Imperium Anglorum wrote:Bears Armed wrote:I tried to come up with revised wording for the rule that would clarify its limits, but other GenSec members dismissed these attempts as too complicated.
I think it would be acceptable to release proposed revisions, if you feel doing so would clarify or otherwise help in discussion of alternatives to the majority's proposed recision.
Okay, 'll go through the versions that I suggested before at some point in the next 2-3 days and put together as coherent a "final" one as I can to post here.
There's the general rule that proposals' designated strengths must be appropriate to their actual contents; there's precedent of Mods telling wannabee authors in the past that even 'Mild' has a lower threshold (in one case giving the rather memorable example that "a proposal only affecting left-handed redheads named Colin" would be ruled aa illegal on that basis); and there's the 'Operative Clause' rule that effectively weeds out some of the "too mild" efforts.