quotes]
Galloism: ...social media is basically cancer. I’d like to reiterate that social media is bringing the downfall of society in a lot of ways.
I'm Not Telling You It's Going to Be Easy, I'm Telling You It's Going to be Worth It.
Oh my god this comic

User avatar
Nova Nacio
Diplomat
 
Posts: 551
Founded: Jul 10, 2011
Ex-Nation

Postby Nova Nacio » Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:31 am

The Land Fomerly Known as Ligerplace wrote:
To respond to the former, the difference lies in when a fetus objectively becomes an actual human person.

To respond to gay marriage, you gave no reason except for "just because". And in my personal view, the government should view ALL OF THAT stuff as far as marriage as legal contracts only, and shouldn't care about who does them in what combination, that includes polygamy and the like. Keep them out of your church, no one cares, but they have no logical and objective reason not to have the same legal rights as you as far as government recognized unions are concerned.


Just another day of debunking American conservative BS in a nation that is secretly and increasingly getting tired of it... That's good to hear.

Well, as to respond to the OP, the 4th choice, seeing as I rather despise people who vote against things that could benefit them if allowed to exist in the long run instead of hoping things get done fast and with little productivity or positive impact on the society involved.
Last edited by Nova Nacio on Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:33 am, edited 2 times in total.

User avatar
Abatael
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6608
Founded: Mar 03, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Abatael » Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:33 am

Xeng He wrote:
Abatael wrote:
No.


Now it's your turn to be more specific.


The example you gave is not as equally disgusting as assassinating the sovereign.
Last edited by Abatael on Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:36 am, edited 1 time in total.
IMPERIVM·NOVVM·VENOLIÆ.
PAX·PER·BELLVM.
ROMVLVS·AVRELIVS·SECVNDVS.
DEVS·VENOLIAM·BENEDICAT.

Second Best Factbook (UNDERGOING MAJOR REVISIONS)| Factbook Rankings | Embassy Program

User avatar
Delvoir
Diplomat
 
Posts: 699
Founded: Aug 21, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Delvoir » Sun Oct 14, 2012 9:34 am

Old Geneva wrote:I'm a Republican conservative. Mitt Romney and I share most of the same views on a lot of things.

I personally think that abortion is murder, denying the individual to grow up and live in the pursuit of happiness. It should also be up to the father of the child, seeing that he himself could raise the infant. He must have a say in the going on.

I've seen people get charged with murder by killing their infant, and I ask, what is so different from abortion?

Also, same sex marriage is morally wrong. It's just not right. There is something obviously wrong with your head, if you find the same gender attractive beyond reasoning.

Murder is abortion. Gay rights are wrong.


To me, this is just purposely inflammatory. I don't even think any of that warrants a response other than the fact that those views are archaic and hopefully will be a thing of the past very soon.
The Most Royal Kingdom of Delvoir
Semi-Constitutional Monarchy
State Religion: New Delvoirian Catholicism
Head of State: His Most High and Royal Majesty King Louis XIX of Delvoir and Fravarre
The Royal Delvoir Foreign Ministry - Open Embassies, Ask Questions

User avatar
Xeng He
Minister
 
Posts: 2905
Founded: Nov 14, 2011
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby Xeng He » Sun Oct 14, 2012 10:15 am

Abatael wrote:
Xeng He wrote:
Now it's your turn to be more specific.


The example you gave is not as equally disgusting as assassinating the sovereign.





I find it equally disgusting, personally, because in my own view a sovereign exists solely to prevent people from using their freedom to oppress others, and to prevent really one-sided agreements. To make sure that, where possible, freedom and justice reign by preventing worse individuals from coming to power.

Whereas you...think what?
Blazedtown wrote:[an ism is] A term used by people who won't admit their true beliefs, or don't have any.
[spoiler=Quotes]
Galloism: ...social media is basically cancer. I’d like to reiterate that social media is bringing the downfall of society in a lot of ways.
I'm Not Telling You It's Going to Be Easy, I'm Telling You It's Going to be Worth It.
Oh my god this comic

User avatar
Abatael
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6608
Founded: Mar 03, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Abatael » Sun Oct 14, 2012 10:27 am

Xeng He wrote:
Abatael wrote:
The example you gave is not as equally disgusting as assassinating the sovereign.





I find it equally disgusting, personally, because in my own view a sovereign exists solely to prevent people from using their freedom to oppress others, and to prevent really one-sided agreements. To make sure that, where possible, freedom and justice reign by preventing worse individuals from coming to power.

Whereas you...think what?


I think that it is the job of the sovereign to reign over his subjects, and his territory. I will not define their specific role the way you just did, because I believe that should be defined in the constitution of the state. Do you understand what I am saying?
IMPERIVM·NOVVM·VENOLIÆ.
PAX·PER·BELLVM.
ROMVLVS·AVRELIVS·SECVNDVS.
DEVS·VENOLIAM·BENEDICAT.

Second Best Factbook (UNDERGOING MAJOR REVISIONS)| Factbook Rankings | Embassy Program

User avatar
Xeng He
Minister
 
Posts: 2905
Founded: Nov 14, 2011
Iron Fist Consumerists

Postby Xeng He » Sun Oct 14, 2012 10:31 am

Abatael wrote:
I think that it is the job of the sovereign to reign over his subjects, and his territory. I will not define their specific role the way you just did, because I believe that should be defined in the constitution of the state. Do you understand what I am saying?



I do. I disagree, but unfortunately there are no internal inconsistancies therein...

...well, arguably, what exactly makes that contract any more legitimate than any other prospective ruler of the area's, but...
Blazedtown wrote:[an ism is] A term used by people who won't admit their true beliefs, or don't have any.
[spoiler=Quotes]
Galloism: ...social media is basically cancer. I’d like to reiterate that social media is bringing the downfall of society in a lot of ways.
I'm Not Telling You It's Going to Be Easy, I'm Telling You It's Going to be Worth It.
Oh my god this comic

User avatar
Abatael
Negotiator
 
Posts: 6608
Founded: Mar 03, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby Abatael » Sun Oct 14, 2012 10:36 am

Xeng He wrote:
Abatael wrote:
I think that it is the job of the sovereign to reign over his subjects, and his territory. I will not define their specific role the way you just did, because I believe that should be defined in the constitution of the state. Do you understand what I am saying?



I do. I disagree, but unfortunately there are no internal inconsistancies therein...

...well, arguably, what exactly makes that contract any more legitimate than any other prospective ruler of the area's, but...


Is your question, "What makes a contract more legitimate than a person?"
IMPERIVM·NOVVM·VENOLIÆ.
PAX·PER·BELLVM.
ROMVLVS·AVRELIVS·SECVNDVS.
DEVS·VENOLIAM·BENEDICAT.

Second Best Factbook (UNDERGOING MAJOR REVISIONS)| Factbook Rankings | Embassy Program

User avatar
East Ormania
Diplomat
 
Posts: 746
Founded: Oct 06, 2012
Ex-Nation

Postby East Ormania » Sun Oct 14, 2012 12:15 pm

Moving Forward Inc wrote:If the leader of a said nation trampled on individual rights, resulting in tyranny, would it be morally right to kill such a leader?

Maybe, but only if he killed someone while in power

Moving Forward Inc wrote:Would your opinion change based on whether he is a Dictator or democratically elected?

Not at all.

Moving Forward Inc wrote:If a politician voted in favor of a bill that tramples on such rights, would you see it as morally right to kill him?

Same stuff on the first topic.

Moving Forward Inc wrote:If Police and Military forces protected such persons and enforced such laws, would it be morally okay to kill them?

In any way, no. They were probably just following orders.

Moving Forward Inc wrote:If a person supported such politicians and leaders, with the use of donations, organizing rallies, or expression of their support for such persons, would you think it morally right to place any sort of punishment on such a person?

Hell no! He wasn't responsible for that!

The killing of such individuals, in my opinion, is only justified if he killed someone while he holded power.
Aside from that, no no no no no.
ayy lmao
Stand
Stand

with
with

Russia
Novorossiya

Previous

Advertisement

Remove ads

Return to General

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Ask Jeeves [Bot], Bombadil, Emotional Support Crocodile, Mergold-Aurlia, Republics of the Solar Union, Singaporen Empire

Advertisement

Remove ads