The Star Wars vs. WH40K Debate

[Kreanoltha]

Matt Ward

No.

Nononononononononono

Relevant: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p89WL6pzA9s

[The Zeonic States]

Neither Star Wars nor Halo adorn their soldiers with nearly enough skulls, pauldrons or skull pauldrons to compete with 40k.

O.o Some one has never seen Durge Or Any Member of the Mandolorian DeathWatch faction obviously.

Both Durge and those fine Mando both andorned their armor, homes and ships with Trophies that used to be attacted to bodies.

[Wallonochia]

Matt Ward

No.

Nononononononononono

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m3p_VuPIS2c

As a 40k voter I'm voting more for this.

http://i.imgur.com/EfYZl.jpg

[Arkotania]

Neither Star Wars nor Halo adorn their soldiers with nearly enough skulls, pauldrons or skull pauldrons to compete with 40k.

O.o Some one has never seen Durge Or Any Member of the Mandolorian DeathWatch faction obviously.

Both Durge and those fine Mando both andorned their armor, homes and ships with Trophies that used to be attacted to bodies.

Mandalorians aren't soldiers. Their warriors. They don't fight for any reason but to fight.

[Arkania 5]

O.o Some one has never seen Durge Or Any Member of the Mandolorian DeathWatch faction obviously.

Both Durge and those fine Mando both andorned their armor, homes and ships with Trophies that used to be attacted to bodies.

Mandalorians aren't soldiers. Their warriors. They don't fight for any reason but to fight.

Durge was such a beast.

[The Zeonic States]

Personally I see the GE encountering 40k going one of two ways.

1.) Palpy manages to secure an alliance with the imperium of man (Both being Human-centric, xenophobic, fascist, states.), the two team up to ROFLstomp both their minor foes and gear up for the more major threats. Vader is kept under control VIA Gellar field. Alternatively, Palpatine manages to gain enough information to construct Gellar fields and puts a portable one on vader at all times.

2.) Vader teams up with Khorne to kick Palpatine off his throne (Khorne wanting nothing to do with a sissy wizard-king.) The new Galactic Khornate Empire proceeds to give Khorne a huge power boost due to 50 million star systems being forcibly converted, in turn giving the newly converted empire a huge power boost. Not to mention that Khornate Sith would be double the hatred/anger-power. It's a win-win. Except for everyone else.

As to why Palpatine wouldn't team up with Tzeentch? He's smart and knows that's a stupid idea.

And nurgle and slaanesh are both annoying.

Yeah as a fan of both series; That wouldn't have any chance in hell of Happening.

For one Palps doesn't do "Alliances" By choice His goal is singular domination.

Second The empire could within reason defeat the Imperium of man in a in a costly and long war due to techological advantage and diffrence.

No real motive for an alliance.

[The Zeonic States]

O.o Some one has never seen Durge Or Any Member of the Mandolorian DeathWatch faction obviously.

Both Durge and those fine Mando both andorned their armor, homes and ships with Trophies that used to be attacted to bodies.

Mandalorians aren't soldiers. Their warriors. They don't fight for any reason but to fight.

Incorrect; They are Normally wandering Nomadic warrior bands but they have been soldiers at times.

When united under a singular banner and fighting for a cause? Such as they did for Exar Kun? They were soldiers, probably among the best respected soldiers the Sith field.

The Sith all two of them at first were pleased with their New army but in time? They came to respect it and that bond lasted CENTURIES after the conflict ended.

They are among the few Sith will openly respect.

Mandalorians aren't soldiers. Their warriors. They don't fight for any reason but to fight.

Durge was such a beast.

Even being tossed into a Sun wasn't enough to kill him for good.

He lived for so long, Killed so many...He is beyond the level of "Beast" He is a killing diety.

[Arkotania]

Personally I see the GE encountering 40k going one of two ways.

1.) Palpy manages to secure an alliance with the imperium of man (Both being Human-centric, xenophobic, fascist, states.), the two team up to ROFLstomp both their minor foes and gear up for the more major threats. Vader is kept under control VIA Gellar field. Alternatively, Palpatine manages to gain enough information to construct Gellar fields and puts a portable one on vader at all times.

2.) Vader teams up with Khorne to kick Palpatine off his throne (Khorne wanting nothing to do with a sissy wizard-king.) The new Galactic Khornate Empire proceeds to give Khorne a huge power boost due to 50 million star systems being forcibly converted, in turn giving the newly converted empire a huge power boost. Not to mention that Khornate Sith would be double the hatred/anger-power. It's a win-win. Except for everyone else.

As to why Palpatine wouldn't team up with Tzeentch? He's smart and knows that's a stupid idea.

And nurgle and slaanesh are both annoying.

Yeah as a fan of both series; That wouldn't have any chance in hell of Happening.

For one Palps doesn't do "Alliances" By choice His goal is singular domination.

Second The empire could within reason defeat the Imperium of man in a in a costly and long war due to techological advantage and diffrence.

No real motive for an alliance.

Basically, Palpatine wouldn't rest till the chaos gods served him.

[The Zeonic States]

Yeah as a fan of both series; That wouldn't have any chance in hell of Happening.

For one Palps doesn't do "Alliances" By choice His goal is singular domination.

Second The empire could within reason defeat the Imperium of man in a in a costly and long war due to techological advantage and diffrence.

No real motive for an alliance.

Basically, Palpatine wouldn't rest till the chaos gods served him.

I respect the Sith for their Ambition and despite Lucas's Meddling he didn't manage to Ruin Palpatine nor his decades long plot and long reaching immortal grasp.

He wanted to Dominate all Life and he came within miles of that goal.

[Arkotania]

Basically, Palpatine wouldn't rest till the chaos gods served him.

I respect the Sith for their Ambition and despite Lucas's Meddling he didn't manage to Ruin Palpatine nor his decades long plot and long reaching immortal grasp.

He wanted to Dominate all Life and he came within miles of that goal.

Just imagine if he had a Star Forge.

[Bone Fort]

I respect the Sith for their Ambition and despite Lucas's Meddling he didn't manage to Ruin Palpatine nor his decades long plot and long reaching immortal grasp.

He wanted to Dominate all Life and he came within miles of that goal.

Palaptine was the one thing Lucas managed to not screw up in the new trilogy.

[Trollgaard]

I prefer 40k, but I like star wars a lot. I don't know much about Halo, but from what I know it seems pretty neat, though not nearly as cool as the other two settings.

Also, 40k would stomp the other settings if they got into a war.

[Bone Fort]

I prefer 40k, but I like star wars a lot. I don't know much about Halo, but from what I know it seems pretty neat, though not nearly as cool as the other two settings.

Also, 40k would stomp the other settings if they got into a war.

Already talked about that, isn't that simple and let's not bring it back up.

[The Zeonic States]

I respect the Sith for their Ambition and despite Lucas's Meddling he didn't manage to Ruin Palpatine nor his decades long plot and long reaching immortal grasp.

He wanted to Dominate all Life and he came within miles of that goal.

Palaptine was the one thing Lucas managed to not screw up in the new trilogy.

Indeed; The Central Antagonist is crucial and thankfully it wasn't ruined by poor directing skill.

I respect the Sith for their Ambition and despite Lucas's Meddling he didn't manage to Ruin Palpatine nor his decades long plot and long reaching immortal grasp.

He wanted to Dominate all Life and he came within miles of that goal.

Just imagine if he had a Star Forge.

Pity he didn't find any records of it or didn't have the Knowledge to create one he had enough command of the force to use it i have no doubt about that.

A self generating Military platform though? Something like that...cornucopia techology i believe would be the closest actual theory to the starforge, creating from nothing or near and all.

The Empire could have dominated the galaxy for enternity and probably beyond that in time.

[Trollgaard]

I prefer 40k, but I like star wars a lot. I don't know much about Halo, but from what I know it seems pretty neat, though not nearly as cool as the other two settings.

Also, 40k would stomp the other settings if they got into a war.

Already talked about that, isn't that simple and let's not bring it back up.

We don't have to, I"m just sayin'.

Space Marines and all that.

[The Zeonic States]

I prefer 40k, but I like star wars a lot. I don't know much about Halo, but from what I know it seems pretty neat, though not nearly as cool as the other two settings.

Also, 40k would stomp the other settings if they got into a war.

Already talked about that, isn't that simple and let's not bring it back up.

Yeah both sides field a ton of information and Ultimately it was drawn into some sort of truce not to bring it back up again despite me believing the opposite of this fellow that Starwars would openly win any conflict with the Warhammer universe.

[Bone Fort]

We don't have to, I"m just sayin'.

Space Marines and all that.

Again, not that simple.

But yeah, if he had gotten the Star Forge, nothing would've stopped him. Hell, even 40k wouldn't be able to.

[The Zeonic States]

We don't have to, I"m just sayin'.

Space Marines and all that.

Again, not that simple.

But yeah, if he had gotten the Star Forge, nothing would've stopped him. Hell, even 40k wouldn't be able to.

Would have been tricky to defend but if it was well guarded enough? It wouldn't matter if you found it or not.

[Trollgaard]

Already talked about that, isn't that simple and let's not bring it back up.

Yeah both sides field a ton of information and Ultimately it was drawn into some sort of truce not to bring it back up again despite me believing the opposite of this fellow that Starwars would openly win any conflict with the Warhammer universe.

If you get right down to it parts of 40k and parts of star wars would probably ally against other parts of both. Tau and the Rebe Alliance would get along nicely.

I 'spose it would depend on which era we are talking about.

Because Great Crusade Era 40k would be unstoppable.

[Bone Fort]

If you get right down to it parts of 40k and parts of star wars would probably ally against other parts of both. Tau and the Rebe Alliance would get along nicely.

I 'spose it would depend on which era we are talking about.

Because Great Crusade Era 40k would be unstoppable.

Yes, but so would Infinite Empire-Era Star Wars and various other things, which is why it was dropped.

[The Zeonic States]

If you get right down to it parts of 40k and parts of star wars would probably ally against other parts of both. Tau and the Rebe Alliance would get along nicely.

I 'spose it would depend on which era we are talking about.

Because Great Crusade Era 40k would be unstoppable.

Yes, but so would Infinite Empire-Era Star Wars and various other things, which is why it was dropped.

Indeed; Toss in things like the Sun Crusher and Galatic Gun and such? You have devices capable of destorying Solar Systems.

The Starforge a platform capable of generating Military vessels, Droids and Materials of war and pretty much anything else with little to no resources being used.

Starwars has a few things capable of making it "Invincible"

[Trollgaard]

Yes, but so would Infinite Empire-Era Star Wars and various other things, which is why it was dropped.

Indeed; Toss in things like the Sun Crusher and Galatic Gun and such? You have devices capable of destorying Solar Systems.

The Starforge a platform capable of generating Military vessels, Droids and Materials of war and pretty much anything else with little to no resources being used.

Starwars has a few things capable of making it "Invincible"

Nids and Orks.

And Space Marines.

'nuff said.

[The Zeonic States]

Indeed; Toss in things like the Sun Crusher and Galatic Gun and such? You have devices capable of destorying Solar Systems.

The Starforge a platform capable of generating Military vessels, Droids and Materials of war and pretty much anything else with little to no resources being used.

Starwars has a few things capable of making it "Invincible"

Nids and Orks.

And Space Marines.

'nuff said.

This was Debated Already and I wont get into it a second time.

[Bone Fort]

Indeed; Toss in things like the Sun Crusher and Galatic Gun and such? You have devices capable of destorying Solar Systems.

The Starforge a platform capable of generating Military vessels, Droids and Materials of war and pretty much anything else with little to no resources being used.

Starwars has a few things capable of making it "Invincible"

And that's putting it lightly.

And I sense we're about to get back into it, so I'm just going to drop it.

How about we compare the two in terms of story telling and general atmosphere? I like how 40k is going with the grimdark thing, it's a fresh breeze from the usual Hollywood "Good guys always win, happy ending" stuff we usually get, but sometimes I feel they go a bit to far into it, ya know?

[Trollgaard]

Nids and Orks.

And Space Marines.

'nuff said.

This was Debated Already and I wont get into it a second time.

Nids, Orks, and Space Marines, OH MY!