Johanneslanden wrote:Praeceps wrote:I responded to Syl's argument in another thread. The short of it is that while it is interesting information that we will note, we take it with skepticism given how Syl is not as objective as they have been attempting to give the perception of. Given the CCD's long history of fascism, the eager embrace of it by their leadership which has not changed, how not too long ago they have attempted to change, and the questionable suppression of independent anti-fascist identification efforts in the region, TNP remains unconvinced at this time that the CCD has changed on the issue of fascism.
I'm faintly confused by this, so perhaps you would be good enough to enlighten me.
In what way is Syl compromised in this? From what I can tell, you're dismissing them based on their lack of objectivity, which apparently stems from their having been in contact with the CCD.
I find it difficult to understand how anyone is supposed to gain a perspective on what the CCD is like without interacting with them.
I wouldn't use the word compromised—I think that carries the wrong connotations. I'm not dismissing their points based on a lack of objectivity, I am taking their points with skepticism due to their connection with the CCD. In their initial post in this thread on the matter, they claimed that due to McM's history that McM was not objective and specifically notes that they are objective. Do note that Syl does not disclose the following information in this post or subsequently disclose it publicly until I brought it up. Syl asked for the CCD's help in compiling the evidence that they claim proves that the CCD is no longer fascist. That link was also linked in the CCD's dispatch on the issue until Syl convinced them to remove it. Lastly, I'll note that the skepticism of Syl's evidence is not due to being in contact with the CCD but due to the nature of it.
A tangential point that you raise is whether it is necessary for interaction with a region in order to get a perspective on that region. I disagree that it is necessary for there to be interaction. I think it is sufficient to gain a perspective on a region through observing their activities (eg. dispatches, RMB, Discord, etc.). It is worth noting that the perspective from interaction one gets can greatly depend on where it is (eg. RMB vs. general Discord channels vs. private Discord channels).
Let me know if you have any further questions.