Roman-Britannic Empire wrote:Ransium wrote:
I think we fundamentally disagree on civil rights. I can't read this option and see it as doing anything but taking away the rights of citizens albiet mildly. Keep in mind, NS tracks civil right relating to crime and punishment.
It is not sensible for that option to decrease civil rights. He only faces punishment if he was guilty in Maxtopia. In Roman-Britannic Empire, he's guilty of (whatever it was in the issue, drunken driven or something) so a deportation of a non citizen who commited a crime is hardly violating anyone's civil rights. Your logic of punishment=less civil rights makes no sense. Punishment of the innocent I could see, but in no way does the issue imply his innocence
Okay here is my personal deduction: You still ban a person from your nation. Even if he or she is a criminal in Maxtopia or wherever and faces punishments there... Even if he or she was a criminal in your nation too. You effectively exile them. That, no matter how you look at it, is a breach of civil rights in my book. Exiling people from a nation is anything but contributing to civil rights, rather the opposite. Regardless of reasons here. Fact is you exile people, and fact is that is indeed a breach of peoples civil rights. The civil right sensible thing to do would be too either leave him be(if he has done nothing in your nation), or charge him inside your nation for the crimes he commited in your nation(not in Maxtopia or god knows where, doesn´t matter). You cannot expect to exile people without any loss to your civil rights.