NationStates

Just to be on the safe side, it's quite a close vote, feedback appreciated as always.

REPEAL "LIBERATE HOGWARTS"
Category: Repeal | Resolution: SC #145

---

The Security Council

Denouncing the use of SC #145 as a weapon against the current government of Hogwarts;

Highlighting the biased logic applied by the resolution author who on one hand acknowledges that this is yet another reincarnation of a dead/dying region, yet laments those who have pursued the refounding of it, suggesting that the largest issue here, is not the refound, but those who seek to do so;

Sickened that such a proposal would be utilized which goes against the mission statement of this council, simply because of whom has chosen to resurrect it as opposed to the intent of the people doing so;

Appalled that this resolution was passed without any true consultation with the native population, wherein to do so would not have resulted in the passage of this resolution in a manner which has clearly divided the international community;

Noting the authors hopes that "Hogwarts can maintain its history of being a free, open, and peaceful region in the spirit of the community" yet highlighting the authors biased tarring of the fate of this region by stating that "the invader culture of the Lone Wolves United is a threat to this hope," despite LWU's statement they wish to bring activity to the region;

Desirous to ensure that the purposes and ideals of this esteemed Council are not subverted to the prejudices of its members against ideologies and utilized for the purposes of undermining any group without some shred of evidence to their intent;

Hereby;
Repeals SC #145, Liberate Hogwarts

Well here is some evidence of their true intent.

Evil Wolf wrote:

Defendingg wrote: I hope that some delegates will change their votes in order to give Hogwarts back to the true natives, before it is destroyed forever.

Ah yes, the alleged "true natives", none of which can be found nor named. The region is not being "destroyed forever" it is being refounded to make sure people like Defendingg don't claim it as a trophy for themselves.

So you admit that you are refounding it? Good to know.

I admit nothing, I have no allegiance to LWU, what I do see here, is a proposal being used to subvert LWU on the sole basis that they are raiders, and thus raiders must be bad and be intent on doing bad things, which is, to be frank, utter bollox.

Defendingg wrote:Well here is some evidence of their true intent.

Evil Wolf wrote:
Ah yes, the alleged "true natives", none of which can be found nor named. The region is not being "destroyed forever" it is being refounded to make sure people like Defendingg don't claim it as a trophy for themselves.

So you admit that you are refounding it? Good to know.

What's wrong with the group that founded it refounding it?

Nitpick:

Noting the authors hopes that " that Hogwarts can maintain its history of being a free, open, and peaceful region in the spirit of the community" yet highlighting the authors own lack of community spirit in subsequently tarring the fate of this region by stating that "the invader culture of the Lone Wolves United is a threat to this hope,";

Delete the first "that" please (grammatical point), also an extraneous space between the opening quote marks and the second "that".

Evil Wolf aka Blue Wolf is clearly pulling strings in the North Pacific.

sham! sham! sham!

Clearly.

Evil Wolf wrote:Clearly.

without any doubt.

Beyond denial.

Evil Wolf wrote:Clearly.

Dude everyone knows your game you are always scheming to turn TNP more invader and this person writing is from TNP, so via consequence is influenced by your transparent and obvious machinations.

Clearly.

Beyond denial.

Through The Breach wrote:Dude everyone knows your game you are always scheming to turn TNP more invader and this person writing is from TNP, so via consequence is influenced by your transparent and obvious machinations.

Yes, everyone is well aware of how I have all 5,177 nations of The North Pacific firmly in my back pocket.

Evil Wolf wrote:

Through The Breach wrote:Dude everyone knows your game you are always scheming to turn TNP more invader and this person writing is from TNP, so via consequence is influenced by your transparent and obvious machinations.

Yes, everyone is well aware of how I have all 5,177 nations of The North Pacific firmly in my back pocket.

Bro just hurry up and try to refound Hogwarts already.

You're sitting on that thing like a constipated man on a toilet.

I'm ready to beat you.

go! go! go!

Through The Breach wrote:

Evil Wolf wrote:
Yes, everyone is well aware of how I have all 5,177 nations of The North Pacific firmly in my back pocket.

Bro just hurry up and try to refound Hogwarts already.

You're sitting on that thing like a constipated man on a toilet.

I'm ready to beat you.

go! go! go!

I'm calling it now. After the resolution fails, he will go ahead and put a password in. How TITO cannot see this is beyond me.

Unless of course one of the main delegates is waiting to pull a funny and flip the vote at the last minute.

He can password because he isn't man enough to go toe to toe, but we can still snatch it if they ever try to refound.

He will just hide behind the password though until people get bored and do it when no one is looking.

If he had balls he would announce the refound date and let us race, but he knows he can't beat us fair and square so he hides in the shadows like a Wolf man.

Ah, so you both seem to be implying that this whole liberation thing really has nothing to do with the wants of anonymous "true natives" and more to do with a personal grudge against me. You've more or less confirmed that this is about the two of you "winning" and not about the rights of Hogwarts or its natives.

Evil Wolf wrote:Ah, so you both seem to be implying that this whole liberation thing really has nothing to do with the wants of anonymous "true natives" and more to do with a personal grudge against me. You've more or less confirmed that this is about the two of you "winning" and not about the rights of Hogwarts or its natives.

They aren't anonymous you mushroom face, one of them posted in the main thread.

Get your facts right.

TEP: 1
SC: 0

Abacathea wrote:Just to be on the safe side, it's quite a close vote, feedback appreciated as always.

REPEAL "LIBERATE HOGWARTS"
Category: Repeal | Resolution: SC #X

---

The Security Council

Denouncing the use of SC #X as a weapon against the current government of Hogwarts;

Highlighting the contradictory language used by the resolution author who on one hand acknowledges the reincarnation of this region once again, yet laments those who would refound it;

Sickened that such a proposal would be utilized against a region simply because of whom has chosen to resurrect it as opposed to any other rational;

Appalled that this resolution was passed without any true consultation with the native population, wherein to do so would not have resulted in the passage of this resolution in a manner which has clearly divided the international community;

Noting the authors hopes that " that Hogwarts can maintain its history of being a free, open, and peaceful region in the spirit of the community" yet highlighting the authors own lack of community spirit in subsequently tarring the fate of this region by stating that "the invader culture of the Lone Wolves United is a threat to this hope,";

Desirous to ensure that the purposes and ideals of this esteemed Council are not subverted to the prejudices of its members against ideologies and utilized for the purposes of undermining any group without some shred of evidence to their intent;

Hereby;
Repeals SC #X, Liberate Hogwarts

Point by point:

1. How is it a weapon?

2. What is the contradiction? You don't explain it you just say it is.

3. Um... whom does matter. If a Nazi shows up at your bat mitzvah I think you are going to care about that more than if it is some random person. Whom always matters, if an invader refounds - bad. If a native refounds - good. This 'whom' argument is weak.

4. Natives were consulted, so this is a lie. Proctos is a native and Gryffidor was against the Lone Wolves United occupation - see his RMB posts. So you lie lie pants on fire.

5. WTF does this even mean? "Lack of community spirit"? They are invaders, they destroyed and purged a community that was trying to refound and protect itself, this section of the proposal is barking mad.

6. Um, they clearly said they are going to refound, so we do have evidence of their intent. They are a condemned group already by the SC council, and again whom matters and that shows what kind of people they are. So you fail pretty hard there. Secondly, nothing was subverted. And thirdly, how much is Blue Wolf paying you to write this?

Full support for the repeal. It's a shame that the resolution passed in the first place.

Cormac A Stark wrote:Full support for the repeal. It's a shame that the resolution passed in the first place.

Yes, such a shame that a region that has been invaded, griefed and purged be given a fighting chance to survive.

Such a shame such a shame.

Wait no, THIS proposal is a shame.

There we go.

I doubt Lone Wolves United and supporting forces have any intention of abandoning Hogwarts to "defender" invaders and faux "natives." Seen Anarchy lately? Your liberation resolution does not mean that you've won.

Cormac A Stark wrote:I doubt Lone Wolves United and supporting forces have any intention of abandoning Hogwarts to "defender" invaders and faux "natives." Seen Anarchy lately? Your liberation resolution does not mean that you've won.

lol you don't refute my points you just confirm you are invading the region and want to "win"

nice job Cormac

the only faux natives are evil wolf and his band of invader agents

Cormac A Stark wrote:I doubt Lone Wolves United and supporting forces have any intention of abandoning Hogwarts to "defender" invaders and faux "natives." Seen Anarchy lately? Your liberation resolution does not mean that you've won.

But it does complicate efforts to refound the region. Also, if LWU troops have to be deployed to Hogwarts, that keeps other regions that may have been raided safe as well.

Defendingg wrote:Also, if LWU troops have to be deployed to Hogwarts, that keeps other regions that may have been raided safe as well.

Evil Wolf starts planning a raid immediately.

Evil Wolf wrote:

Defendingg wrote:Also, if LWU troops have to be deployed to Hogwarts, that keeps other regions that may have been raided safe as well.

Evil Wolf starts planning a raid immediately.

And I'll show you 15-20 nations who will not be joining you.