Would a Sticky be possible?

[The Emmerian Unions]

For this thread:

viewtopic.php?f=9&t=548

As it is quite important to the GA as it helps to inform the masses of bad proposals, and even helps the Game mods in their sweeping of the GA Proposal Queue. If not, That's ok.

[Topid]

If that is made a sticky this should be too, it's only fair.

[Ardchoille]

The last time this came up I'm pretty sure Fris nixed it, on the grounds that stickies give threads a semblance of official approval.

The problem is that players who post their opinions on the legality of the proposals quoted aren't always right; I think it'd be a bit confusing to suggest (by stickying) that their opinions were endorsed by the mods.

I agree it's a valuable resource, especially for people who are trying to learn what goes into a successful proposal. But so's NS Wiki, and it's not stickied either. Fortunately, enough people seem to use the Silly and Illegals to keep it near the top of the forum anyway.

Topid, the SC Silly/Illegals thread doesn't have the same purpose as the GA one, probably because there are so few ways for an SC proposal to be illegal. So far, it's more "have you ever seen anything like this in your life?" posts. Which is fun, but not sticky.

[The Emmerian Unions]

Ok. I was just wondering if it would be possible, and from what I can piece together, it seems that it won't, which is understandable.