Ganos Lao wrote:But how does synthesis even work? Green light can't inexplicably make people half-synthetic. Not only that, but it makes me wonder why Joker would seem happy to be stranded upon Gilligan's Planet if you chose to jump into the green light. Why would he be happy?
I think the strongest theory for me is that they were too enamoured with causing speculation amidst the fans that they lost sight of what they should've done - fulfilled their promises. I was expecting closure, the culmination of all my choices. Not waiting for DLC which may not even "fix" the endings that good anyways. There's the possibility that BioWare's "fixes" might cause even more anger with fans. Had they just done a simple wide spectrum of endings, ranging from the Reapers winning to ultimate victory and everything in between, we would not have this problem.
Now that where the wild speculation occurs. I've got little doubt in my mind that there is something to Shepard being indoctrinated at the end. That said, I'm still not entirely sure what they're driving at in terms of the extent. The most fitting explanation is the one where the final scenes were all in Shepards head-something which I will agree is a bit of wishful thinking. Of course, that would be an amazing plot development if true, but an absolutely atrocious and confusing ending. If this is really what they were going for they did it absolutely horribly. It's essentially ending a book at the climax. There is a good reason as to why conventions exist in writing fiction, and that is because otherwise you get confusing shit. Such as this.
That said, a bit of speculation is always good. However all that one is left with at the end of ME3 is speculation. There is no end to the game. Just a massive load of unanswered questions, plotholes in all senses of the world, and a feeling of shallowness to the story. A good story will always leave speculation. A bad story will leave only speculation. What Bioware did is absolutely unfathomable from a well accredited writing staff- leave a story incomplete. You simply do not do that. You always end the story arc you are working on in any good story, and Bioware seems to have decided to end it right in the middle. It's absolutely no surprise to me that people are angry, because they were given only part of a story while being promised the full book. Even if the promises weren't made, the costumers have every reason to expect to be delivered a fully fleshed out story that actually ends.
Truth of the matter is that Bioware got greedy. A bit of speculation is good for business. People will want to buy more material to find out if their speculation is true. What Bioware did however is make the entire ending speculation, with absolutely no answers given. It seems to me like a hail mary type of move, where by leaving every question unanswered they have nearly limitless possibilities for future products. Which is absolute bullshit.



