[DEFEATED] Repeal: “Data Protection Accord”

[Kenmoria]

If you don't mind me asking, which of the clauses of this repeal do you agree with?

These I feel are most valid:

General Assembly Resolution #481 “Data Protection Accord”
Concerned about the broad definition of "organization" in Section 1, Clause A, which has too broad of a scope and may limit the ability of small organizations to properly run websites given their lack of resources

Aware of the fact that Section 2, Clause B, may limit the ability of websites to use advertisements to generate revenue for the operation of the website and organization,

They're relatively minor gripes, as I say, which is why my vote is to keep things as they are rather than hope that the corrective legislature both fixes the issues and doesn't introduce bigger ones.

(OOC: The first of the repeal’s mentioned concerns is dealt with by the nature of small business. Although I acknowledge that there are significant costs involved in modern website maintenance, these costs scale with the number of users. This means that a small business will have lower costs than a large one, which should be easily manageable.

The second clause I have no response to, because it is in the nature of the resolution. The point of the Data Protection Accord was to limit the actions that businesses can take, so a loss in revenue is to be expected.)

[Meritocratic Republic of Valprinia]

(OOC: The first of the repeal’s mentioned concerns is dealt with by the nature of small business. Although I acknowledge that there are significant costs involved in modern website maintenance, these costs scale with the number of users. This means that a small business will have lower costs than a large one, which should be easily manageable.

The second clause I have no response to, because it is in the nature of the resolution. The point of the Data Protection Accord was to limit the actions that businesses can take, so a loss in revenue is to be expected.)

Yeah, checks out, I guess it's a matter of preference. In the context of my nation the freedom to do so is important, it's more about the micromanagement of what data can be used, how, and why, etc.

[Inner Neptondia]

We here at Inner Neptondia value the rights of people over corporations. If businesses have to suffer to maintain the rights of a person's rights to use their computer at their own home then so be it. National sovereignity is all well and good, but all the soverignity in the world won't help you recover from becoming a corporate-run capitalist hellscape, and historically loosening regulations has almost always resulted in overall negative outcomes.

[Picairn]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

[Ardiveds]

General Assembly Resolution #481 “Data Protection Accord” (Category: Regulation; Area of Effect: Consumer Protection) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The World Assembly,

Understanding the need to protect an individual's right to privacy,

Concerned about the broad definition of "organization" in Section 1, Clause A, which has too broad of a scope and may limit the ability of small organizations to properly run websites given their lack of resources,

Aware of the fact that Section 2, Clause B, may limit the ability of websites to use advertisements to generate revenue for the operation of the website and organization,

Believing that Section 3, Clause B, is often impractical for businesses to do,

What are your thoughts?

"While the issues with Section 1, Clause A and Section 3, Clause B both seem somewhat reasonable to us, our government does subsidise small businesses in establishing and maintaining an online presence as we believe internet is no less important to modern society than electricity.
We vehemently disagree with the percieved issue with Section 2, Clause B with respect to collection of revenue. Letting a business use an user's data collected without the user's explicit consent for earning revenue is tantamount to letting a business sell stolen goods.
The rest seem to be ambiguity in the meaning of words or national sovereignty arguments. Opposed."
--- Kaiser

[Marxist Germany]

"This gets a hard pass from me."

[United Cats of America]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

Why do so many people hate this bill?

[Morover]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

Why do so many people hate this bill?

OOC:

If only someone had warned you...

[United Cats of America]

Why do so many people hate this bill?

OOC:

If only someone had warned you...

OOC: Warned about what?

[Morover]

OOC:

If only someone had warned you...

OOC: Warned about what?

I think there are problems with GAR#481 that potentially could warrant a repeal, but sadly this ain't it chief.

Concerned about the broad definition of "organization" in Section 1, Clause A, which has too broad of a scope and may limit the ability of small organizations to properly run websites given their lack of resources,

Aware of the fact that Section 2, Clause B, may limit the ability of websites to use advertisements to generate revenue for the operation of the website and organization,

Believing that Section 3, Clause B, is often impractical for businesses to do,

IC: These all are the same argument essentially and they're not convincing. Sure it puts a little bit of a strain on businesses, but these regulations are proportional and necessary to the end-goal which is the protection of an individual's right of privacy.

Noticing that Section 3, Clause G, is vague in terms of what measures is considered "reasonable",

Simple and typical terms like "reasonable" don't need further definition. If every term needed a definition, language could not function (you would run out of terms for defining other terms).

Noting that Section 2, Clause B, violates the sovereignty of member states in limiting their ability to conduct searches and monitoring,

Why would nations want to gather foreign citizens' data without their consent, for the purpose other than crime prevention, is beyond me.
OOC: This is almost an Honest Mistake and it tipped me off the first time I've read it. Government-run entities are excluded from the definition of "organization" in the target (cf. 1a) insofar as they collect the data from their own citizens/residents/people born there. But because government can collect data from the foreigners, it is in the content of GAR#481 that member states are limited in their ability to conduct monitoring.

OOC: NatSov only, illegal.

I'd argue that the following are enough to constitute a repeal (not that I agree with it, just that it's not NatSov only):

Noticing that Section 3, Clause G, is vague in terms of what measures is considered "reasonable",

Concerned about the broad definition of "organization" in Section 1, Clause A, which has too broad of a scope and may limit the ability of small organizations to properly run websites given their lack of resources,

Also believing Section 3, Clause C, is impractical in dealing with disciplinary actions that occurs after the data is removed once the user ceases to be a member of the organization.

[Kenmoria]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

Why do so many people hate this bill?

(OOC: You submitted it far too early, and chose the wrong target. Of course I’m slightly biased, being the coauthor of the legislation, but I genuinely can’t see many flaws with the Data Protection Accord. If there were better repeal arguments, then it would have required far more drafting or a more experienced author in order to put them in a good repeal.)

[Attempted Socialism]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

Why do so many people hate this bill?

I don't hate it, I just voted against it because the repeal itself is founded on a terrible argument; it was drafted far too short so the format is also clearly off; the targeted resolution is good; there's no replacement even contemplated; and I don't want to promote poor drafting etiquette. In evaluation your repeal scores only negative marks (Some of which are probably unavoidable given what you want to do, some you were warned about and yet kept) and the targeted resolution scores several positive ones.

Next time, draft your resolution, listen to feedback, and don't assume people hate you or your resolution just because they vote against it.

[Maowi]

"Yeah, no support from me here, ambassador. This is basically a national-sovereignty-only repeal with a couple of extra arguments hastily shoved in just in case."

[Maralania]

General Assembly Resolution #481 “Data Protection Accord” (Category: Regulation; Area of Effect: Consumer Protection) shall be struck out and rendered null and void.

The World Assembly,

Understanding the need to protect an individual's right to privacy,

Concerned about the broad definition of "organization" in Section 1, Clause A, which has too broad of a scope and may limit the ability of small organizations to properly run websites given their lack of resources,

Aware of the fact that Section 2, Clause B, may limit the ability of websites to use advertisements to generate revenue for the operation of the website and organization,

Noting that Section 2, Clause B, violates the sovereignty of member states in limiting their ability to conduct searches and monitoring,

Believing that Section 3, Clause B, is often impractical for businesses to do,

Also believing Section 3, Clause C, is impractical in dealing with disciplinary actions that occurs after the data is removed once the user ceases to be a member of the organization.

Noticing that Section 3, Clause G, is vague in terms of what measures is considered "reasonable",

Believing the national sovereignty of nations ought to be respected and that unnecessary and harmful regulation of the Internet needs to halted,

Hereby repeals GA #481 "Data Protection Accord".

What are your thoughts?

The main reason why I will vote NO is that I don´t think Resolution GA#481 should be repealed on the arguments given against Section 3, Clause C. I don´t really see anything wrong with Section 3, Clause C of the Resolution. The cause already allows those data not to be removed if there is a clear and compelling safety or disciplinary reason for not removing them.
Maybe the Resolution should have been stronger and mandate the non-removal of data in case of criminal investigations and the like, but the draft does not say anything about that possibility

[Ashaie]

Why do so many people hate this bill?

OOC: I don't think the arguments are enough to constitute a repeal. There's barely any arguments, even.

[The Foxfyre Islands]

I'm afraid this particular turkey needed to stay in the oven a bit longer. Foxfyre Islands is opposed. This should have been passed around a bit with a clear replacement ready to go.

[McMasterdonia]

The North Pacific's Ministry of World Assembly Affairs has recommended a vote of AGAINST for this proposal. I have voted in line with the vote of our residents on our forum, which was also against.

[Honeydewistania]

The bill is effectively dead: 10,000 votes against vs 2,000 votes for.

Why do so many people hate this bill?

Don't be discouraged! People are voting against because they are not convinced your arguments are strong enough to warrant a repeal. Maybe you can try an easier nut to crack or draft your submission here for some much needed advice it would have had a better chance at passing.

[Sancta Romana Ecclesia]

Why do so many people hate this bill?

Don't be discouraged! People are voting against because they are not convinced your arguments are strong enough to warrant a repeal. Maybe you can try an easier nut to crack or draft your submission here for some much needed advice it would have had a better chance at passing.

This, draft your proposals before submitting it and you'll see much bigger support.

[Tinhampton]

"Repeal "Data Protection Accord"" was defeated 20,952 votes to 3,413.

For: 3,413: Bran Astor (965), Layem (130), Bonnie Blue Republic (77), Gonadez (37), NewTexas (31), Christian Democrats (28), New Nationale Einheit (25), New Luciannova (25), Corsoaua (22), Chicken Cutlet (18), Kustonia (14), Wuunime (13), The Flyin (12), Sylh Alanor (12), Auxorii (11), Pagrya (7), SFR Philippines (7), The Newest of Virginia (7), Ferroviaire (7), Capsland (7), People of Tyra (6), Alatoma (6), Balticonia (6), Tdogg (6), Davelands (6), CALLMEDADDYSTRATTON (6), Suternia (5), Tianjastan (5), King Rankmore (5), Lodhs beard (5), Winfallow (5), Eare Tesisia (5), SOUTH WANISTAN (5), Awesomeland012345 (5), Dux Gloriosus (4), Kalinai (4), RBBF (4), Swuoz Smua WA Delegate (4), The Eastern Pacific Islands (4), Kams Rams (4), Chlavia (3), Arconia Defender (3), Drawkland (3), The Greater Union of Man (3), The Begnion Regime (3), Afarmania (3), Hooserian (3), Bairamcea (3), Vladilan (3), Oriental Merchants (3), Meretica (3), Bettisia (3), Tranman (3), Kuromagna (3), GreatEstate (3), Kionces (3), Imren (3), Karrittland (3), The republic ofTexas and northern Mexico (2), Rivgalia (2), United Lammunist Republic (2), Colas Reich (2), Lacmhacarh (2), Lamebrainia (2), The Yeetusa (2), Negeitamonity (2), Ilmarene (2), New Finlandia (2), Corporate Triumvirate (2), Chechenastan (2), Seldt (2), Papa Fetter (2), Southern and Northern Caledonia (2), Technocratic Land of Prosperity (2), Somalwilandia (2), XKrieg (2), Goldeneye Regi0n (2), UEAM (2), Nydelok (2), Het Solen (2), Castilistan (2), The Empire of Hoodania (2), Blatter Land (2), New Aradania (2), Acinonyx Nivalis (2), Nopengie (2), Arab Darussalam (2), Laissez-faire Federated States (2), Nikitan (2), Vampiric Hollandia (2), Mpia (2), Nastropolis (2), Irish socialist soviet republics (2), Anarchist Polish States (2), Jamez Empire (2), Joderia (2), Byrdonia (2), Comackia (2), TySdUR (2), President Pro Tempore (2), Folgoria (2), Adeiatic (2), Slightly Better Latvia (2), Legolannd (2), Anishier (2), Nouvelle Maison (2), Bohamas (2), Sedgistan (2), Facebook Moms Union of Minion Memes (2), South Burtander (2), and (1,700) individual member nations.

Against: 20,952: McMasterdonia (1,461), Aumeltopia (1,155), Marrabuk (1,047), Kuriko (866), East Durthang (659), Aexnidaral (481), Imperium Anglorum (394), North East Somerset (302), Dead I Jack (286), Treadwellia (282), Llorens (252), OF Arian Hellas (231), New Jaedonstan (218), Rikuchar (184), Titanne (173), ShrewLlamaLand (172), Dekks (171), Sorentia (153), Zentata (138), Dome Artan (134), Takura (128), Laurennia (127), Nulkia (127), One Small Island (119), Yodle (110), Bietzopolis (105), Lesser Velutaria (92), The Salaxalans (71), Mikeswill (70), Koiho (69), Enlais (66), Dabberwocky (62), These United Socialists (62), Vancouvia (60), Pure Blooded Whites (51), Bretislavia (51), Greater Victora (48), New Gandor (46), New Legland (46), Kamchakta (44), Albrook (42), Telgan (42), Mother Bear (41), Altorthfnara (40), United Calanworie (40), Karteria (39), Lord Terrorizer of Spammers (38), Asian Lands (37), Lauchenoiria (37), Arudis (35), Mikoyansk (32), Thembria SSR (32), Candensia (30), Aynia Moreaux (26), Alcala-Cordel (26), Bearded Dragones (25), Amantes Farchka (24), Halcyon Nova (24), Ukraniumstan (23), South Krimelski (23), Switzar (23), Breadoria (22), Neo Kerala (21), Johanneslanden (20), Scaneland (19), United Massachusetts (19), ScotlandSerenity (17), Ile Morice (17), The Socialist Republic of Saian (16), Greater Cuba (15), Palsada (15), The New North Republic (14), Albarusija (14), Catterborough (13), Durchhalten (13), Acaciatropole (13), Lead Keion (13), Ariusgrad (12), Atlantian Oceania (12), Prodstrazka (12), Pontanova (12), Wanarpu (12), Newreath (12), Orca and Narwhal (12), FireFox15 (12), Losconia (11), The Sheika (11), Hydroponic Nation (11), The Soviet state of Svalbard (11), Notty Swaras (11), Canogally (11), GAIAD (11), Sail Nation (10), Marlida (10), Dierexa (10), Otaku Stratus (10), Ampolia (10), Madresia (10), Sereteia (10), Luxenermy (10), New Eberron (9), San Lumen (9), FORKTASTICSTAN (9), 3XH181T A (9), Wobbegong (8), The States of France (8), The Greater Nordics (8), The Regalian Underland (8), Orennica (8), Lorthanien (8), OmegaShenron (8), Auruga (8), Draganisia (8), Western Arab Empire (8), Mundane (8), GoodKingWenceslas (7), Mmm monkey (7), Amblibahdesh (7), Riocht mor Daraen (7), Omniabstracta (7), Shaker (7), BasedTupacFan27 (7), Browzantine (7), Kindjal (7), Valtula (7), Fdryden (7), Whims (7), The Greater Low Countries (7), Ankoz (7), Bej (7), The Chuck (6), Lamoni (6), New Delfos (6), Teekerbocker (6), Aelythium (6), New Chillvania (6), Focis Vitae (6), Lord Plembington (6), Flor-Fina (6), Australian rePublic (6), Medoynia (6), The Voltarum (6), Cool Guys and Alex (5), Draekonya (5), United England n Wales (5), West Intermarium (5), The United Peoples of Caedis (5), The Eastern Antarctic State (5), Shineon (5), South Sulphur (5), Cash Monet (5), Of Britannia and Hibernia (5), People of Phoenix (5), Greater Christian (5), Tzedeck (5), Pinochet Executionists (5), Empire of Atlanta (5), New Ontaria (5), Wabacha (5), Bayuda (5), Baophenx Dynasty (5), The People Of New Thebes (5), Golanchia (5), Fed Dusistan (5), Valtrona (5), Smiley Bob (5), Epic Super Bros (5), Kalix (4), Legal Free Weed (4), The Palentine (4), Republic of Dixie (4), Metriacantho (4), United idiots and other individuals (4), Harmonic Empire (4), Rakscovia (4), Kachiro (4), TexJeeps (4), Kingdom of totalitarianism (4), Willtechia (4), Codainia (4), Voroslavl (4), Gremenia (4), New Scandanavia (4), Gran Serenissima (4), St Saratoga (4), Denathor (4), Elsworthia (4), Ashaie (4), Soracana Islands (4), Orthodox Ukraine (4), The Great Lakes Partnership (4), JBR (4), AlMualin (4), Republic of Callaxium (4), Groot (4), Varmistan (4), North Power (4), Eleuthernia (4), Haruhi Japan (4), New Jamiea (4), Preblion (4), Lesbian Piraters (4), Beazlend (4), Galathion (4), Stellanova (4), Suomilandian (4), Karsti (3), Scardinius (3), Peoples Sane Holy Empire (3), Fukistrania (3), Cantanasia (3), United Western State (3), Kropotkinist Communes (3), Eastern Mystaria (3), The Lancistarian Archipelago (3), The Democratic Legion (3), Capunga (3), Marsopolis (3), Umuyyad (3), Segennea (3), Setnei (3), Kylistan (3), Depeche Mode To Joy (3), Ienovo (3), Unknown24 (3), Crawlaysia (3), Voryan (3), H Douglas (3), The Champlain (3), Gastononia (3), Lebrea (3), Jacobopolus (3), Cooomer (3), Barak Khalad (3), Shauntopia (3), Ecotopia2 (3), The Walter Republic (3), TushDeMorta (3), Solariia (3), Moosh Moosh World (3), Niger-Area (3), SiegFreeden (3), Furret Cult (3), Olivetree (3), Ourcraf (3), Beinirham (3), Wadelhelpia (3), The Age of Utopia (3), Democratic Exodian Territories (3), Kajiit (3), Kowani (3), Gonzlandia (3), CurrentOffensiveTopic (3), Tanuvar (3), World Proletarian People (3), Ves Chelo (3), Arioane (3), Dragons of Power (3), Danieldan0 (3), Loush Land (3), Lambay (3), Qisten (3), Gladoria (3), Arlii Zaldreya riy Embar (3), The Great Outer Rim (3), Korefa (3), Alpansburg (3), Aureumterra (3), Greekzantium (3), Pius Mandalore (3), Of NUGE (3), Uzushiogakure no Sato (3), Sanctity Moonlands (3), Draavida (3), Banzorland (3), Alpes a Septentrionali Imperium (3), United Dependencies (3), Grandalonia (3), Binnen de Ring (2), Libertarian Democracy (2), United Federation of California (2), Potatosain (2), New Dominioan (2), Urlendia (2), Dr ag on (2), Germeria (2), Mutazilia (2), Waluigi number one (2), Dump 64 (2), Melva (2), Ridgevale (2), Infernia (2), Teerbekistan (2), United Ediernestan (2), Pharexia (2), Healthcarium (2), Deepnest (2), Saphrosynia (2), ElectronRepublic (2), Blood and Anger (2), Sho Ban (2), Ratiolandia (2), HIV Java Cooperation (2), New Domai New Socito (2), South Yunchaek (2), Estuans Interius Imperii (2), God Junopia (2), Taeros (2), Beebung (2), United States Of RYLEE (2), Northern Gala Arment Toustavo (2), ChinchWayuq (2), The Britannia Republic (2), West Shores (2), St Nevis And Kitts (2), Alireda (2), Potato Dictatorship (2), Molson Iceland (2), West Axeton (2), Michael West (2), The great cheese (2), Hoshido and Nohr (2), Vronstkylad (2), New Isradia (2), Walist (2), Potato-Nation (2), The Authoritarian People (2), Utarchous (2), Archidamus (2), Band geng (2), Eabhair daonlathach (2), Ynoria (2), Tyrvinr (2), The Confeterated States of Petoria (2), The Communist Powers (2), Pogaria (2), Eylwe (2), Phaleina (2), The King of All Cosmos (2), Muzztopia (2), Marican (2), West End (2), Cipher Llama (2), Romulus III (2), Darbilana (2), Nacho cheese (2), Therseria (2), HENSOC (2), Ostrovskiy (2), The Fleming (2), Toopaka (2), The Akasha Colony (2), Schatztopia (2), Unified Ceres Government (2), Ariele (2), Republic of Fembois anonymous of Malta (2), New Maxwellia (2), Roye (2), Libertatis Regalis (2), Victores (2), Of blocistan (2), Vandoro (2), Raizhearth (2), Turkyss (2), Civlonia (2), Lehqhbraot (2), Hectore (2), The Hellespont (2), The United Simps (2), Orville IV (2), Raccquesi (2), Truther (2), Cannaland Island (2), Torregal (2), Land of the peeps (2), Emu Sultante (2), Scandaland (2), Regnum Credentes (2), New Albionshire (2), YouTube Inc (2), Bulindania (2), The Pop Punk Union (2), Tylliarnesium (2), Easway (2), Moto Moto pond (2), Spresia (2), Qazaq Eli (2), Cribernia (2), Ferrianona (2), Gilmore 420 (2), The Mitchfynde Difference (2), Northern Brlen Kus (2), Haroldiaistan (2), The Junts (2), Chanhu-Daro (2), Ideam-aKer (2), Cynic (2), A Deadly Wasteland (2), Aln Island (2), Hitor (2), New Cerzonius (2), Cyndorr (2), Jedingtown (2), Ilyas Hasanoff (2), Alistia (2), Achlavania (2), Azaghal (2), Kinkerland (2), Omaha Utopia (2), Main (2), Mardatan (2), Fahnair (2), Nerutia (2), Draconae (2), Spartakoi (2), Skyrim And Nordic Peoples (2), Some People on Planet Arcadia (2), Scoutistan (2), Rindin (2), Zombiedolphins (2), Dzherangrad (2), North Texia (2), Nghymru (2), Spaviland (2), Vetigo (2), Foralin (2), Mezi Mori (2), AMERICA EUROPE AND SOUTH ASIA (2), The Land of Districts (2), Cyber-Carthage (2), Narnia123456 (2), BOX PANZER I (2), Am Yisrael Chai (2), Kermea (2), The Ancient World (2), Beebians (2), Zrewolf (2), Daption Zaron (2), Victorer (2), Cynobia (2), Federation of Sarawak (2), and (8,322) individual member nations.

[Kenmoria]

"Repeal "Data Protection Accord"" was defeated 20,952 votes to 3,413.

For: 3,413: Bran Astor (965), Layem (130), Bonnie Blue Republic (77), Gonadez (37), NewTexas (31), Christian Democrats (28), New Nationale Einheit (25), New Luciannova (25), Corsoaua (22), Chicken Cutlet (18), Kustonia (14), Wuunime (13), The Flyin (12), Sylh Alanor (12), Auxorii (11), Pagrya (7), SFR Philippines (7), The Newest of Virginia (7), Ferroviaire (7), Capsland (7), People of Tyra (6), Alatoma (6), Balticonia (6), Tdogg (6), Davelands (6), CALLMEDADDYSTRATTON (6), Suternia (5), Tianjastan (5), King Rankmore (5), Lodhs beard (5), Winfallow (5), Eare Tesisia (5), SOUTH WANISTAN (5), Awesomeland012345 (5), Dux Gloriosus (4), Kalinai (4), RBBF (4), Swuoz Smua WA Delegate (4), The Eastern Pacific Islands (4), Kams Rams (4), Chlavia (3), Arconia Defender (3), Drawkland (3), The Greater Union of Man (3), The Begnion Regime (3), Afarmania (3), Hooserian (3), Bairamcea (3), Vladilan (3), Oriental Merchants (3), Meretica (3), Bettisia (3), Tranman (3), Kuromagna (3), GreatEstate (3), Kionces (3), Imren (3), Karrittland (3), The republic ofTexas and northern Mexico (2), Rivgalia (2), United Lammunist Republic (2), Colas Reich (2), Lacmhacarh (2), Lamebrainia (2), The Yeetusa (2), Negeitamonity (2), Ilmarene (2), New Finlandia (2), Corporate Triumvirate (2), Chechenastan (2), Seldt (2), Papa Fetter (2), Southern and Northern Caledonia (2), Technocratic Land of Prosperity (2), Somalwilandia (2), XKrieg (2), Goldeneye Regi0n (2), UEAM (2), Nydelok (2), Het Solen (2), Castilistan (2), The Empire of Hoodania (2), Blatter Land (2), New Aradania (2), Acinonyx Nivalis (2), Nopengie (2), Arab Darussalam (2), Laissez-faire Federated States (2), Nikitan (2), Vampiric Hollandia (2), Mpia (2), Nastropolis (2), Irish socialist soviet republics (2), Anarchist Polish States (2), Jamez Empire (2), Joderia (2), Byrdonia (2), Comackia (2), TySdUR (2), President Pro Tempore (2), Folgoria (2), Adeiatic (2), Slightly Better Latvia (2), Legolannd (2), Anishier (2), Nouvelle Maison (2), Bohamas (2), Sedgistan (2), Facebook Moms Union of Minion Memes (2), South Burtander (2), and (1,700) individual member nations.

Against: 20,952: McMasterdonia (1,461), Aumeltopia (1,155), Marrabuk (1,047), Kuriko (866), East Durthang (659), Aexnidaral (481), Imperium Anglorum (394), North East Somerset (302), Dead I Jack (286), Treadwellia (282), Llorens (252), OF Arian Hellas (231), New Jaedonstan (218), Rikuchar (184), Titanne (173), ShrewLlamaLand (172), Dekks (171), Sorentia (153), Zentata (138), Dome Artan (134), Takura (128), Laurennia (127), Nulkia (127), One Small Island (119), Yodle (110), Bietzopolis (105), Lesser Velutaria (92), The Salaxalans (71), Mikeswill (70), Koiho (69), Enlais (66), Dabberwocky (62), These United Socialists (62), Vancouvia (60), Pure Blooded Whites (51), Bretislavia (51), Greater Victora (48), New Gandor (46), New Legland (46), Kamchakta (44), Albrook (42), Telgan (42), Mother Bear (41), Altorthfnara (40), United Calanworie (40), Karteria (39), Lord Terrorizer of Spammers (38), Asian Lands (37), Lauchenoiria (37), Arudis (35), Mikoyansk (32), Thembria SSR (32), Candensia (30), Aynia Moreaux (26), Alcala-Cordel (26), Bearded Dragones (25), Amantes Farchka (24), Halcyon Nova (24), Ukraniumstan (23), South Krimelski (23), Switzar (23), Breadoria (22), Neo Kerala (21), Johanneslanden (20), Scaneland (19), United Massachusetts (19), ScotlandSerenity (17), Ile Morice (17), The Socialist Republic of Saian (16), Greater Cuba (15), Palsada (15), The New North Republic (14), Albarusija (14), Catterborough (13), Durchhalten (13), Acaciatropole (13), Lead Keion (13), Ariusgrad (12), Atlantian Oceania (12), Prodstrazka (12), Pontanova (12), Wanarpu (12), Newreath (12), Orca and Narwhal (12), FireFox15 (12), Losconia (11), The Sheika (11), Hydroponic Nation (11), The Soviet state of Svalbard (11), Notty Swaras (11), Canogally (11), GAIAD (11), Sail Nation (10), Marlida (10), Dierexa (10), Otaku Stratus (10), Ampolia (10), Madresia (10), Sereteia (10), Luxenermy (10), New Eberron (9), San Lumen (9), FORKTASTICSTAN (9), 3XH181T A (9), Wobbegong (8), The States of France (8), The Greater Nordics (8), The Regalian Underland (8), Orennica (8), Lorthanien (8), OmegaShenron (8), Auruga (8), Draganisia (8), Western Arab Empire (8), Mundane (8), GoodKingWenceslas (7), Mmm monkey (7), Amblibahdesh (7), Riocht mor Daraen (7), Omniabstracta (7), Shaker (7), BasedTupacFan27 (7), Browzantine (7), Kindjal (7), Valtula (7), Fdryden (7), Whims (7), The Greater Low Countries (7), Ankoz (7), Bej (7), The Chuck (6), Lamoni (6), New Delfos (6), Teekerbocker (6), Aelythium (6), New Chillvania (6), Focis Vitae (6), Lord Plembington (6), Flor-Fina (6), Australian rePublic (6), Medoynia (6), The Voltarum (6), Cool Guys and Alex (5), Draekonya (5), United England n Wales (5), West Intermarium (5), The United Peoples of Caedis (5), The Eastern Antarctic State (5), Shineon (5), South Sulphur (5), Cash Monet (5), Of Britannia and Hibernia (5), People of Phoenix (5), Greater Christian (5), Tzedeck (5), Pinochet Executionists (5), Empire of Atlanta (5), New Ontaria (5), Wabacha (5), Bayuda (5), Baophenx Dynasty (5), The People Of New Thebes (5), Golanchia (5), Fed Dusistan (5), Valtrona (5), Smiley Bob (5), Epic Super Bros (5), Kalix (4), Legal Free Weed (4), The Palentine (4), Republic of Dixie (4), Metriacantho (4), United idiots and other individuals (4), Harmonic Empire (4), Rakscovia (4), Kachiro (4), TexJeeps (4), Kingdom of totalitarianism (4), Willtechia (4), Codainia (4), Voroslavl (4), Gremenia (4), New Scandanavia (4), Gran Serenissima (4), St Saratoga (4), Denathor (4), Elsworthia (4), Ashaie (4), Soracana Islands (4), Orthodox Ukraine (4), The Great Lakes Partnership (4), JBR (4), AlMualin (4), Republic of Callaxium (4), Groot (4), Varmistan (4), North Power (4), Eleuthernia (4), Haruhi Japan (4), New Jamiea (4), Preblion (4), Lesbian Piraters (4), Beazlend (4), Galathion (4), Stellanova (4), Suomilandian (4), Karsti (3), Scardinius (3), Peoples Sane Holy Empire (3), Fukistrania (3), Cantanasia (3), United Western State (3), Kropotkinist Communes (3), Eastern Mystaria (3), The Lancistarian Archipelago (3), The Democratic Legion (3), Capunga (3), Marsopolis (3), Umuyyad (3), Segennea (3), Setnei (3), Kylistan (3), Depeche Mode To Joy (3), Ienovo (3), Unknown24 (3), Crawlaysia (3), Voryan (3), H Douglas (3), The Champlain (3), Gastononia (3), Lebrea (3), Jacobopolus (3), Cooomer (3), Barak Khalad (3), Shauntopia (3), Ecotopia2 (3), The Walter Republic (3), TushDeMorta (3), Solariia (3), Moosh Moosh World (3), Niger-Area (3), SiegFreeden (3), Furret Cult (3), Olivetree (3), Ourcraf (3), Beinirham (3), Wadelhelpia (3), The Age of Utopia (3), Democratic Exodian Territories (3), Kajiit (3), Kowani (3), Gonzlandia (3), CurrentOffensiveTopic (3), Tanuvar (3), World Proletarian People (3), Ves Chelo (3), Arioane (3), Dragons of Power (3), Danieldan0 (3), Loush Land (3), Lambay (3), Qisten (3), Gladoria (3), Arlii Zaldreya riy Embar (3), The Great Outer Rim (3), Korefa (3), Alpansburg (3), Aureumterra (3), Greekzantium (3), Pius Mandalore (3), Of NUGE (3), Uzushiogakure no Sato (3), Sanctity Moonlands (3), Draavida (3), Banzorland (3), Alpes a Septentrionali Imperium (3), United Dependencies (3), Grandalonia (3), Binnen de Ring (2), Libertarian Democracy (2), United Federation of California (2), Potatosain (2), New Dominioan (2), Urlendia (2), Dr ag on (2), Germeria (2), Mutazilia (2), Waluigi number one (2), Dump 64 (2), Melva (2), Ridgevale (2), Infernia (2), Teerbekistan (2), United Ediernestan (2), Pharexia (2), Healthcarium (2), Deepnest (2), Saphrosynia (2), ElectronRepublic (2), Blood and Anger (2), Sho Ban (2), Ratiolandia (2), HIV Java Cooperation (2), New Domai New Socito (2), South Yunchaek (2), Estuans Interius Imperii (2), God Junopia (2), Taeros (2), Beebung (2), United States Of RYLEE (2), Northern Gala Arment Toustavo (2), ChinchWayuq (2), The Britannia Republic (2), West Shores (2), St Nevis And Kitts (2), Alireda (2), Potato Dictatorship (2), Molson Iceland (2), West Axeton (2), Michael West (2), The great cheese (2), Hoshido and Nohr (2), Vronstkylad (2), New Isradia (2), Walist (2), Potato-Nation (2), The Authoritarian People (2), Utarchous (2), Archidamus (2), Band geng (2), Eabhair daonlathach (2), Ynoria (2), Tyrvinr (2), The Confeterated States of Petoria (2), The Communist Powers (2), Pogaria (2), Eylwe (2), Phaleina (2), The King of All Cosmos (2), Muzztopia (2), Marican (2), West End (2), Cipher Llama (2), Romulus III (2), Darbilana (2), Nacho cheese (2), Therseria (2), HENSOC (2), Ostrovskiy (2), The Fleming (2), Toopaka (2), The Akasha Colony (2), Schatztopia (2), Unified Ceres Government (2), Ariele (2), Republic of Fembois anonymous of Malta (2), New Maxwellia (2), Roye (2), Libertatis Regalis (2), Victores (2), Of blocistan (2), Vandoro (2), Raizhearth (2), Turkyss (2), Civlonia (2), Lehqhbraot (2), Hectore (2), The Hellespont (2), The United Simps (2), Orville IV (2), Raccquesi (2), Truther (2), Cannaland Island (2), Torregal (2), Land of the peeps (2), Emu Sultante (2), Scandaland (2), Regnum Credentes (2), New Albionshire (2), YouTube Inc (2), Bulindania (2), The Pop Punk Union (2), Tylliarnesium (2), Easway (2), Moto Moto pond (2), Spresia (2), Qazaq Eli (2), Cribernia (2), Ferrianona (2), Gilmore 420 (2), The Mitchfynde Difference (2), Northern Brlen Kus (2), Haroldiaistan (2), The Junts (2), Chanhu-Daro (2), Ideam-aKer (2), Cynic (2), A Deadly Wasteland (2), Aln Island (2), Hitor (2), New Cerzonius (2), Cyndorr (2), Jedingtown (2), Ilyas Hasanoff (2), Alistia (2), Achlavania (2), Azaghal (2), Kinkerland (2), Omaha Utopia (2), Main (2), Mardatan (2), Fahnair (2), Nerutia (2), Draconae (2), Spartakoi (2), Skyrim And Nordic Peoples (2), Some People on Planet Arcadia (2), Scoutistan (2), Rindin (2), Zombiedolphins (2), Dzherangrad (2), North Texia (2), Nghymru (2), Spaviland (2), Vetigo (2), Foralin (2), Mezi Mori (2), AMERICA EUROPE AND SOUTH ASIA (2), The Land of Districts (2), Cyber-Carthage (2), Narnia123456 (2), BOX PANZER I (2), Am Yisrael Chai (2), Kermea (2), The Ancient World (2), Beebians (2), Zrewolf (2), Daption Zaron (2), Victorer (2), Cynobia (2), Federation of Sarawak (2), and (8,322) individual member nations.

(OOC: Commiserations, United Cats. This does demonstrate the importance of drafting.)