What do you think of this song?

[The Weimar Republic]

The vocals ruin it.

That's a bit blunt, maybe you could expand on that and give some constructive criticism.

I have to wonder why your nation has the same name as the band and you are taking all this so personally. You said you just Googled the name, but really...

[Novograd IV]

That's a bit blunt, maybe you could expand on that and give some constructive criticism.

I have to wonder why your nation has the same name as the band and you are taking all this so personally. You said you just Googled the name, but really...

Look at the age of his nation
Look at the posts of his nation

tireless months of browsing youtube

AND

I googled my nation's name for fun

[The Believers (Ancient)]

That's a bit blunt, maybe you could expand on that and give some constructive criticism.

I have to wonder why your nation has the same name as the band and you are taking all this so personally. You said you just Googled the name, but really...

I'm honestly not taking it personally, I just feel some people should be more constructive with their criticism. This seems to have become a personal attack on me now in fact..."tireless months of browsing youtube" - I was being sarcastic.

[The Believers (Ancient)]

Why can you never have a decent discussion on internet forums?

[Novograd IV]

I have to wonder why your nation has the same name as the band and you are taking all this so personally. You said you just Googled the name, but really...

I'm honestly not taking it personally, I just feel some people should be more constructive with their criticism. This seems to have become a personal attack on me now in fact...

You're too sensitive, to put it bluntly.


On another note:
Your own statements don't add up, and you 'happen' to have a nation name the same as an incredibly underground (i.e: at a school level) band.

Then, you proceed to take enough interest to forward the band, try and make everything seem positive and any negative opinions, you try and bend to be much more positive.


Of course you've got nothing to do with them

[Novograd IV]

Why can you never have a decent discussion on internet forums?

Because suspicious people come on and try and put on a mask as opaque as crystal glass in an attempt to hide their affiliation?

And declare anything that isn't sunshine and roses to be a 'personal attack'


This is the internet, whether you like it or not, it's more oriented to debate (and at a lower, more common, level: 'shouting' contests) than it is to 'Oh, I love everything'
Cynicism is what makes the internet so popular.

[The Weimar Republic]

I have to wonder why your nation has the same name as the band and you are taking all this so personally. You said you just Googled the name, but really...

I'm honestly not taking it personally, I just feel some people should be more constructive with their criticism. This seems to have become a personal attack on me now in fact..."tireless months of browsing youtube" - I was being sarcastic.

How was my criticism not constructive? I told you what specific element of the song was ruining it.

Why can you never have a decent discussion on internet forums?

It would have gone better if you started it with "Hi, guys! What do you think of this song I made?" Either you were trying to hide the fact that it was your song or you do sarcasm about as well as I prevented inflation in the early 1920s.

[Mike the Progressive]

You're fired.