Glen-Rhodes wrote:Kylia Quilor wrote:The point of the repository would be to provide all the evidence that led to the ban, or as much as practically possible, and then allow each region to investgaite to their own satisfaction. It makes the sharing of evidence easier, but doesn't garuntee any more convictions.
Hm. Well, let me just share this anecdote. 2 out of 3 admins in TSP who were asked to ban Unibot were specifically disallowed from seeing the evidence against him. That was at the request of the person(s) filing the complaint. So I'm not sure how willing people would be to let all admins of the forums part of that project see the evidence they give. Whether that be for genuine reasons of not wanting it to leak or spread, or for more political reasons.
Well, in that case, if people won't share the evidence, then you don't act to ban, presumably. If someone asked me to ban someone from my region with no evidence, I'd certainly not listen. So I don't see how this changes anything.