[DEFEATED] Condemn Nations Creating Regions For SC Props (*)

[Tinhampton]

Defeated on 18th April 2020: FOR 1,562 (9.4%) --- AGAINST 15,058 (90.6%)

(*): This proposal was written by Davelands, WA Delegate for The Sportsbook and the former WAD of The West Pacific. I did not write or submit this proposal, and I did not write the campaign telegram that brought it to queue. Will (probably) come to vote between minor update on Tuesday 14th April and minor update on Saturday 18th April, after Commend Kuriko's seemingly-inevitable passage.

AS OF 0445 BST ON EASTER SUNDAY: Approvals: 79 out of 70 needed (Rikuchar, South Newlandia, Telgan, Kaystein, Negeitamonity, Albrook, The Chuck, Trinibad1, Thembria SSR, Kelantan State, Mpia, East Durthang, Ransium, Pletamia, Titanne, Vicitania, New Legland, Cancerous Memeboys, Setnei, Prelet, Zentata, Smiley Bob, God-King Rorschach, Frogsrael, The Newest of Virginia, DiRito-Opolis, Yodle, Team Lennox, Corncube, Ile Morice, Sereteia, Otaku Stratus, Alzerman, ScotlandSerenity, Phloryda, Balgul, Johanneslanden, Kowani, Magical Anime Girl Thighs, Quarentia, Ratiolandia, Aiyyocheta, Gremenia, Alcala-Cordel, United Massachusetts, GAIAD, RureCorona, Halcyon Nova, Cariacica, Ilmarene, Regnum Credentes, Legolannd, Dabberwocky, The Waffleonian Reich, Spexico, Lower Delkorpilydriumphe, Davelands, Scardinius, Chanhu-Daro, Lesser Velutaria, Papa Fetter, Aynia Moreaux, Comackia, People of Phoenix, Bairamcea, Notty Swaras, Baophenx Dynasty, New Nationale Einheit, Peoples Sane Holy Empire, Nopengie, JucheGang Red Fleet Outpost, South Krimelski, Hallownesians, Socratipolis, Arlii Zaldreya riy Embar, Avidesatan, Diplomatic Territories, The Greater Low Countries, Cyndorr)

Condemn Nations Creating Regions For SC Props
A resolution to express shock and dismay at a nation or region.

Category: Condemnation

Nominee: Nations Creating Regions For SC Props

Proposed by: Davelands

---

NOTICING Nations Creating Regions For SC Props,

DISMAYED at the recent trend of Nations Creating Regions For SC Props;

HORRIFIED that Nations Creating Regions For SC Props might continue indefinitely;

BELIEVING that the terrible practices of Nations Creating Regions For SC Props deserve widespread recognition across the world;

HEREBY CONDEMNS Nations Creating Regions For SC Props.

[Guaylandia]

This is a beautifully ironic resolution. But a better way to deal with the issue would be to just repeal Condemn This Game and vote down/not approve Condemn The World Assembly Elite.

[Honeydewistania]

Against. I think the best measure would be to ignore these annoying proposals, rather than sort of encourage them.

[Daytime to Night]

Enjoyed the humor but slightly surprised this got ruled legal on the joke proposal rule. I would suggest that this falls on the wrong side of that, offering no genuine content worthy of a vote, and should have been posted on the forums and not submitted.

Obviously it doesn't fall foul of the DON'T SUBMIT rule in terms of flamey proposals that don't give a target a right of reply, but its just pretty spammy at this point and will hold up well written necessary proposals and drag down interest in the Security Council

[Blood Wine]

I'm more surprised it got ruled legal even though i'm pretty sure it's a r4 violation

>DISMAYED at the recent trend of Nations Creating Regions For SC Props;

[Sedgistan]

It's no worse than "Condemn This Game", which WA members saw fit to pass. Not seeing a R4 violation there either.

[Wallenburg]

It's nothing more than a joke, and a tasteless, unimaginative, undrafted one at that. This condemnation has not earned my consideration and certainly not my vote.

[South Reinkalistan]

Against. This is a joke, and a waste of time.

[Bormiar]

So glad to see that people who voted for Condemn this Game have gotten sick of this.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

I don’t think I’ve seen an SC proposal get so thoroughly stomped in the first hour of voting.

[Daytime to Night]

I'm more surprised it got ruled legal even though i'm pretty sure it's a r4 violation

>DISMAYED at the recent trend of Nations Creating Regions For SC Props;

Ruling something a R4 violation on the wording within an actual nation or regions name would be very problematic but I feel like a judgment call could have been made on the joke proposal rule, rather than wasting 4 days of voting on this.

Also have a for every delegate that approved this and will inevitably now vote against it.

[Fire Taco]

Why isit like 200-5,000 i’m out of the loop

[Luziyca]

Why isit like 200-5,000 i’m out of the loop

Because this resolution, quite frankly, may as well be a joke proposal. It condemns nations creating regions for SC props, all the while doing the exact same thing.

That was precisely why I, the ambassador of Luziyca, voted against the proposal.

[ShrewLlamaLand]

smh WA Elite dumping all their votes early again.

[Concrete Slab]

(Image)

smh WA Elite dumping all their votes early again.

That's just... how the game works? Vote early vote often? And you also voted with the "WA Elite" early in the vote.

[South Acren]

Against, And I'm starting to see a trend of these silly and sometimes poorly worded proposals, as we see now. I advise anyone to vote against.

[Morover]

(Image)

smh WA Elite dumping all their votes early again.

That's just... how the game works? Vote early vote often? And you also voted with the "WA Elite" early in the vote.

Not to defend Shrew here, but I do believe they were making a joke.

[Concrete Slab]

That's just... how the game works? Vote early vote often? And you also voted with the "WA Elite" early in the vote.

Not to defend Shrew here, but I do believe they were making a joke.

*smacks forehead*
My bad, I'm tired.

[Denmeria]

I voted against Condemn This Game, but this is way worse...AGAINST, and I recommend you vote against too

[The New Sicilian State]

(Image)

smh WA Elite dumping all their votes early again.

[OOC: Whoops, said some mean things and overlooked the fact that you were making a joke. My honest apologies, it's been a terrible day.]

[Guaylandia]

These are the largest margins against a resolution I've seen in a long time.

Surprising, because I only got 1 campaign telegram, and it was in favor.

I guess that says something about the power of the GCRs people.

[South Acren]

These are the largest margins against a resolution I've seen in a long time.

Surprising, because I only got 1 campaign telegram, and it was in favor.

I guess that says something about the power of the GCRs people.

Or....you know....the resolution is as badly worded as it is unneeded and unhelpful. Honestly i dislike it for how ridiculous it is. I mean, it doesn't even explain into detail what the region is or what they have done. Its just a joke resolution, no better then the others.

[Guaylandia]

These are the largest margins against a resolution I've seen in a long time.

Surprising, because I only got 1 campaign telegram, and it was in favor.

I guess that says something about the power of the GCRs people.

Or....you know....the resolution is as badly worded as it is unneeded and unhelpful. Honestly i dislike it for how ridiculous it is. I mean, it doesn't even explain into detail what the region is or what they have done. Its just a joke resolution, no better then the others.

That was a bit of a joke.

For the record, I'm also strongly against the resolution. Joke resolutions shouldn't ever reach a vote, and this should just be dealt with by deciding not to approve SC prop region commendations/condemnations outside of April Fools Day.

[South Acren]

That was a bit of a joke.

For the record, I'm also strongly against the resolution. Joke resolutions shouldn't ever reach a vote, and this should just be dealt with by deciding not to approve SC prop region commendations/condemnations outside of April Fools Day.

You know, this happened in this forum earlier XD Its hard to tell a joke from seriousness nowadays.

[Guaylandia]

That was a bit of a joke.

For the record, I'm also strongly against the resolution. Joke resolutions shouldn't ever reach a vote, and this should just be dealt with by deciding not to approve SC prop region commendations/condemnations outside of April Fools Day.

You know, this happened in this forum earlier XD Its hard to tell a joke from seriousness nowadays.

Equally hard to make satire that doesn't look too serious. I think that was more of the problem in this case.