Star Wars: Debate Thread

[Bearon]

Qymaen Jai Sheelal is a pretty good warrior. His time as a general for the Confederacy of Independent Systems was probably his prime.

Which is you favorite Sith Lord? Hego Damask (Darth Plagueis)?
Darth Tenebrous?
Darth Sidious?
Darth Revan?
Darth Nihilus
Darth Sion?
Darth Traya?
Darth Bane
Darth Zannah?

None of them.

[Creepoc Infinite]

Qymaen Jai Sheelal is a pretty good warrior. His time as a general for the Confederacy of Independent Systems was probably his prime.

Which is you favorite Sith Lord? Hego Damask (Darth Plagueis)?
Darth Tenebrous?
Darth Sidious?
Darth Revan?
Darth Nihilus
Darth Sion?
Darth Traya?
Darth Bane
Darth Zannah?

None of them.

Which one then?

[Spoder]

It's Quinlan Vos.

[Creepoc Infinite]

It's Quinlan Vos.

I'll bet you don't know who Qymaen Jai Sheelal is.

[Spoder]

It's Quinlan Vos.

I'll bet you don't know who Qymaen Jai Sheelal is.

Only a famous Kaleesh.

[Creepoc Infinite]

I'll bet you don't know who Qymaen Jai Sheelal is.

Only a famous Kaleesh.

A name?

[Bearon]

None of them.

Which one then?

Darth Tyranus. :3

[Spoder]

Only a famous Kaleesh.

A name?

A really shitty character from the prequel series.

[Nirvash Type TheEND]

Qymaen Jai Sheelal is a pretty good warrior. His time as a general for the Confederacy of Independent Systems was probably his prime.

Which is you favorite Sith Lord? Hego Damask (Darth Plagueis)?
Darth Tenebrous?
Darth Sidious?
Darth Revan?
Darth Nihilus
Darth Sion?
Darth Traya?
Darth Bane
Darth Zannah?

Tulak Hord. However from your list, Nihilus.

[Creepoc Infinite]

A name?

A really shitty character from the prequel series.

Qymaen Jai SHeelal is better developed in the expanded universe.

[Nirvash Type TheEND]

I think it's perfectly reasonable to say the Grevious who handed two jedi masters their asses on a silver platter is a wholly different character from Lucas' wheezing 'moustache twirling' Grevious.

[Creepoc Infinite]

I think it's perfectly reasonable to say the Grevious who handed two jedi masters their asses on a silver platter is a wholly different character from Lucas' wheezing 'moustache twirling' Grevious.

pre-fuckin-cisely

[Spoder]

A really shitty character from the prequel series.

Qymaen Jai SHeelal is better developed in the expanded universe.

I know he is.

But in the prequels he's a wheezing chicken shit assface.

[Jetan]

None of them.

Which one then?

Vader.

[Creepoc Infinite]

Qymaen Jai SHeelal is better developed in the expanded universe.

I know he is.

But in the prequels he's a wheezing chicken shit assface.

He's only in Episode 3. Which is the only prequel film that is genuinely good.

[Spoder]

I know he is.

But in the prequels he's a wheezing chicken shit assface.

He's only in Episode 3. Which is the only prequel film that is genuinely good.

>Episode 3
>

good

[Creepoc Infinite]

He's only in Episode 3. Which is the only prequel film that is genuinely good.

>Episode 3
>

good

It's at least better than episode 1 And episode 2 combined three times over.

[Spoder]

>Episode 3
>

It's at least better than episode 1 And episode 2 combined three times over.

Please stop; you're going to give me a heart attack.

[Creepoc Infinite]

It's at least better than episode 1 And episode 2 combined three times over.

Please stop; you're going to give me a heart attack.

Okay, then please elaborate on what makes it bad.
Other than the shitty childish romance scenes between Anikan and padme. I already know that shit's bad.

[The United Colonies of Earth]

It's at least better than episode 1 And episode 2 combined three times over.

Please stop; you're going to give me a heart attack.

What's so bad about the prequels?

[Creepoc Infinite]

Please stop; you're going to give me a heart attack.

What's so bad about the prequels?

Jar jar, jake loyd, the entire script of the first two films and 40 percent of ep 3's script.
George lucas

[Spoder]

What's so bad about the prequels?

Jar jar, jake loyd, the entire script of the first two films and 40 percent of ep 3's script.
George lucas

Hayden Christensen. Jar Jar is tolerable.

Hayden Christensen is not.

The entire episode III script sucks ass too.

Episode I is tolerable, just because fucking Hayden Christensen isn't in it.

[Creepoc Infinite]

Jar jar, jake loyd, the entire script of the first two films and 40 percent of ep 3's script.
George lucas

Hayden Christensen. Jar Jar is tolerable.

Hayden Christensen is not.

The entire episode III script sucks ass too.

Episode I is tolerable, just because fucking Hayden Christensen isn't in it.

Hayden Christensen is a decent actor. The only problem is that his acting ability relies on the director heavily.
Watch any movies with him in it that doesn't have as hokey a script as this one and he can actually give a good performance.
His best scenes are in episode 3, and are the ones where there are no lines. He has the ability to give a quality performance but Lucas's direction and the script, and the reputation of the previous two prequels are what make it look as if he is shit.

Episode 1 had a couple cool scenes but they included the parts with earth maul and palpatine.
Jar jar is tolerable? You can't be serious

[The United Colonies of Earth]

Jar jar, jake loyd, the entire script of the first two films and 40 percent of ep 3's script.
George lucas

Hayden Christensen. Jar Jar is tolerable.

Hayden Christensen is not.

The entire episode III script sucks ass too.

Episode I is tolerable, just because fucking Hayden Christensen isn't in it.

Well then. It's been a long time since I watched the prequels, and when I did watch them I was about twelve. I suppose that watching the movies at that age, or without the viewpoint of a critic, allows one to take a more positive opinion of them (which I have overall). Then again, the Battle of Coruscant seems to have been poorly designed, even with the EU explanation that the Home Fleet had been diverted elsewhere by the CIS.

[Creepoc Infinite]

Hayden Christensen. Jar Jar is tolerable.

Hayden Christensen is not.

The entire episode III script sucks ass too.

Episode I is tolerable, just because fucking Hayden Christensen isn't in it.

Well then. It's been a long time since I watched the prequels, and when I did watch them I was about twelve. I suppose that watching the movies at that age, or without the viewpoint of a critic, allows one to take a more positive opinion of them (which I have overall). Then again, the Battle of Coruscant seems to have been poorly designed, even with the EU explanation that the Home Fleet had been diverted elsewhere by the CIS.

The only quality movie episode 3.
With a couple of parts in the previous two films that stand out