Page 1 of 2

[PASSED] Commend Wintony

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 11:23 am
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Commend Wintony

Author: Kawaii Schoolgirl | Category: Commendation | Nominee: Wintony


The Security Council,

Understanding that commendations are considered awards that are dedicated to nations for their significant accomplishments.

Believing the nation of Wintony to be a valid candidate for such an award.

Remembers Wintony's humble beginnings in the region of The Council of Noteworthy Nations, a small region home to nations who considered each other close friends. However, through years of growing inactivity in the region, Wintony left CONN for Illuminati in February of 2015, intrigued by the region's history as well as the promise of a larger role in the greater world.

Understands, however, that much of Illuminati's recruitment was nothing more than propaganda to lure suspecting nations in. There was a system in place in the region by its founder that ensured that no nation could rise to their full potential; in other words, the founder made sure no nation could become too influential, and that any who were popular supported and carried out the founder's agenda.

Highlights that Illuminati has long been involved with and responsible for harassing behavior against a number of regions and individual nations. This is made clear with its involvement with the Aeazen Combine, an organization which had become vilified for the destruction of forums belonging to certain regions which had been targeted. This being merely one of many examples of Illuminati's past behaviors.

Admires the March Revolution which sought to unify Illuminati against Rhyphix in light of the forceful dismissal of its Directorate, Dominionaire. This revolt had sparked the most activity in the region up to that point in time, however, despite their efforts, nothing could be done to bring about the change they wanted to see. Wintony would return back to CONN for the remainder of that year.

Applauds Wintony's return to Illuminati in which they had been invited back to. Wintony felt saddened by the dead state Illuminati had fallen into after revolt in March that previous year. Wintony wanted to repair the region and try to make Illuminati's dream something more than propaganda, and so Wintony would become the region's 52nd Grand Chancellor once again, and under this distinguished nation's leadership, Illuminati began to see a new record breaking surge of activity once again. This would mark a golden age in Illuminati, the government was active, it had a hard working cultural department, and a number of great projects were in the works such as G.O.D. and G.A.I.A. which would have aided its global news network.

Praises Wintony for the leadership and integrity displayed throughout the nation's time as Grand Chancellor, and more so during the regional purge of June 19th, 2016, when Wintony had been violently deported from the region by the founder, in light of Wintony winning a popularity vote, which had only come about due to Rhyphix's push to remove the nation as the region's grand chancellor. It was on this day that the nations of Illuminati learned the true nature of the region and its founder, and with Wintony's forceful removal from the region, dozens would follow, leaving Illuminati for the region of Exodus.

Recognizes Wintony as the prime leader of both the Exodus-Illuminati war and Illuminati Revolution, the latter of which resulted in successfully ending Rhyphix's power grasp over the region, by guiding the nations of Kawaii Village, Altino, and Rigels Light through the process and advising each move that needed to be taken.

Fully Understanding that without Wintony's guidance, a revolution in Illuminati would have been unlikely, and Rhyphix would continue to harass the world and keep citizens of the region under the founder's influence and control.

Hereby Commends the nation of Wintony

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 11:58 am
by Lord Dominator
Currently opposed, I don't think there's enough justification for it.
Kudos for the forum drafting and excellent writing though

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:13 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Lord Dominator wrote:Currently opposed, I don't think there's enough justification for it.
Kudos for the forum drafting and excellent writing though

Okay, that's perfectly alright, but what if I were to give more detail then?

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:15 pm
by Lord Dominator
Kawaii Schoolgirl wrote:
Lord Dominator wrote:Currently opposed, I don't think there's enough justification for it.
Kudos for the forum drafting and excellent writing though

Okay, that's perfectly alright, but what if I were to give more detail then?

More detail is always good, you gave 5k characters to work with

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:17 pm
by Willania Imperium
It's a good start, with strong points. I do agree with the consensus of more detail and info is needed, but I think I'd support it as it is. More info is always good.

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:18 pm
by Lord Dominator
Willania Imperium wrote:It's a good start, with strong points. I do agree with the consensus of more detail and info is needed, but I think I'd support it as it is. More info is always good.

This. Also, another thought but I don't think there's enough about why we should care what they did

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:30 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Alright, thank you both! I will work on making it better and will be sure to let you know when I've made my edits. ^_^

PostPosted: Sun Mar 18, 2018 12:31 pm
by Lord Dominator
Kawaii Schoolgirl wrote:Alright, thank you both! I will work on making it better and will be sure to let you know when I've made my edits. ^_^

That's great, glad to be of some assistance!

PostPosted: Mon Mar 19, 2018 10:53 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Okay the proposal has been heavily revised to include more content in effort to better highlight Wintony's accomplishments. I hope this will prove to be a better draft, but again, if there's anything that may need to be added/revised, I will be glad to consider it.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:04 am
by Willania Imperium
Hey, that's pretty good! It's very detailed and informative.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 3:06 am
by Arotania
Is the dissonance between category (Condemnation) and language used (Admires, Honors, Applauds...) intended? This reads quite strange to me at the moment.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 3:08 am
by Wrapper
Arotania wrote:Is the dissonance between category (Condemnation) and language used (Admires, Honors, Applauds...) intended? This reads quite strange to me at the moment.

Indeed. If it reads like a commendation, why not make it a commendation?

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:03 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Wrapper wrote:
Arotania wrote:Is the dissonance between category (Condemnation) and language used (Admires, Honors, Applauds...) intended? This reads quite strange to me at the moment.

Indeed. If it reads like a commendation, why not make it a commendation?

I can change it to that category for sure. :)

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:11 pm
by Lenlyvit
Much better Kawaii :)

Honors Wintony's short involvement in DEN in February 2016. Through the course of about a month, Wintony had participated in raiding an estimate of over 450 regions including the occupations of Anarchy, Portugal, Atlantis, Antarctica, and Shadow Proclamation. Wintony had also once took part in a record breaking raid of 65 regions all being tagged in a single minor update, and had also been involved with a minor update raid in which 112 regions were hit, awarding him and all participants had the Iron Cross. Wintony would also receive Cimmerian Purple Heart days later as well. These many accomplishments were done, as stated earlier, under the span of about a month, when Wintony left DEN, returning to Illuminati that March.


Bolded part breaks Rule 4(b). Otherwise, a few grammatical mistakes but I support :)

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:17 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Lenlyvit wrote:Much better Kawaii :)

Honors Wintony's short involvement in DEN in February 2016. Through the course of about a month, Wintony had participated in raiding an estimate of over 450 regions including the occupations of Anarchy, Portugal, Atlantis, Antarctica, and Shadow Proclamation. Wintony had also once took part in a record breaking raid of 65 regions all being tagged in a single minor update, and had also been involved with a minor update raid in which 112 regions were hit, awarding him and all participants had the Iron Cross. Wintony would also receive Cimmerian Purple Heart days later as well. These many accomplishments were done, as stated earlier, under the span of about a month, when Wintony left DEN, returning to Illuminati that March.


Bolded part breaks Rule 4(b). Otherwise, a few grammatical mistakes but I support :)

Hey, Lenny! ^_^ Thank you, for noticing that, it's been fixed.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 12:26 pm
by Malphe
Image

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 1:28 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Unless anyone has anything more to add, I will move to submit this proposal tonight. Thank you to everyone who has helped so far, and a special thanks to Lenny who's caught several errors in the proposal.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 1:57 pm
by RiderSyl
The only reason Wintony was able to raid 450 regions in 1 month with DEN was because DEN was cheating with Predator.exe, which the entire region got deleted for, just 2 months after Wintony left. The section "honoring" Wintony's time in DEN should be entirely removed from the proposal.

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 2:06 pm
by Lord Dominator
RiderSyl wrote:The only reason Wintony was able to raid 450 regions in 1 month with DEN was because DEN was cheating with Predator.exe, which the entire region got deleted for, just 2 months after Wintony left. The section "honoring" Wintony's time in DEN should be entirely removed from the proposal.

If so, then the above should occur.

Otherwise I support

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 2:09 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Lord Dominator wrote:
RiderSyl wrote:The only reason Wintony was able to raid 450 regions in 1 month with DEN was because DEN was cheating with Predator.exe, which the entire region got deleted for, just 2 months after Wintony left. The section "honoring" Wintony's time in DEN should be entirely removed from the proposal.

If so, then the above should occur.

Otherwise I support
RiderSyl wrote:The only reason Wintony was able to raid 450 regions in 1 month with DEN was because DEN was cheating with Predator.exe, which the entire region got deleted for, just 2 months after Wintony left. The section "honoring" Wintony's time in DEN should be entirely removed from the proposal.

Okay I think that is fair enough. :) Consider it done!

PostPosted: Tue Mar 20, 2018 7:12 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
The proposal has been submitted! Please help get it to quorum by voting here:
https://www.nationstates.net/page=UN_vi ... 1521597295

PostPosted: Thu Mar 22, 2018 8:26 am
by Fauxia
Lord Dominator wrote:Currently opposed, I don't think there's enough justification for it.
Kudos for the forum drafting and excellent writing though
I second this

PostPosted: Thu Mar 22, 2018 2:29 pm
by Lord Dominator
Seeing change, full support

PostPosted: Thu Mar 22, 2018 3:07 pm
by Kawaii Schoolgirl
Lord Dominator wrote:Seeing change, full support

Thank you, we're almost up to quorum! ^_^

PostPosted: Thu Mar 22, 2018 6:21 pm
by Willania Imperium
We're in quorum! I repeat we're in quorum!

UPDATE: We at the Imperial SC Delegation apologize for the mistaken declaration of quorum reaching. As such, we rescind our declaration and will remove all involved parties.