[DRAFT] Repeal "Condemn The Black Riders"

[Stuzemstazem WA Mission]

Confirming that The Black Riders have invaded and raided thousands of regions

However Noting that the condemnation imposed on The Black Riders does not serve its purpose, stopping the Black Riders from raiding.

Also Noting that the Black Riders use the condemnation imposed on them as a "badge", and benefit from it by showing other regions how great they are at what they do.

Understanding that removing the condemnation imposed on TBR will be best for the WA.

Also Understanding that removing the condemnation will remove what TBR consider "a badge"

Hereby repeals "Condemn the Black Riders"

[DWAsnia]

Confirming that The Black Riders have invaded and raided thousands of regions

However Noting that the condemnation imposed on The Black Riders does not serve its purpose, stopping the Black Riders from raiding.

Also Noting that the Black Riders use the condemnation imposed on them as a "badge", and benefit from it by showing other regions how great they are at what they do.

Understanding that removing the condemnation imposed on TBR will be best for the WA.

Also Understanding that removing the condemnation will remove what TBR consider "a badge"

Weak, but we definitely ought to repeal their first (horribly written) condemn. But your draft lacks an operative clause - the Hereby Repeals bit that's at the end of every resolution.

[Stuzemstazem]

Hmmm.

[Nordenwald]

nope

[Nephmir]

Confirming that The Black Riders have invaded and raided thousands of regions

However Noting that the condemnation imposed on The Black Riders does not serve its purpose, stopping the Black Riders from raiding.

Also Noting that the Black Riders use the condemnation imposed on them as a "badge", and benefit from it by showing other regions how great they are at what they do.

Understanding that removing the condemnation imposed on TBR will be best for the WA.

Also Understanding that removing the condemnation will remove what TBR consider "a badge"

Weak, but we definitely ought to repeal their first (horribly written) condemn. But your draft lacks an operative clause - the Hereby Repeals bit that's at the end of every resolution.

That was already repealed, if I am not mistaken.

[RiderSyl]

Weak, but we definitely ought to repeal their first (horribly written) condemn.

That was already repealed.

This is just an attempt to remove a condemnation because the residents of that condemned region don't take it seriously.
If that is grounds for a repeal, you might as well repeal every condemnation.

[Ynys Prydain]

This is just an attempt to remove a condemnation because the residents of that condemned region don't take it seriously.
If that is grounds for a repeal, you might as well repeal every condemnation.

Pretty much this. The Black Riders are as deserving as any region of condemnation, and more deserving than some. Plus you can't repeal my best SC resolution.

[Stuzemstazem WA Mission]

TBR use it to their advantage.

[Chester Pearson]

TBR use it to their advantage.

I would sure as the hell hope so....

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Amazing. You've actually managed to write a resolution that is worse than your "Commend The Rejected Realms".

This is poorly written, shoddily researched and inaccurate.

[RiderSyl]

TBR use it to their advantage.

No, we don't.

[Nordenwald]

We should commend TBR.


/sarcasm

[Cora II]

Good Idea. After repealing TBR's condemnation effectively:

1) WA-SC Condemnations there after have no idea or reasons to exist
2) We (TBR) get finally rid of all those accusations concerning our 'Crimes' against regions we raid
3) Maybe finally We get also rid of that childish and always not too PG-13 criticisms directed toward us
4) After crashing and ruining thousands and thousands regions we can be sure that if our core activity is not considered condemnworthy, then there are no such things at all in NS
5) Logical conclusion from that would be that whole C/C institution is rendered totally meaningless and should be abandoned as a non-essential and time consuming extra load for the World Assembly apparatus
6) If Raiding is not Considered Condemnworthy, and when so, then Defending is not Commendworthy either
7) Raiders can be finally Commended for what they are good at.

Maybe natives could then learn make their nativedoms safe by themselves... Just maybe.

NOTE: C/C badges doesn't make any difference to the practice of raiding Activity.

[Bhang Bhang Duc]

Cora,

Your note right at the bottom of your post is something the author seems to have not understood in his proposal.

[Redsward]

TBR use it to their advantage.

No, we don't.

Syl's right. Just because they see it as a "badge of honor" doesn't mean that they use it to their advantage.

[Avron Wolves]

Not to completely rehash what everyone else has posted or anything, but to repeal TBR's condemnation would there for open a window to repeal very other condemned region's condemnation. And sure, we take great pride in the fact so much time and effort has been spent on behalf of the security council to smack TBR on the wrist (if even....), but we don't nessicarily use the condemnation to our advantage. At the most, stand on the roof and brag about it. But that's not taking advantage of it. So I fail to see how this proposal would profit the goals of the Security Council. In fact, I think it would cause implication that would only benefit TBR. So either way...
On addition, this proposal was fairly poorly written to begin with, so I'm assuming not much research went into it. Said already, but I feel the need to repeat what everyone else has basicly said here.

[Philjia]

You have missed the point of a condemnation. Dedicated raiders will not stop for anyone, but a condemnation will mark them out as dangerous, making recognition of raiders, and defence from said, easier. This policy should be enforced on all raiders, even the now legendary Black Riders.