[PASSED] Condemn Wrapper

[Jabberwocky]

Despite the fact that Wrapper locked one of my threads for what I considered purely arbitrary reasons, the wording of the proposal reads like an ad hominem attack based upon a personal dislike of Wrapper. The draft assumes definitions upon which there is clearly no consensual agreement. For those reasons, Sherlock Quixote is opposed.

[Herby]

Despite the fact that Wrapper locked one of my threads for what I considered purely arbitrary reasons, the wording of the proposal reads like an ad hominem attack based upon a personal dislike of Wrapper. The draft assumes definitions upon which there is clearly no consensual agreement. For those reasons, Sherlock Quixote is opposed.

A personal dislike? In real life? Heh heh heh heh. Nothing could be farther from the truth!

[Harbertia]

In this Condemnation, there's 3 weak points that never should have made the final draft. They're just stupid. Nothing is condemn-worthy about karaoke night, Groot jokes, or a shitpost in The Strangers' Bar.

Your awkward WA forum in-jokes don't belong in a Condemn proposal, guys. It just makes it cringe-worthy, and easier to repeal.

[Harbertia]

The WA's resolutions don't even affect the individual member states

Incorrect. As moderator Mallorea and Riva state there is confusion on this point and they provide a good example in this section. I first discovered the impact when I was a WA member under the name 'Megacorp' or 'Megacorp International' and saw my government category altered upon the passing of a WA resolution as prior I had stopped responding to naton issues having achieved the desired corporate government form.

[Ransium]

The WA's resolutions don't even affect the individual member states

Incorrect. As moderator Mallorea and Riva state there is confusion on this point and they provide a good example in this section. I first discovered the impact when I was a WA member under the name 'Megacorp' or 'Megacorp International' and saw my government category altered upon the passing of a WA resolution as prior I had stopped responding to naton issues having achieved the desired corporate government form.

Okay, I’ve got to step in and correct factual inaccuracy. You’re confused. General Assembly legislation impacts stats. Condemnations/commendations do nothing stats wise.

Overall, my intent was not to cause such offense to Wrapper, you, or this August Assembly and I’m truly sorry I did offend you.

[Harbertia]

Incorrect. As moderator Mallorea and Riva state there is confusion on this point and they provide a good example in this section. I first discovered the impact when I was a WA member under the name 'Megacorp' or 'Megacorp International' and saw my government category altered upon the passing of a WA resolution as prior I had stopped responding to naton issues having achieved the desired corporate government form.

Okay, I’ve got to step in and correct factual inaccuracy. You’re confused. General Assembly legislation impacts stats. Condemnations/commendations do nothing stats wise.

Overall, my intent was not to cause such offense to Wrapper, you, or this August Assembly and I’m truly sorry I did offend you.

You've not offended, and my response to Oresland was in regards to stats as his [Oresland's] direct statement was that WA resolutions don't impact member stats and thus I provided a link detailing which stats are impacted by what category of resolution. Wrapper himself isn't offended, he's TGed me personally to state that he's not. No one is presently offended though I did initially freak out and am thankful that you handled it so well on the regional discussion thread. The appeal it's self provides greater detail on my position.

[Jabberwocky]

Despite the fact that Wrapper locked one of my threads for what I considered purely arbitrary reasons, the wording of the proposal reads like an ad hominem attack based upon a personal dislike of Wrapper. The draft assumes definitions upon which there is clearly no consensual agreement. For those reasons, Sherlock Quixote is opposed.

A personal dislike? In real life? Heh heh heh heh. Nothing could be farther from the truth!

Real life? In NS? Absurd!

[Lord Dominator]

Full support, we clearly need to give this total menace a badge signifying how bad they are

[Liagolas]

In this Condemnation, there's 3 weak points that never should have made the final draft. They're just stupid. Nothing is condemn-worthy about karaoke night, Groot jokes, or a shitpost in The Strangers' Bar.

Your awkward WA forum in-jokes don't belong in a Condemn proposal, guys. It just makes it cringe-worthy, and easier to repeal.

"Then this august body shall await the repeal and thereupon the revocation of the Puddle-Jumping Wads' fancy sticker," the Mouth of the Dominion says while finagling with the snarled microphone cords of a karaoke machine. "Since it is so easy, it is the expectation of the Dominion that it should not take long."

[RiderSyl]

In this Condemnation, there's 3 weak points that never should have made the final draft. They're just stupid. Nothing is condemn-worthy about karaoke night, Groot jokes, or a shitpost in The Strangers' Bar.

Your awkward WA forum in-jokes don't belong in a Condemn proposal, guys. It just makes it cringe-worthy, and easier to repeal.

"Then this august body shall await the repeal and thereupon the revocation of the Puddle-Jumping Wads' fancy sticker," the Mouth of the Dominion says while finagling with the snarled microphone cords of a karaoke machine. "Since it is so easy, it is the expectation of the Dominion that it should not take long."

I said those clauses make it easier to repeal. I didn't say the proposal would be easy to repeal. Try reading next time.

[New Keam]

The WA Ambassador from New Keam rises from his seat. "This is the best condemnation ever written. I call on everyone to vote for it".

[Herby]

In this Condemnation, there's 3 weak points that never should have made the final draft. They're just stupid. Nothing is condemn-worthy about karaoke night, Groot jokes, or a shitpost in The Strangers' Bar.

Your awkward WA forum in-jokes don't belong in a Condemn proposal, guys. It just makes it cringe-worthy, and easier to repeal.

Ehhhhh lighten up Francis. If we can get a chuckle outta GA regulars, Marvel fanboys/fangirls and karaoke haters (OOC Seriously, you ever been to a karaoke bar? I passed by one in a cruise ship once and hoo boy talk about cringe-worthy!) then it was all worth it. Besides 12000ish votes can’t all be wrong!

The WA Ambassador from New Keam rises from his seat. "This is the best condemnation ever written. I call on everyone to vote for it".

Hear that? Best damn one ever! Thank you ehhhhhh wait a sec who the hell are you?

[The Atlae Isles]

Why immortalize the positive with a negative label? Should a man who has lived a life of celibacy be branded a rapist?

Condemnations are badges of honor, like commendations. They're for playing the game in an 'evil' manner.

It is NOT just whoever is the worst player. Recent examples include the repeals of condemnations of raiders who used Predator. The logic was that they cheated, so they don't deserve a condemnation.

It is also worth noting that often times, commendations are also repealed after what some consider OOC acts.

A condemnation, if there are no penalties attached, will remain as a badge of honor, and doesn't really hinder the recipient in any way.

[Fungoose]

this is stupid

[Queen Yuno]

I voted for this because Wrapper is nice.

[Fishy Apples]

The WA Ambassador from New Keam rises from his seat. "This is the best condemnation ever written. I call on everyone to vote for it".

"We concur!! This is one of the greatest issues of our time. It is of the utmost imperative we vote for this. Do it... do it for the apples......" *left eye twitches involuntarily*

[Herby]

I voted for this because Wrapper is nice.

But....... but........ ehhhhhh okay sure we’ll take it.

Okay so it looks like this one’s gonna squeak by. Heh heh. Actually we’re gonna break the record for most votes cast in favor of a condemnation. Dayum, you guys either really love Wrapper or really hate him. Me.... ehhhhh.........

[Abunenin]

I condem wrapper simply because he authored that ban on ritual sacrifice.....how else do u keep the sun rising everyday?

[Ransium]

Condemn Wrapper was passed 13,834 votes to 4,038.

I 100% thought the vote total would be reversed. I'm glad NS has such a sense of humor. Or is taking this way to seriously. Not sure which. Anyways, glad this is on the books. I think I might have to resign from authoring SC proposals though, as it is clearly all downhill for me from here.

Also so much credit to my co-author Herby, this as all their idea, I just made some mediocre words.

[Wrapper]

Well now. I honestly don't know whether to say "you guys suck" or "woo hoo, thanks." I never realized I was both so popular and so reviled.

Ransium, job well done.

Herby...

Although I must agree a little bit with Syl, you two did go a little overboard including Groot and Drane. The Ritual Sacrifice resolution is one thing, but the hurricane relief jar, there was a story there I was going to post in the Bar but never got around to it, something about Drane losing his home. Minor quibbles, not going to dwell on it, so you shouldn't either. Overall, a fine effort.

Now if you'll all excuse me, I'm going to accidentally ban a few nations and lock some random threads. You know, bumbling incompetence and all that.

[Herby]

You’re welcome ya big lovable goofball.