Advertisement
by Wabbitslayah » Tue Jul 17, 2018 6:13 am
by Syberis » Tue Jul 17, 2018 6:40 am
Wabbitslayah wrote:Here's the reality of British Monarchy or Monarchy regions (UCRs only in this example), a lot of people use rl sounding names. Whether these names are based on actual historical figures like Monarchs, royal families, or common type of names in Victorian to present day.
Tim-Opolis would not be the usual fair, but Timothy Smith/Mountbatten/Stuart or something would be normal. If we think of normal regions as a PolSim instead of RP, these regions will PolSim, except Cosplay while doing it. It makes more sense to do so anyways as opposed to Spiritus. I would argue Mordor could do this in a sense. Since they're specifically thematic.
On to Families themselves. You can be a Montresor whatever in Spiritus, but that doesn't really matter. Being a Stuart that's Royal Family in a Monarchy region makes sense. Then you have other families, royal or not that exist there too. They get titles and all that blah blah. They're already sorto of playing a character. It fits the themes.
So all of this isn't unusual and neither is it particularly an OOC issue.
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Tim Stark » Tue Jul 17, 2018 10:14 am
Syberis wrote:I mean, it has historically been incredibly problematic in KGB and has been used... manipulatively in the past, which is why it can be an OOC issue. The issue is when it's not treated as roleplay, which has happened quite a lot in KGB. If it was pure roleplay, then yeah, it would make some sense.
<Koth - 06/30/2020> I mean as far as GPers go, Tim is one of the most iconic
by Greater vakolicci haven » Tue Jul 17, 2018 10:23 am
Tim Stark wrote:Syberis wrote:I mean, it has historically been incredibly problematic in KGB and has been used... manipulatively in the past, which is why it can be an OOC issue. The issue is when it's not treated as roleplay, which has happened quite a lot in KGB. If it was pure roleplay, then yeah, it would make some sense.
Yeah, a lot of my skepticism comes from the fact that, in recent years, it seems that all the families that take it this seriously end up developing OOC issues from the whole affair. KGB, in particular, really epitomizes this.
Also, British regions are bland af.
by Syberis » Tue Jul 17, 2018 1:03 pm
Greater vakolicci haven wrote:Tim Stark wrote:Yeah, a lot of my skepticism comes from the fact that, in recent years, it seems that all the families that take it this seriously end up developing OOC issues from the whole affair. KGB, in particular, really epitomizes this.
Also, British regions are bland af.
I'd say it's more the community that makes a region interesting, rather than its theme. I dare say a lot of very new players have had really interesting ideas for regions, but they've been so niche that very few people took interest in them and so the communities died. Regions which just raid, regions which just defend and regions that just rp will always have a pool of potentially-interested new recruits, and so the community in those regions flourishes despite the idea for such a region being farely bland. The same is true for regions based on a generic idea, like Britain and its traditional nobility, and in the past (though less so atm) popular book/film series.
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Greater vakolicci haven » Tue Jul 17, 2018 1:18 pm
Syberis wrote:Greater vakolicci haven wrote:I'd say it's more the community that makes a region interesting, rather than its theme. I dare say a lot of very new players have had really interesting ideas for regions, but they've been so niche that very few people took interest in them and so the communities died. Regions which just raid, regions which just defend and regions that just rp will always have a pool of potentially-interested new recruits, and so the community in those regions flourishes despite the idea for such a region being farely bland. The same is true for regions based on a generic idea, like Britain and its traditional nobility, and in the past (though less so atm) popular book/film series.
That doesn't address any of the concerns we posted. Are you c/ping from a script or something? What we're saying is that KGB has had some serious issues with manipulation via OOC means that would mean that I would absolutely advise people stay away from it. You're defending them by ignoring the argument entirely.
by Wentshire » Tue Jul 17, 2018 2:07 pm
Syberis wrote:How are these related to the individuals who declared a shadow war on Osiris and Euro?
Just so that I can update my own documentation.
by Consular » Wed Jul 18, 2018 4:17 am
by Syberis » Wed Jul 18, 2018 5:21 am
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Isle of Rye » Sat Jul 21, 2018 4:26 pm
Syberis wrote:Greater vakolicci haven wrote:I'd say it's more the community that makes a region interesting, rather than its theme. I dare say a lot of very new players have had really interesting ideas for regions, but they've been so niche that very few people took interest in them and so the communities died. Regions which just raid, regions which just defend and regions that just rp will always have a pool of potentially-interested new recruits, and so the community in those regions flourishes despite the idea for such a region being farely bland. The same is true for regions based on a generic idea, like Britain and its traditional nobility, and in the past (though less so atm) popular book/film series.
That doesn't address any of the concerns we posted. Are you c/ping from a script or something? What we're saying is that KGB has had some serious issues with manipulation via OOC means that would mean that I would absolutely advise people stay away from it. You're defending them by ignoring the argument entirely.
by Consular » Sat Jul 21, 2018 6:23 pm
Isle of Rye wrote:what else would you expect? A purge of the entire royal family? That would just kill KoGB
by Salvarity » Sat Jul 21, 2018 6:43 pm
by Drop Your Pants » Sat Jul 21, 2018 7:26 pm
Salvarity wrote:But wanting a community to just die off instead of redeeming and improving itself is an absolutely disgusting point of view to hold.
by Consular » Sat Jul 21, 2018 8:15 pm
Salvarity wrote:Consular wrote:*shrugs* works for me
An absolutely disgusting point of view to hold.
Just kill off every community we don't like, right? KoGB has had a terrible history, yes, no one who pays attention to NSGP is going to deny that. But wanting a community to just die off instead of redeeming and improving itself is an absolutely disgusting point of view to hold.
I like seeing improvement in KoGB and hope you guys can keep improving your community.
by Syberis » Sat Jul 21, 2018 10:20 pm
Isle of Rye wrote:Syberis wrote:
That doesn't address any of the concerns we posted. Are you c/ping from a script or something? What we're saying is that KGB has had some serious issues with manipulation via OOC means that would mean that I would absolutely advise people stay away from it. You're defending them by ignoring the argument entirely.
What Don did is inexcusable, KoGB knows this, yes obviously those that were in 'power' back under his days have influence in the region still, what else would you expect? A purge of the entire royal family? That would just kill KoGB, the current King, Henry IX, has done wonders -- as have many politicians -- to make the region not Don's region. What I fail to see in your argument is the outcome of it, what do you hope to achieve?
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Greater vakolicci haven » Sun Jul 22, 2018 3:44 am
Syberis wrote:Isle of Rye wrote:
What Don did is inexcusable, KoGB knows this, yes obviously those that were in 'power' back under his days have influence in the region still, what else would you expect? A purge of the entire royal family? That would just kill KoGB, the current King, Henry IX, has done wonders -- as have many politicians -- to make the region not Don's region. What I fail to see in your argument is the outcome of it, what do you hope to achieve?
The permanent and irrevocable removal of the following individuals connected to Don's Curia Regis, and a public announcement of their removal in disgrace. Even if these people leave or have already left on their own, punitive measures should be levied after the fact:
Charles Lancaster
Victor Lancaster
Arthur Pendragon
Owen Bonaparte
Cornelius Talleyrand
Whatever you guys called Vac.
Due to their complicit behavior in the actions of King George Mountbatten VI, including planning and discussion of retaliatory actions against regions which housed players who exposed Don's behavior.
Oh, and as I've told John, to make certain Don cannot return, I have requested one last tool to make sure the region remains free of his influence; The founder nation, under my singular and distant ownership. I will not interfere with the region or it's behavior except to enforce good-faith practices and proper OOC behavior of its members.
Once these demands are met, I might consider that KoGB potentially is worth saving.
by Salvarity » Sun Jul 22, 2018 9:43 am
Consular wrote:Salvarity wrote:
An absolutely disgusting point of view to hold.
Just kill off every community we don't like, right? KoGB has had a terrible history, yes, no one who pays attention to NSGP is going to deny that. But wanting a community to just die off instead of redeeming and improving itself is an absolutely disgusting point of view to hold.
I like seeing improvement in KoGB and hope you guys can keep improving your community.
I think they way the LKE invades and griefs innocent regions is pretty disgusting tbh.
You don't get to waltz on in here on some high horse when killing off communities, that exact thing you're throwing a silly tantrum over right now, is a celebrated activity in your garbage pile of a region.
Syberis wrote:Oh, and as I've told John, to make certain Don cannot return, I have requested one last tool to make sure the region remains free of his influence; The founder nation, under my singular and distant ownership. I will not interfere with the region or it's behavior except to enforce good-faith practices and proper OOC behavior of its members.
Once these demands are met, I might consider that KoGB potentially is worth saving.
by Syberis » Sun Jul 22, 2018 10:10 am
Salvarity wrote:Consular wrote:I think they way the LKE invades and griefs innocent regions is pretty disgusting tbh.
You don't get to waltz on in here on some high horse when killing off communities, that exact thing you're throwing a silly tantrum over right now, is a celebrated activity in your garbage pile of a region.
Grade A deflection attempt. But this isn't about the LKE or Albion or wherever.
We could go over semantics about how inactive founderless regions are barely communities, but we don't need to because in my seven years on NationStates; I have never participated in a region destruction/refounding operation. I kinda wish I wasn't making my case in defense of KoGB, but this vindictive dogpile is disgusting to watch.Syberis wrote:Oh, and as I've told John, to make certain Don cannot return, I have requested one last tool to make sure the region remains free of his influence; The founder nation, under my singular and distant ownership. I will not interfere with the region or it's behavior except to enforce good-faith practices and proper OOC behavior of its members.
Once these demands are met, I might consider that KoGB potentially is worth saving.
.....
Jesus fucking Christ. Was that supposed to be a joke or something?
That is just such a beyond stupid request. But of course, that's the point. Set up an impossible standard, then just keep shit talking when no one (rightfully) steps up to that standard.
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Salvarity » Sun Jul 22, 2018 10:30 am
Syberis wrote:Salvarity wrote:
Grade A deflection attempt. But this isn't about the LKE or Albion or wherever.
We could go over semantics about how inactive founderless regions are barely communities, but we don't need to because in my seven years on NationStates; I have never participated in a region destruction/refounding operation. I kinda wish I wasn't making my case in defense of KoGB, but this vindictive dogpile is disgusting to watch.
.....
Jesus fucking Christ. Was that supposed to be a joke or something?
That is just such a beyond stupid request. But of course, that's the point. Set up an impossible standard, then just keep shit talking when no one (rightfully) steps up to that standard.
If you were the least bit aware of Don's actions and behavior, the confirmation that he wouldn't sneak back in would be absolutely critical, wouldn't you think?
I cannot trust a single member of that government to keep Don out, as it's been long established and confirmed by KoGB in the past that he maintained ghost accounts. For all we know, one of the boys climbing up the ranks is Don in disguise again. I do not trust that region to self-report, because of their history.
I suppose I'd be willing to negotiate that last bit if the removal of everyone else who enabled Don's behavior occurs and there's a consistent effort.
by Drop Your Pants » Sun Jul 22, 2018 10:47 am
Syberis wrote:Oh, and as I've told John, to make certain Don cannot return, I have requested one last tool to make sure the region remains free of his influence; The founder nation, under my singular and distant ownership. I will not interfere with the region or it's behavior except to enforce good-faith practices and proper OOC behavior of its members..
by Syberis » Sun Jul 22, 2018 11:20 am
Drop Your Pants wrote:Syberis wrote:Oh, and as I've told John, to make certain Don cannot return, I have requested one last tool to make sure the region remains free of his influence; The founder nation, under my singular and distant ownership. I will not interfere with the region or it's behavior except to enforce good-faith practices and proper OOC behavior of its members..
And to ensure you play fair you can give me control of your main for the duration you hold that founder.
Zaolat wrote:WHO THE F*** IS SYBERIS
by Greater vakolicci haven » Sun Jul 22, 2018 11:42 am
Syberis wrote:Drop Your Pants wrote:And to ensure you play fair you can give me control of your main for the duration you hold that founder.
Ah yes, the false equivalency. I forgot that OOC terrible players have historically had access to my main and have had secret access to my main during false retirements before.
by Big Bad Badger » Sun Jul 22, 2018 12:03 pm
by King Alexander » Sun Jul 22, 2018 1:54 pm
Advertisement
Advertisement