[PASSED] Nuclear Power Safety Act

[Damanucus]

Although the necessity of this act may not appear to some, it is clear that measures regarding nuclear weapons are quite serious and that this measure is clearly in favor of protecting the members of the WA. Approved, and strongly recommended that you do the same.

This is about nuclear power, not nuclear weapons.

[United Dependencies]

It seems to be a little too vague as far as actual standards go. I'm not sure if I want just a committee being in charge of standards and regulation. Opposed (for now)

[Silvadus]

I just don't see why this is necessary. This act makes it sound like countries tend to be reckless and just sit around in their own radioactive filth. Unless I am convinced that this act could prevent something that could be of international consequences, I will remain opposed. Otherwise it should be up to states to decide how to regulate this.

There have been instances of nuclear power plants that have not followed proper regulations and as such there have been consequence; this if often due to the underestimation of the potential hazards of nuclear power. Nuclear disasters and waste can have effects internationally, such has radiation crossing the border which could harm people and the environment. Along with that there are both international economic and political consequences for nuclear power plants that are not properly maintained. Nuclear meltdowns can cause major economic downfall, especially if a state is dependent on it.

It seems to be a little too vague as far as actual standards go. I'm not sure if I want just a committee being in charge of standards and regulation. Opposed (for now)

It's vague so as to allow the committee to make standards based off their own experience and what is known at present among the internal community of nuclear power safety. What would you suggest other than a committee?

[Glenn]

There have been instances of nuclear power plants that have not followed proper regulations and as such there have been consequence; this if often due to the underestimation of the potential hazards of nuclear power. Nuclear disasters and waste can have effects internationally, such has radiation crossing the border which could harm people and the environment. Along with that there are both international economic and political consequences for nuclear power plants that are not properly maintained. Nuclear meltdowns can cause major economic downfall, especially if a state is dependent on it.

I will research your claims and then come back with a response. Or if anyone wants to provide such research, I will read it.

[Silvadus]

I have resubmitted this proposal. If there are any suggestions for improving the proposal please do post them.

[Canadian Davsland]

I am against Nuclear power.

[South Titania]

Has my approval. No harm in letting a few wise old men control man's penchant for messing with the limits of Nuclear power.

[Silvadus]

The following changes have been made to the draft:

MANDATES the following for nations:
I. Take prime responsibility for risks caused by exposure to radiation while handling radioactive material for the purpose of nuclear power,
II. Establish procedures and arrangements to maintain safety and stability while operating nuclear power plants,
III. Have safety measures in place to prevent or have arrangements to deal with exposure to radiation while handling radioactive material,
IV. Follow adequate building designs for the construction of nuclear power plant facilities,
V. Establish proper regulations for facilities and activities dealing with the handling of radioactive materials for the purpose of generating power,
VI. Enforce regulations placed upon nuclear facilities and attempt to pass legislation to better the safety of said nuclear facilities,

[Libraria and Ausitoria]

MANDATES the following for nations:

What about if the precise details have been devolved to other parties, for instance local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations?

[Silvadus]

MANDATES the following for nations:

What about if the precise details have been devolved to other parties, for instance local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations?

The WA has no authority over such entities.

[Libraria and Ausitoria]

What about if the precise details have been devolved to other parties, for instance local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations?

The WA has no authority over such entities.

Then why are you mandating that member nations exercise powers and responsibilities they may not have?

[Silvadus]

Those mandates are simply a goal for nations to attempt to reach and for the NESC when evaluating nuclear power plants and facilities.

[Flibbleites]

Those mandates are simply a goal for nations to attempt to reach and for the NESC when evaluating nuclear power plants and facilities.

If you only have to attempt to fulfill the mandate, it's not really much of a mandate now is it?

Bob Flibble
WA Representative

[Puan Puri Naduk]

The WA has no authority over such entities.

Then why are you mandating that member nations exercise powers and responsibilities they may not have?

Not sure what you are talking about. The Author is correct in that the WA only has power over member nations and nothing else. Resolution text can only hold member nations responsible. From there on, it is up to the member nations to enforce the rules on "local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations" that operate within member nations. I see nothing wrong with the resolution.

[Moronist Decisions]

Since member nations are responsible for their power stations, what is the purpose of the committee precisely? I'd be uncomfortable with gnomes being responsible for all safety inspections and pawing over all our power stations.

[Lord Absinthe]

We feel that with a little refinement we could support this proposal.
As it is late her in the Republic, I shall wait till I have rested before making on comment on the meat of the propasal to avoid
making any embaressing mistakes

Ambassador Decado
Democratic Republic of Lord Absinthe

[Silvadus]

Those mandates are simply a goal for nations to attempt to reach and for the NESC when evaluating nuclear power plants and facilities.

If you only have to attempt to fulfill the mandate, it's not really much of a mandate now is it?

Bob Flibble
WA Representative

Very true, I worded that poorly. The NESC will attempt to work with nations in order to better their conditions to meet the mandates.

[Jefferson and Paul]

Do you know how many inspectors, employees and the amount GA Funds it would take to inspect even a small fraction of the Member Nations' nuclear plants?

[Libraria and Ausitoria]

Then why are you mandating that member nations exercise powers and responsibilities they may not have?

Not sure what you are talking about. The Author is correct in that the WA only has power over member nations and nothing else. Resolution text can only hold member nations responsible. From there on, it is up to the member nations to enforce the rules on "local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations" that operate within member nations. I see nothing wrong with the resolution.

We have no wish to take prime responsibility for the acts of individuals, local governments, companies, foreign powers, or supranational organizations operating within our nation.

[Dwarfington]

I oppose, my nation uses nuclear power as its primary source of energy, and industry is the number 1 priority to the nations economy and society, the environment is something that dwarfington is always willing to sacrifice if there is money to be made from natural resources.

[Stalltopia]

I oppose, my nation uses nuclear power as its primary source of energy, and industry is the number 1 priority to the nations economy and society, the environment is something that dwarfington is always willing to sacrifice if there is money to be made from natural resources.

This resolution is not talking about putting limits on mining. It is addressing the safety of the facilities themselves. And as far as we can see inspectors will only be offering suggestions for improvement to safety based on their findings in the best interest of helping a nation without controlling it.

The nation of Stalltopia is currently for this bill, but before we approve it we feel we must bring the issue up with the other nations of the Newera Empire whom we represent.

[The Grand Duchy of Muscovy]

The Grand Duchy of Muscovy is for this proposal as we feel that nuclear power plants are a danger everyone in the area, but are simple too important to some nations power situation to not be used and so need firm regulations and people to inforce them.

[BORDURIAA WA NATION]

Stringent Safety standards for Nucleur power is a must. The Agency has been formed to set safety standards, not ban nucleur energy. Nucleur accidents can be devastating and hence this bill is required.
Approved.

[Sanctaria]

Well this snuck up on me ... how in God's name did it reach quorum?!

Regardless, I don't see anything immediately questionable so ... tentatively in support.

[JonathanAtopia]

I think it is a good resulation to protect our people I approve