Platypus Bureaucracy wrote:Yusseria wrote:Why not? They created an extremely beloved and critically-acclaimed show.
And fantasy isn't really all that different from sci-fi once you get right down to it.
They adapted someone else's material to create that show, and it markedly declined in quality once they went off-book. And it hasn't even finished yet, so there's no guarantee they'll stick the landing.
They might both be fantasy, but they're wildly different in tone. GoT is notorious for being an adult, sexy, violent show. Star Wars has to be family friendly. GoT is gritty to the point of misanthropy, Star Wars is traditionally idealistic. And that's not even considering that they're going from TV to film.
Really, beyond "they did a fantasy and it was big", I don't see any reason for hiring them in particular. I'm not saying there couldn't be one. Like I said: I'd like to know what the thinking was. Maybe they made a great pitch.
Edit: You know who I'd love to see do a Star War? Joss Whedon. Man knows his way around a character.
Oh, please keep Whedon away. I really would prefer that Star Wars isn't Marvel-fied (of course, this has already happened since Marvel has been publishing all the new SW comics, but still).
Anyway, I do see your point. However, I don't real mind making Star Wars a bit more gritty. This was done in Rogue One and was met with mostly positive reception. Besides, the Old Republic has always been a bit more gritty than the rest of SW. I mean, just take a look at this.